Skip to main content

2 people plead guilty in fatal Dakota County home invasion

Two others charged in the incident will go to trial next year.
Timothy Tuit

Timothy Tuit

Two people have pleaded guilty in connection to a home invasion and death of a 55-year-old man in Greenvale Township in July. 

Timothy Tuit, 36, of South St. Paul, and Stephanie Marie Peabody, 25, of Welch, both pleaded guilty on Wednesday to aiding an offender in Chris Lafontaine's death, Dakota County Attorney Kathryn Keena said. 

“We are pleased that both Mr. Tuit and Ms. Peabody have taken responsibility for their respective roles in the senseless death of Mr. Lafontaine. Our deepest sympathy is extended to Mr. Lafontaine’s family for their loss," Keena said. 

Tuit and Peabody are among the four people charged in connection to the deadly home invasion and burglary. Ryann Elizabeth Smith, 22, of White Bear Lake, is charged with second-degree murder and Nicholas Alan Taylor, 29, of St. Paul, is charged with second-degree murder and first-degree burglary.

Prosecutors allege between July 1-2, the group was involved in a home invasion at Lafontaine's home in Greenvale Township. 

Authorities responded to Lafontaine's home at 4:45 p.m. on July 2, and found Lafontaine dead in the bathroom. A witness had called 911 to report two men ran from Lafontaine's home when a neighbor knocked on the door. The suspects were spotted getting into the victim's vehicle and driving off. 

Northfield police located the victim's vehicle soon after, but the suspects drove off, the complaint states. Eventually, they stopped and all three occupants fled into a wooded area. Police eventually arrested the driver, Peabody, and the front seat passenger, Tuit. 

The other occupant, Taylor, fled on foot. He and Smith were later arrested in Montana, officials said. 

Tuit and Peabody are scheduled to be sentenced on May 11, 2022. The trial for Smith is scheduled to begin Jan. 10, 2020, and Taylor's trial is set for April 25, 2022. 

Sign up: Subscribe to our BREAKING NEWS newsletters

The charges

According to the criminal complaint, deputies with the Dakota County Sheriff's Office responded to a report of a burglary in progress at a home in Greenvale Township.

The 911 caller said two men ran out of the home when a neighbor knocked on the door to check on Lafontaine. Another neighbor got into his car to look for the two men, spotting them coming out of a ditch and getting into Lafontaine's vehicle.

Deputies found the victim dead in a bathroom. His hands and feet were bound together with several cables, charges state. A rag and glove covered his mouth and were tied on with a cable.

An autopsy determined Lafontaine had ligature marks around his mouth, neck, feet and ankles, determining he died of an asphyxial-type death due to the items covering his mouth and the bondage, the complaint says.

About 10 minutes after the victim was found, Northfield police spotted the victim's vehicle driving southbound on Highway 3 and attempted to initiate a traffic stop, but they fled, charges state. Police pursued the vehicle until it stopped in a parking lot and all three people inside fled into a wooded area.

Police eventually arrested the driver, Peabody, and Tuit, who had been in the front seat, the complaint says. The third person in the vehicle was later identified as Taylor, who managed to evade capture.

In an interview with police, Peabody said she and Tuit are dating, Tuit and Taylor are brothers, and Taylor and Smith are dating. 

She admitted to using the victim's vehicle to drop Smith off at a gas station before driving Tuit and Taylor to the victim's home, the complaint says. She then parked on a dirt road until Tuit and Taylor called to have her pick them up by the ditch.

Peabody, who had four of the victim's checks in her possession when she was arrested, said she fled from police because Taylor told her to, charges state.

Peabody said Taylor and Smith had talked about having a "guy tied up," with Taylor saying he "tied him up so tight he could not get loose" and Smith sharing she hit him in the head with a Maglite flashlight because the victim wouldn't shut up, the complaint says.

Peabody said that when Taylor eventually told Smith the victim died, Smith panicked and started crying because she "didn't mean to hurt him like that," charges say.

Tuit told police he and Taylor went to the victim's house because it was a place where they could steal property and/or money, the complaint says. He admitted he had been "all over the house" and that Taylor told him they tied up the victim because he was getting "handsy" or "grabby" with Smith. When Tuit and Taylor fled the victim's home, Taylor told Tuit the victim might be dead and said he may have tied him up too tight, Tuit said.

When officers searched the victim's home, they found a safe strapped to a dolly and other property arranged in piles, charges say.

The victim's home was equipped with video surveillance, which was disconnected when officers found it, court documents say. Footage that was captured shows Taylor, Smith and the victim in the home in the early hours of July 1, but the cameras go black and stop recording.

Police searched Tuit's phone, which was found in the victim's car, in which there were numerous conversations between him and Taylor about a plan to burglarize the victim's home, charges say.

In texts at 5 a.m. on July 1, Taylor says he's going to pick up Tuit and his girlfriend to load all the property in vehicles, adding "you won't need to worry, I'm gonna have him tied up and stripped in the basement bathroom in a way he won't be able to move at all." Taylor also told Tuit the "security system is already down," the complaint states.

Taylor told Tuit they'd split the proceeds of their burglary 60/40 and Tuit said, "I'm down," charges say. At 1:37 a.m. on July 2, Taylor texts Tuit saying, "you know I want to get those boxes picked up and have that thing disposed of and then have the whole area incinerated."

Next Up

Anthony Edwards

Ant's injury clouds Timberwolves' victory over the Nets

The Timberwolves star was injured in the final minutes on Sunday night.

Akoya Lee

Byron native Ayoka Lee sets NCAA record for points in a game

The Kansas State forward broke a record shared by former Gopher Rachel Banham.

cold, wind chill, freezing

It's going to be stupid cold again Tuesday and Wednesday

They'll almost certainly be the 10th and 11th days with subzero temps this month.

Williams Uptown Pub

Williams Uptown Pub & Peanut Bar closes indefinitely after shooting

Reports say police have arrested two suspects in the incident.

Alex Rodríguez

A-Rod wears a Packers hat, Minnesotans lose their minds

The Timberwolves co-owner didn't endear himself to his fan base on Saturday night.

Flickr - Minneapolis police squad - Chad Davis

Police: Man shoots into crowd at funeral reception in Minneapolis

The shooting happened at a reception following a funeral on Saturday afternoon.

Screen Shot 2022-01-23 at 8.37.27 AM

Watch: Jimmy Garoppolo says 'F*** the Packers' after playoff win

The 49ers quarterback congratulated Robbie Gould in spectacular fashion.

Aaron Rodgers

America dunks on Aaron Rodgers after loss to 49ers

The Packers quarterback was destroyed on social media on Saturday night.

Marcus Foligno

Foligno's OT winner gives Wild fans a happy Hockey Day

A slow start gave way to the Wild's fifth win in the past six games.

Related

Timothy William Tuit

Charges reveal details in home invasion, burglary that left 55-year-old dead

The suspects discussed in text messages plans to burglarize the victim's home, charges say.

Facebook - GoGo dog stolen vehicle -  St. Paul Police Department

Teenager pleads guilty to stealing SUV with dog inside, letting it die

He also pleaded guilty in connection to a shooting outside a St. Paul community center in May.

mark ulsaker mugshot

Man who swung golf club at elderly couple holding anti-Trump sign pleads guilty

As a result of the plea agreement, the more serious charges against him will be dismissed.

austin herbst -

Man pleads guilty, admits he killed father in 2013 and dumped his body in WI

Austin Herbst and his mother were both charged in connection to Gary Herbst's death seven years after he was killed.

jeremy jones richardson - pine county

Charges: Man broke into friend's home, killed him with his cane

Pieces of the victim's cane were found on his back, charges say.

duluth police

Charges: Former Duluth man sexually assaulted teen in 2003

DNA led to the charges after nearly 20 years.