Skip to main content

Star Tribune movie critic resigns after accusation of plagiarism

Colin Covert had been with the newspaper for more than 30 years.

The Star Tribune has announced that its movie critic, Colin Covert, has left the newspaper after more than 30 years after some of his reviews were found to have copied the work of others.

Editor Rene Sanchez and managing editor Suki Dardarian said in a letter posted on the Star Tribune website Monday evening that they had found several examples of Covert's work using the same language as writers for other outlets, without attribution.

They were initially informed of the possible plagiarism by a reader, who noticed Covert had incorporated a "unique phrase" used by the late New Yorker critic Pauline Kael into a 2009 review he wrote of the movie "Nine."

This phrase – "self-glorifying masochistic mush" – had been used by Kael in a 1974 review of a UK version of "The Little Prince."

Covert's "Nine" review also included several more phrases that Kael had used, while further examination of his work led to the newspaper finding eight more reviews that contained phrases previously used in the New York Times, Paste Magazine,, The Wall Street Journal, IndieWire, and Hollywood Reporter.

The most recent of these apparent plagiarisms appeared in a Nov. 1 review of "Can You Ever Forgive Me?" 

The Star Tribune says it is removing all of Covert's work from its website, and will also be informing the wire services and syndicates that have been using his reviews.

Sign up: Subscribe to our daily newsletters

"In his long career at the Star Tribune, Covert has made many contributions to our cultural coverage," Sanchez and Dardarian wrote. "But this pattern of using distinct phrasing from other authors without attribution is a form of plagiarism and is a violation of our journalistic standards and ethics and those of our industry."

In the editors' statement, Covert admitted to his "blunders" and thanked the newspaper for affording him a career that "through its benefits safeguarded me through three serious health crises."

"I’m sorry to say that through too many mistakes over the last 30 years I have compromised the Star Tribune’s meticulous reputation for integrity," he added.

Next Up

Train Days

Historic locomotives to roll into St. Paul for Train Days

The festival at the Union Depot returns June 4-5.

Dalton tornado

Tornadoes, large hail, damaging wind possible in Sunday/Monday storms

The Twin Cities is among the areas that could get hit.

Redtail Ridge Elementary

Sunbather on the roof triggers shelter-in-place at Savage elementary school

The sunbather told police he was trying to "tan and relax."


The Raptor Center's ambassador, Nero the turkey vulture, dies at 47

Nero helped save the California condors before taking up his post as an education ambassador.

Ben Leber

Ben Leber named new permanent co-host of 'Twin Cities Live'

The former Minnesota Vikings linebacker was introduced Friday afternoon.


APM Reports, maker of 'In the Dark' podcast, nixed by Minnesota Public Radio

MPR said "select programming elements" of APM Reports will be incorporated into MPR News.

storm, severe

The latest on holiday weekend severe weather chances for MN

The most significant severe threats are Sunday night and again on Monday.

Arianna Vos

Charges: Driver was drunk, high in head-on crash that killed 19-year-old woman

The young woman killed in the crash was a college student studying zoology.


Star Tribune

Star Tribune gossip columnist C.J. leaving the newspaper

Over her years writing about local celebrities, C.J. built up a large following.

Star Tribune

Star Tribune food critic Rick Nelson is moving to a new beat

A nationwide search has been launched to find a replacement for the award-winning food critic.

City Pages

Fan creates City Pages archive, Star Tribune tells him to remove it

After word spread that the defunct newspaper's website would go down, a fan created his own copy. Then he got a cease and desist letter.

La Velle E. Neal III

Twins reporter La Velle E. Neal III to become Star Tribune sports columnist

The long-serving Twins reporter has received a promotion.


'Mystery reader' leaving vintage Star Tribune newspapers around town

The Strib says they've been found in their vending boxes.

Movie stars confirmed to attend Twin Cities Film Fest

The festival kicks off on Oct. 17 with a movie from one of the Farrelly brothers.

Amelia Rayno is leaving the Star Tribune after 8 years

The sports reporter turned food & drink writer will leave the newspaper next month.