Watch: Alexa, Google Home give wildly different snow forecasts

They gave totally different answers!
Author:
Publish date:

Can you really trust your smart devices to provide the most accurate weather forecast?

Bring Me The News digital guru W'Will Seng put Google Home and Amazon Alexa to the test, asking both how much snow is going to fall in Shakopee. The results aren't even close. 

Alexa tells him that Shakopee is in line for 5.1 inches of snow while Google comes back with an answer of 1.4 inches. 

The official National Weather Service forecast for Shakopee, at the time Seng asked the question, called for 3-5 inches of snow in Shakopee. That number has since gone up with the NWS adding the metro area to a winter storm warning, but you get the point. 

Where does each smart device get its weather data from?

According to Amazon, Alexa uses data from AccuWeather. It's not entirely clear where Google Assistant accesses weather data, but a Google search turned back results that suggest it uses The Weather Channel, Weather Underground and AccuWeather. 

Next Up

covid-19, coronavirus

Here is Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Wednesday, Jan. 27

The latest update from the state health department.

charley's

Charges: Bar owner, employee served underage drinkers during shutdown

The bar hosted 20-30 people on Dec. 4, 2020, charges say.

police lights

Driver wearing bulletproof vest strikes pedestrian in Rochester

The 21-year-old claimed the vest keeps him warm, according to police.

Screen Shot 2019-08-19 at 8.08.05 PM

6 men charged in connection to 'disturbing trend' of carjackings, shootings

The men are accused of three carjackings in one day, as well as other crimes.

YouTube TV, FSN

Report: Fox Sports North is becoming Bally Sports North

The rebranding will reportedly happen prior to the start of the MLB season.

walmart mask

Wisconsin Senate votes to end statewide mask mandate

The joint resolution now heads to the Republican-controlled state assembly.

P.J. Fleck

Looks like the Gophers can put Fleck-to-Tennessee rumors to rest

Fleck is annually a hot commodity when coaching jobs open up.

Matt Dumba

Wild drop front end of back-to-back with Kings

The Wild lost consecutive games for the first time this season.

Andrelton Simmons / Minnesota Twins

Twins sign Andrelton Simmons to one-year deal

The former Angels shortstop is a four-time Gold Glove winner.

Related

Old Farmer's Almanac releases winter forecast for Minnesota

They also believe El NiƱo will play a role in our weather.

More snow Tuesday, March forecast offers no winter relief

It's been 118 days since the Twin Cities hit 50 degrees.

snow, plow

Winter storm watch issued in advance of weekend snow

One way or another, this storm is going to hit hard in southern Minnesota.

Rain, snow in the forecast through Election Day

This weekend will be pretty miserable, and election day not much better.

Cold rain Friday-Sunday, watching snow chances for next week

Mixed precipitation will be possible in central and northern Minnesota.

snow, snowplow

Winter storm watch: Heaviest snow forecast to impact Twin Cities

The storm will bring impacts to much of Minnesota Thursday and Friday.

Sunday AM update: New snow totals forecast by the NWS

A slight uptick in expected snow totals for folks in the winter storm warning.