Skip to main content

In defense of not reviewing food

A food writer leans away from traditional food critiques.
  • Author:
  • Updated:

Over a recent dinner with a couple of local food critics, I said that food criticism might very well be anachronistic. Played out. Done-zo.

My companions were James Norton and Becca Dilley, founders of Heavy Table, a respected online magazine about Upper Midwest food scene and traditions.

Norton did not immediately plunge a steak knife into my arm, and even conceded that I might be onto something. But still, he clings to criticism. You can read his four-point blog "In Defense of Reviewing Food" here

I agree with some of his points. Especially: “A good working critic has likely eaten at thousands of restaurants in dozens of cities, at all price points, and at locations from gas stations to chef’s tables.”

I’d add that working a decade-plus as a professional cook, caterer, and chef lends me an added layer of street cred as a professional critic. And still, I’ve opted to lean away from traditional food critiques at this point in my career.

Here’s why I’ll leave criticism to others for now. Call it my 4:44 to their Lemonade.

Everyone’s a critic now

Really. Professional reviews (on any topic) are no longer our only source. Before YouTube, food TV, Yelp, and Instagram took hold, Dara Moskowitz’s weekly City Pages column evaluating restaurants and highlighting new openings was essential. To know how to make pasta puttanesca, I forked over $29.95 for Lynne Rossetto Kasper’s latest cookbook. Resources for any town's finest gourmet ice cream cone or the best flour for making hand-pulled noodles are now available at the flick of a thumb. 

For the first time in history, Americans are eating out more than they are eating in. For many, eating out is now a daily endeavor, not a wait-until-the-weekend treat. And everyone's reporting back on what they experienced. The average 20-year-old is posting opinions about what is or isn't good nearly as often as a posh food writer.Every eater can consider herself a critic, and does – whether the professionals like it or not.

Even if something is bad, it can still be interesting

At its core, food is sustenance and cooking is an offering (whether to oneself or others). Cooking is a highly personal, vulnerable endeavor, and when reduced to “good” or “bad” that vulnerability becomes heightened. Sure, when a service is offered in exchange for a (often very high) price that service is fair game for critique. 

Still, whether or not something is good, bad, or worth the price is only part of the story. The story I’m more interested in is the “why?” Why did someone endeavor to cook this food in the first place? Quality aside, there’s a story behind every plate, no matter how simple. I want to tell the story of the why, rather than the bite-by-bite commentary and pictorial provided by... everyone (see above).

Not everyone dines, but everyone eats

The more time I spend with food as a career, the less interesting the eating part of the equation becomes. Don’t get me wrong. I love to eat. I came by this career honestly. But the more I do it, the more I realize that a cheap hot dog on a slightly stale bun can be just as satisfying (sometimes more so) than the most elaborate tasting dinner at a high-priced restaurant. 

How do I reconcile that? And moreover, the guy who served that dog to me might have a more interesting story than the veteran chef. So food criticism, while certainly worthwhile, may be beside the point in an ever-expanding conversation around food and eating. Eating is the sole common denominator among all humans. That’s why we’re all inherently interested in it. And while I (or you) may not have a hundred bucks for a tasting menu, we’ll all almost always have enough cash for that dog. Let’s talk about the hot dog instead of the tasting menu for awhile.

Food criticism still matters... sorta 

Here’s the truth: lots of people only care to read about food right before hiring a babysitter for a Saturday night out. In which case, they deserve to know ahead of time whether or not something is worth the fuss. Lots of people are never going to pick up a copy of Lucky Peach (RIP) or debate the virtues of Shake Shack vs. McDonald’s. 

Can that new place on Eat Street top the couch, Game of Thrones, and a pizza? For those people, there is Heavy Table-style food criticism that James Norton defends. But these days, I want to go beyond the salt on the meat. I want to know who killed the cow and why we like tenderloin more than liver. I want to write about the room where the meat was served, and about the whole wide world of food that produces the meat. Although I might occasionally comment on there being too much, too little, or sometimes the perfect amount of salt.

Mecca Bos is a Twin Cities-based food writer. She has an upcoming podcast called Snax Everywhere. Find her on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter.

Next Up


NWS: 'Safe to say' more active weather is ahead

Three rounds of light snow around Minnesota before more substantial precipitation becomes a possibility.


Hero dad who stopped carjacker who fled with his kids identified

A GoFundMe has been set up to support Derek Gotchie and his family following the incident.

Screen Shot 2022-12-03 at 4.35.18 PM

Watch: New London-Spicer wins 3A championship on incredible walk-off TD

New London-Spicer defeated the unbeaten Dilworth-Glyndon-Felton in remarkable circumstances.


Suspect in woman's killing in Moorhead is arrested

James Kollie Jr. was arrested Friday evening.

Jennifer Carnahan

Former chair Jennifer Carnahan sues Minnesota GOP, which is suing her back

Carnahan stepped down under a cloud of controversy in August 2021.

Minneapolis Fire Department

One injured after leaping from burning vacant building in Minneapolis

Authorities say the building is known to be used by squatters.


Head-on crash leaves two drivers dead in southeastern Minnesota

The crash happened in Houston County just before 4 p.m. Friday.


Charges: Armed man made death threats at Minneapolis LGBTQ bar

The man allegedly used derogatory terms while threatening to kill someone.


FDA pulls last COVID-19 monoclonal antibody treatment as new variants rise

A therapy used to treat more than 11,000 Minnesotans is no longer authorized amid a surge in the latest COVID-19 variants.

Austin Robert LeClaire

Charges: Plymouth man shot girlfriend in head after birthday party

The 23-year-old victim is in critical condition as of Friday.


State announces $2.5M in grants for child care providers

Child care providers in roughly a dozen communities will receive funds to help grow the supply of affordable, quality child care.


5 barbecue dishes you can (mostly) only get in Minnesota

A wealth of different global traditions – from Scandinavia to Asia to Oklahoma – inspire our local fare.

Gohan's pop-up sushi bar is primed for Instagram

It's smaller than a restaurant, but not quite fit for a food truck.

7 foods to grab at Twin Cities farmers markets now

Local produce does all the heavy lifting in the kitchen during harvest season.

Ranked: The 10 weirdest foods at Hy-Vee

Brownie batter hummus is just the beginning of the oddities within.

5 best classic Minnesota State Fair foods

This is the stuff that you crave before you even enter the gate.

Twin Cities burger lovers, meet the Stray Dog

As the Bulldog Northeast rebrands under new ownership, the local burger gets a new chapter.

We tasted 8 pumpkin spice foods so you don't have to

This autumnal haul ranges from spooky to superb.

5 hidden-gem foods at the Minnesota State Fair

Here are some surprisingly tasty options you might have missed.