Skip to main content

An anonymous Reddit tale told by a first-time visitor to the Boundary Waters Canoe Area this week has sparked conversation online about proper campsite etiquette. 

The consensus? It's intrusive and a bit odd to roll up to a campsite where a group is already settled and set-up camp less than 10 feet away without a word. 

So, here's the story told on Reddit

Four women in their late 20s head up to the BWCA. They're enjoying their campsite when two women (presumably a mother and daughter) paddle up. 

"We say hello, with silence as a response," the Reddit writer tells. 

As the duo pulls into the campsite, they inquire about how many people are in the group and ask directions to the latrine. Upon returning from the latrine, they begin unloading and set up camp within 10 feet of the other site, the writer explains. 

"In the most Midwest way possible, one of the girls confronted them about their proximity to our campsite," the post reads. "They say that the site holds 9 (which is true) and they 'don’t care if we smoke weed or drink'. And that was that, they set up and stayed the night right next to us." 

Now, most BWCA campers agree severe weather, looming darkness and no availability to other campsites might be reasons to break social norms and settle in next to other campers. 

The Reddit author, however, said none of those conditions were present. It was a "perfect day", she writes, and tons of spots were available not more than two miles away. 

The post ends with a question: "Are we crazy for being upset? Is this totally cool behavior where in BWCA?" 

The top-voted reply offers this simple response: "Nope. Not cool. No No No." 

Further discussion ensued when the Reddit post made its way over to Twitter. 

Some Twitter users said the two women's behavior actually violated the permit rules — others said that wasn't exactly true. We reached out to the Superior National Forest for comment and here's what they said. 

"Camping in the BWCAW is first come first serve, there is no requirement for the number of parties per site as long as they don’t exceed the 9-person/4 watercraft per site," wrote Caroline Torkildson, a public affairs specialist. "We encourage all visitors to follow Leave No Trace principles, including 'be considerate of other visitors.'" 

So, after all, the fine print doesn't appear to speak directly to a situation like the Reddit story. But, pretty much everyone who replied online said it wasn't cool. 

"Next time I see a canoe go by with only 2 people, I’m gonna hop in the middle without a word," one Twitter reply stated. "When asked, I’ll be sure to let them know that their canoe technically holds 3 and that I don’t mind their rowing." 

Empowered by the internet's response, the original Reddit writer shared another update: 

"Had we had the knowledge this thread provided, on that day, we most certainly would have told them to keep paddling," the post reads. "I’m glad to know how to react next time, but by the sounds of it there won’t be a next time. All in all it was a fabulous trip, one of the best times of my life. We’ve already planned for this to be an annual trip. Not even camp intruders can ruin that." 

Next Up


SWAT presence in Eagan neighborhood Tuesday morning

There's a developing story out of Eagan.


Comedian claims hotel bed bug ruined his Twin Cities visit

The Hilton Garden Inn in downtown Minneapolis states otherwise.

Lindahl lawsuit

Kris Lindahl suing realtor, accusing him of copying arms out pose

The real estate agent is accused of breach of contract and copyright infringement.

Screen Shot 2022-08-16 at 8.44.12 AM

Pair wanted for questioning for assault, property crimes in Hugo

Surveillance footage was released by the Washington County Sheriff's Office.

Screen Shot 2022-08-11 at 2.49.44 PM

15,000 Minnesota nurses 'overwhelmingly' authorize strike

Overworked and underpaid, the Minnesota Nurses Association is ready to strike.

School dinners lunch

Minnesota to offer free school meals to 90,000 extra students

Gov. Tim Walz, who is facing re-election in November, announced the measure on Monday.


Minneapolis man dies from injuries days after motorcycle pileup

The 69-year-old died after four days at Regions Hospital.

Sebastion Wolbersen-O’Hara

Police: 15-year-old missing from home north of Twin Cities

Authorities say he may be headed to the metro.


Foundation, the building, the win

Identifying Value Plus Catalysts helps your financial strategy and foundation

boating minnesota lake

25-year-old Hopkins man drowns after falling off boat

The man reportedly fell from the boat while fishing with friends.

mayor frey city minneapolis live stream march 14 2022

What's in Mayor Jacob Frey's budget proposal?

Here's a breakdown of what the Minneapolis mayor is focusing on in 2023-24.


Pixabay - camp food fire

Bear sightings prompt food storage mandate up north

Visitors to the forest and BWCAW will be required to 'properly' store their food.

boundary waters

Parts of Boundary Waters closed near border due to wildfire threats

The closures will begin Saturday and last for at least seven days or until the situation is resolved.

boundary waters

Forest Service limiting permits to BWCAW due to damage, overcrowding

Visitors have been cutting down trees and have been forced to compete for campsites.

Flickr - campfire

No campfires allowed in BWCAW or Superior National Forest

The campfire ban applies to all campsites in the forest, including those in the BWCAW.


Study reveals what color lures walleye prefer

The best lure colors might depend on water conditions.

Facebook Bezhik Fire crop

Wildfire begins pushing out of Boundary Waters, toward private property

The fire is estimated to be more than 900 acres in size.

Flickr - Superior National Forest Boundary Waters

Forest Service closes off more of BWCA due to nearby wildfires

Officials are worried the Canadian fires could spread to the U.S.