Skip to main content

New York Times raises eyebrows with its tater tot hotdish recipe

We have a lot of questions. Number 1: How dare you.

The New York Times* has continued its passion for trampling over beloved Minnesota institutions by having a go at arguably its most famous food: tater tot hotdish.

As you might expect, the New York Times' take on the Midwest classic has raised more than a few eyebrows among Minnesota's extremely understanding social media users.

It seemingly tries to escape condemnation by wrongly calling the dish "Tater tot casserole," only for writer Sam Sifton to make the rookie mistake of referring to it as "hot dish" in the first sentence.

The main crime in the recipe? It doesn't contain any canned "Cream of..." soup, instead tasking cooks to make the soup from scratch using bouillon or broth base – which seems to somewhat defeat the purpose of hotdish, namely that it's simple.

*We have linked to the NYT's recipe at the top of this story but we urge you not to click, it'll only encourage them. 

Speaking of simple, the classic tater tot hotdish rarely uses anything more than 5 ingredients (tots, soup, meat, a vegetable or two, sometimes cheese for topping) plus seasoning. The NYT's example? It has 11.

The recipe originally came from Molly Yeh, the food and lifestyle blogger who moved from Brooklyn, New York, to a farm in East Grand Forks, Minnesota.

We're certainly not averse from any Minnesotan from modifying a tater tot hotdish to their own particular taste – such as by making your own soup.

Find the latest recipes from BMTN's food writer Lindsay Guentzel

But from what we can tell, this is the only recipe for tater tot hotdish in the NYT's venerable food section, so for it to deviate from the tried and tested formula is somewhat of a shame, albeit in a completely unsurprising way. 

The grape salad fiasco of 2014 (wow, so long ago) is the obvious example of the NYT screwing up Minnesota, but also last year it suggested using American cheese for the filling of a Jucy Lucy burger, while its political editor got in trouble for suggesting Minneapolis isn't a part of the Midwest.

Like we said, Midwest Twitter took this latest recipe as well as can be expected.

Next Up


Ticket details released for 5-week run of 'Hamilton' in Minneapolis

The tour of the production has been delayed twice due to the pandemic.


Minnesota Board of Pharmacy files lawsuit against 3 THC edible retailers

The board has received 46 complaints in the past four months regarding the products.

Screen Shot 2022-12-05 at 2.53.55 PM

ATF now investigating fire at Lyndale Avenue apartment building

It was the second fire at a vacant building owned by the same landlord that was being used by squatters in the past few months.


Let the good times roll

Minnesota Roller Derby is back!


Beloved restaurant in southeastern MN to close after 40 years

A final night of celebrations is scheduled for Dec. 17.


MN town shelves ordinance allowing residents to sue abortion providers

Attorney General Keith Ellison advised the town to not go forward with the ordinance.

Spring Street Tavern

Man shot dead inside Minneapolis tavern is identified

The suspect is being held on probable cause murder.

Red Hot Chili Peppers

Red Hot Chili Peppers, The Strokes to play U.S. Bank Stadium in 2023

The Strokes will provide support along with King Princess.

Mall of America exterior Tyler Vigen Wikimedia COmmons

Settlement reached between MOA, family of boy thrown from balcony

The boy suffered multiple injuries that required several surgeries.

Pixabay - police crime tape do not cross stock

Body found in burned out car near Bird Island

The Renville County Sheriff's Office is investigating.


The New York Times finds a new way to enrage Minnesota

An editor found himself in hot water over his claim of what constitutes "The Midwest."

What the New York Times had to say about the State Fair

There was no repeat of grape salad-gate, you'll be glad to hear.

Screen Shot 2020-08-14 at 10.27.38 AM

Recipe: Banana pancakes perfect for weekend brunch

BMTN's Lindsay Guentzel shares her gluten-free banana pancake recipe.


Recipe: Loaded veggie chili with scratch black beans

Want a meatless meal option? Try this loaded chili recipe from Lindsay Guentzel.

5 chili recipes

5 chili recipes from MN food bloggers to help beat the cold

These five chili recipes are perfect for the long winter ahead.