Skip to main content
Publish date:

A look at some of the differences between the criminal complaints filed against Derek Chauvin

Attorney General Keith Ellison and Hennepin County Attorney Mike Freeman's complaints described some things differently.
Derek Chauvin

Charges against former Minneapolis Police Officer Derek Chauvin were elevated to second-degree murder on Wednesday after Attorney General Keith Ellison was tasked at heading up the investigation into George Floyd's death. 

Hennepin County Attorney Mike Freeman initially charged Chauvin with third-degree murder and manslaughter. 

And the criminal complaints filed against Chauvin feature varying word choices to describe what happened (here's the complaint Ellison filed, and here's the one Freeman filed). 

Here's a look at some differences between the two criminal complaints: 

In the complaint filed by Freeman, it states "Officer (Thomas) Lane handcuffed Mr. Floyd. Mr. Floyd actively resisted being handcuffed." Meanwhile, the complaint filed by Ellison does not include this language and just states: "Officer Lane handcuffed Mr. Floyd."

After the officer handcuffed Floyd, Freeman's complaint says "Mr. Floyd became compliant and walked with Officer Lane to the sidewalk." While Ellison's doesn't include the language that states he became compliant, stating "Mr. Floyd walked with Officer Lane to the sidewalk."

Both complaints say at that point, Floyd sat on the ground at Officer Lane's direction. Ellison's complaint then states: "When Mr. Floyd sat down he said 'thank you man' and was calm." Freeman's complaint does not mention this. 

The complaints say they had a conversation that lasted under 2 minutes and then asked if Floyd was "on anything." Ellison's complaint then said Officer Lane "noted there was foam at the edges of his mouth," while Freeman's complaint does not mention this. 

When Officers Lane and Alexander Kueng went to walk Floyd to the squad car, Ellison's complaint says, "As the officers tried to put Mr. Floyd in their squad car, Mr. Floyd stiffened up and fell to the ground. Mr. Floyd told the officers that he was not resisting but he did not want to get in the back seat and was claustrophobic."

Freeman's complaint describes this by stating: "Mr. Floyd stiffened up, fell to the ground, and told the officers he was claustrophobic."

At this point, Officers Derek Chauvin and Tou Thao arrived at the scene, and the officers "made several attempts to get Mr. Floyd in the backseat" of the squad car, with Ellison's complaint describing it as the officers doing so "by pushing him from the driver's side. As the officers were trying to force Mr. Floyd in the backseat, Mr. Floyd repeatedly said that he could not breathe. Mr. Floyd did not voluntarily sit in the backseat and the officers physically struggled to try to get him in the backseat."

Freeman's complaint is less detailed, stating the officers made several attempts to get him in the backseat from the driver's side. "Mr. Floyd did not voluntarily get in the car and struggled with the officers by intentionally falling down, saying he was not going in the car, and refusing to stand still. Mr. Floyd is over six feet tall and weighs more than 200 pounds.

"While standing outside the car, Mr. Floyd began saying and repeating that he could not breathe," Freeman's complaint added.

Later on in the complaints, when they're describing Chauvin kneeling on Floyd's head and neck, Ellison's complaint said Floyd said "I'm about to die." Freeman's complaint does not mention this. 

Freeman's complaint states "BWC (body-worn camera) video shows Mr. Floyd continue to move and breathe. At 8:24:24, Mr. Floyd stopped moving." 

Ellison's complaint states, "While Mr. Floyd showed slight movements, his movements and sounds decreased until at 8:24:24, Mr. Floyd stopped moving." 

Ellison's complaint then goes into more detail from the Hennepin County Medical Examiner's report of the autopsy conducted on Floyd. Freeman's does not include some of these details but does note the full report was still pending. 

Freeman's complaint states: "The combined effects of Mr. Floyd being restrained by the police, his underlying health conditions and any potential intoxicants in his system likely contributed to his death."

Ellison's complaint says, "Officer Chauvin's restraint of Mr. Floyd in this manner for a prolonged period was a substantial causal factor in Mr. Floyd losing consciousness, constituting substantial bodily harm, and Mr. Floyd's death as well."

Next Up

ted mann concert hall - university of minnesota

2 armed suspects rob victim at U of M concert hall

The two suspects pointed guns at the victim.

West St Paul, Minnesota - June 2019

Nine police agencies called in for crowd control after 2 shot in West St. Paul

Police say a large group "attempted to take control" of part of the crime scene.

Brooklyn Center police, Daunte Wright

Brooklyn Center approves $1.3M public safety budget, including policing reforms

The city will use some money from the police department for the new programs.

snow, slush

Snow impacting morning commute across southern Minnesota

A quick inch could make a bit of a mess on the roads.

40636734693_0ec9b711a6_k

Minnesota United star allegedly hit teen with gun in Argentina

The 26-year-old could face charges in Argentina.

Chris Finch

Hawks bury Timberwolves in 3-point barrage

Without D'Angelo Russell, the Wolves couldn't keep up with the Hawks.

P.J. Fleck, Gophers football

Kirk Ciarocca returning to Gophers as offensive coordinator

The architect of the 2019 offense will look to revive the Gophers.

Klobuchar - MTP - NBC screengrab

Klobuchar says Congress should pass law to protect abortion rights

Her comments came as the Supreme Court appears poised to weaken — or gut — Roe v. Wade

MPD missing Heard - crop 1_

Minneapolis woman missing a week is found safe

The 36-year-old hasn't been seen or heard from recently.

unsplash cold winter breath dark

Hello, winter: List of the coldest wind chills in MN Monday morning

The state went from a relatively mild start of the season, to downright frigid wind chills.

deer

1 CWD-positive deer in Brainerd Lakes area, so surveillance will continue

The CWD monitoring measures were supposed to end after this year.

unsplash - visitor patient doctor hospital emergency - crop

MN program will train, hire 1,000 nursing assistants for long-term care

The facilities are facing a severe staffing shortage.

Related

Screen Shot 2020-05-26 at 10.28.52 AM

MN House members say they've 'lost faith' in Hennepin County attorney

They want Attorney General Keith Ellison to handle the case against the officers in George Floyd's death.

Derek Chauvin

Smaller protests outside homes of Derek Chauvin, Hennepin Co. Attorney

There was some property damage at Chauvin's house, but demonstrations were otherwise peaceful.

Derek Chauvin

Derek Chauvin charged with 2nd-degree murder of George Floyd

AG Keith Ellison confirmed the charges Wednesday.

Derek Chauvin

Prosecutors: Chauvin knelt on teen's neck for 17 minutes in 2017

Prosecutors are seeking to include body camera footage from the arrest, which they say shows a pattern of excessive force by Chauvin.

mike freeman

Watch live: Attorney on arrest of ex-Minneapolis cop Derek Chauvin

Chauvin was arrested Friday, according to DPS Commissioner John Harrington.

Screen Shot 2020-05-31 at 7.07.04 PM

Gov. Tim Walz says AG Keith Ellison will lead George Floyd prosecutions

He will take over the lead from Hennepin County Attorney Mike Freeman.

George Floyd

51 arrested in Minneapolis protests after Chauvin is released from prison

The former officer charged in George Floyd's death posted bond Wednesday and was released, prompting the largely peaceful protests in Minneapolis.