Politifact weighs in on the Minnesota-Wisconsin 'who has more lakes' debate

It comes after a Wisconsin's new tourism secretary claimed they have Minnesota beat.
Publish date:

Forget holding the power in D.C. to account, Politifact finally has something meaningful to sink its teeth into: The Minnesota vs. Wisconsin debate.

The fact-checking website has turned its attention to our Midwestern rivalry thanks to a statement made earlier this month by Wisconsin's new Tourism Secretary, Sara Meaney.

Speaking to WTMJ radio, Meaney said: "Wisconsin, many people may not be aware, actually has 15,000 freshwater lakes."

"More than Minnesota," she added at the prompting of the host. "Absolutely. We win. We win."

Seriously ... we're gonna go there?

You can read the full Politifact article here, but the verdict was that Meaney's statement was "False."

How can that be, considering the Wisconsin DNR claims Wisconsin has 15,074 lakes, while the Minnesota DNR says Minnesota has 11,842.

Well I could claim to have the dashing good looks of George Clooney and the erudite wit of Oscar Wilde, but that doesn't make it true.

But seriously, Politifact found that the main reason for the "False" rating is the respective states' definition of lakes.

Minnesota, for example, calls a lake a lake when the body of water is greater than 10 acres. Wisconsin on the other hand defines a lake as "anything it feels like calling a lake," Politifact notes.

Minnesota has standards, basically.

Sign up: Subscribe to our daily newsletters

It notes that thousands of Wisconsin's "lakes" are less than 10 acres, and 60 percent of the 15,074 don't even have a name.

The puddle of tears from Packers fans when they finished 3rd in the NFC North last year? That's a lake.

If Wisconsin was to use Minnesota's standard definition of a lake, it would only have 5,898, little over half as many as Minnesota.

Politifact also looked at data from the U.S. Geological Survey.

Screen Shot 2019-05-24 at 9.09.09 AM

In summary, Politifact concluded that if the 10-acre standard is applied – "or really any other reasonable metric – Minnesota has about twice as many lakes."

Nice try, Wisconsin, but we're called the Land of 10,000 Lakes for a reason.

Next Up

Guy Fieri

MN brewpub to make 2nd appearance on 'Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives'

In other words, Guy Fieri is returning to the Twin Cities.

Screen Shot 2020-06-15 at 7.11.05 AM

St. Cloud teen charged with raping girl in high school bathroom

Police say it happened during a late 2019 basketball game.


Reports: 'Miracle on Ice' star Mark Pavelich found dead at treatment facility

The 63-year-old had been ordered to undergo psychiatric care.

hennepin county government center fencing minneapolis chauvin

Minneapolis, Hennepin County spending $1M on barricades, fencing for Chauvin trial

Minneapolis hopes to be reimbursed for fortification costs by the state if it passes the proposed SAFE Account.

police lights

Police: 3 Minnesotans made fake report to divert SD police away drug investigation

Three people from Detroit Lakes are facing charges, with two of the men involved accused of making a false report of gunmen entering a local business.

Drive-up vaccine

HealthPartners opens drive-up COVID vaccine site

The healthcare provider says it's the first drive-up vaccination site in the state.

derek chauvin

Appeals court: Judge must reconsider third-degree murder charge against Chauvin

The appeals court's recent decision on a different officer-involved shooting case is precedent, it said.

covid-19, vaccine

New data reveals Minnesotans getting COVID vaccines are disproportionately white

The Minnesota Department of Health revealed race and ethnicity vaccine data on Friday.


Wisconsin has 12 of America's 'drunkest' cities, Minnesota has 1

Wisconsin once again ranks highly for binge drinking.

Minnesotans respond to Wisconsin plot to steal our lakes

Things have been getting very silly online this week.

Screen Shot 2019-04-30 at 9.59.02 AM

The 'Save Lake Calhoun' website now has a very different message

It comes a day after a court ruled its name change was illegal.

lake, water

Woman, 71, drowns in northwest Wisconsin lake

It happened just across the border in Wisconsin, south of Duluth.

There's no sign of ice-out on Minnesota lakes

This time last year, most lakes in southern Minnesota had declared ice-outs.

Gallery: Home on the St. Croix has its own tram down to the shore

The unusual feature comes with this 5-bedroom property in River Falls.

Grand View Lodge to add boutique hotel to Gull Lake resort

It claims it would make it Minnesota's largest resort.