Skip to main content

Stillwater BBQ joint featured on Food Network is closing

Owner confirms Smalley's Caribbean BBQ and Pirate Bar is being forced out its current location.

Two years ago, the Food Network declared some of the finest barbecue in the country could be had at Smalley's Caribbean Barbeque and Pirate Bar in Stillwater. But not much longer.

Owner Shawn Smalley confirmed on Thursday to the Stillwater Current that a "conflict about the lease" will lead to the space closing after this weekend. News of the potential closing first circulated in a Wednesday afternoon report from Eater Twin Cities.

“I didn’t want this to happen,” Smalley told the Stillwater Current. “I’m f*****g pissed off, and I’m really sad. This is not how I wanted it to end.”

The pirate-themed diner known for its Jamaican jerk barbecue is housed in a building (at 423 Main Street South) that's under new ownership, Eater said. 

A few days ago, restaurant owners learned they would have to close for "unspecified reasons."

Smalley's has been a popular dining spot in Stillwater since its opening in 2008. It's the brainchild of chef Shawn Smalley and Tim McKee, the James Beard Award winning chef who once ran La Belle Vie – where Eater says Smalley once worked.

The eatery has been featured on the Food Network four times, including on an episode Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives where hostGuy Fieri braved a basket of fiery "666 Wings" containing an ingredient Chef Smalley calls "death juice."

Besides flaming hot chicken, the restaurant also serves up smoked meats, seafood, jerk tacos, and a mac and cheese that will be sorely missed by many.

This guy claims the last chance to sample the menu is Saturday:

Next Up

northbound remodel facebook

Northbound brewpub reopens with new look, revamped menu

It had been closed since October for the big remodel.

Snow, Hanley Falls

Latest storm track, snow forecast for weekend winter storm

The National Weather Service has issued a winter storm watch.

gianni's wayzata heated patio

These Twin Cities restaurants have heated patios for outdoor winter dining

From bonfires to igloos, Twin Cities restaurants have you covered as temperatures drop.

Kirill Kaprizov

Kirill Kaprizov's slow start is a thing of the past

A potential sophomore slump has been erased with a three-point night against the Devils..

mpd aldi incident screengrab

Video shows MPD officer grab, throw Aldi customer

The department says the matter was referred to the Office of Police Conduct Review.

US Sec Defense Flickr - Joe Bide Nov 11 2021

Biden lays out wintertime plan to curb COVID's spread

It comes as the U.S. reported its second case of the omicron variant.

Willow River DOC

MN Dept. of Corrections offering $5K bonuses as it seeks to hire 200

The DOC is offering hiring bonuses for new employees and for referrals.


Caribbean Smokehouse Stillwater

Stillwater restaurant says its temporary closure is now permanent

Caribbean Smokehouse closed in November, and won't be re-opening.

Screen Shot 2019-07-26 at 12.29.06 PM

Stillwater bar with prominent patio closes after 3 years

Lion's Tavern is permanently closed, its owners have announced.

Screen Shot 2020-01-16 at 8.28.54 AM

Ike's Food and Cocktails closes in downtown Minneapolis

It still has locations in Bloomington and Minnetonka, as well as stadium and airport satellite locations.