Skip to main content

All five Republican gubernatorial hopefuls were asked the same first question during Wednesday evening's debate: "In your opinion, did President Biden win a constitutional majority in the electoral college?"

Not a single candidate expressed confidence in the long-certified results.

The debate, livestreamed by Alpha News, included five GOP gubernatorial hopefuls: Sen. Michelle Benson, Sen. Paul Gazelka, Dr. Scott Jensen, Mayor Mike Murphy and Dr. Neil Shah. After opening remarks, moderator Hugh Hewitt — a conservative talk show host and attorney — asked each participant the following:

"Did President Biden win a constitutional majority in the electoral college? If yes, how definitive is your conclusion, and if no, please explain which states you think are in dispute and why? This round of questioning begins at 10:17 in the livestream.

Each candidate had about 90 seconds to respond. All of them sowed doubt about the 2020 election results, despite Biden winning by 7 million individual votes and 74 electoral college votes. Here's a summary of each Republican's response, in the order they answered:

Jensen: "I can't know what I don't know. And I think we have to take that attitude toward 2020," he said, mentioning a Republican-led audit in Maricopa County that found zero discrepancies. Jensen also said there have been "enough shenanigans," adding it's time to address "election integrity." He also said he believes dead people voted.

Shah: Shah joked that, growing up in the Chicago suburbs, he can't tell anyone the last time that city had "a free and fair election." So it's not a problem "unique to 2020," he said. 

Murphy: Murphy, the mayor of Lexington, said he believes there was voter fraud on a "massive scale" across the country in 2020, though acknowledged he can't "pinpoint the evidence' because he's not "privy to the scheme." He also cited a debunked Project Veritas video about the DFL primary in Minnesota's 5th Congressional District.

Gazelka: "I don't think the election was fair, but I do think we have the results that we have and the electroal college is the way that we determine the election," said the former Senate majority leader, who won re-election himself in 2020 but has not questioned the results. Gazelka added he is "not a big fan of how it all played out" and called for election reforms. 

Benson: Benson initially did not answer Hewitt's question directly, saying only that "our job" is "to make it easy to vote and hard to cheat," later adding: "The more we watch, the less we cheat." Asked specifically in a follow-up if Biden won, she replied: "He was certified by Congress as having won the electoral college." Benson also won re-election in 2020 and has not questioned the results.

None of the candidates specifically explained which states' results they believe weren't valid.

Related [Dec. 9]: Republican who doubts 2020 election results wants to oversee MN elections

There has been no evidence of any significant voter fraud in the 13 months since the election was held. An analysis published this week by The Associated Press found fewer than 475 ballots that were flagged as suspicious in six highly contested states — states Biden won by 311,257 combined votes. Meaning even if all 475 ballots were for Biden (they weren't), it wouldn't make any difference in the outcome.

The Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank, has found a total of 1,334 instances of proven voter fraud over the past 41 years. Many of the cases involve allegations related to municipal races, not necessarily presidential races, with 86% having resulted in a criminal conviction. The site shows no cases in Minnesota tied to the 2020 election.

Next Up

turtinen two harbors

MN mayor in hot water for hawking $400M underwater hotel plan

The city council called a special meeting to discuss the mayor's public comments.

police lights

Woman in critical condition after attempted murder, authorities say

A 33-year-old woman is in custody and facing possible charges.

Flickr - police lights squad siren - Edward Kimmel

Charges: Driver threw 'large rocks' at police car during highway chase

Authorities say the suspect had used methamphetamine earlier in the day.

covid, coronavirus

Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Friday, January 21

Hospitalizations dipped from 1,629 Jan. 19 to 1,571 on Jan. 20.

minneapolis police

Shooting near University of Minnesota kills 1, injures 2

The victims were all in a parked car when the shooting happened, police said.

canada bodies found 2

Florida man charged with human smuggling after 4 die, 5 rescued near border

A baby and an teenage boy were among those who were found dead feet from the U.S. border.

Screen Shot 2022-01-21 at 8.42.40 AM

Man shot while driving on I-394 in St. Louis Park

The driver and his bullet-riddled SUV wound up outside the DoubleTree hotel in St. Louis Park.

Mall of America

Mall of America to celebrate 30 years with events, giveaways throughout 2022

The festivities will kick off Friday with a '90s-themed drag show.

Screen Shot 2022-01-21 at 7.29.00 AM

Victim of 1994 Michigan cold case murder ID'd as missing Minnesotan

Shelley Rae Kephart went missing from Hennepin County more than 28 years ago.

Mike Zimmer

Coller: Did the Vikings wait too long to fire Zimmer, Spielman?

This wasn’t just ugly. This was ugly, ugly.

walz flanagan lorie shaull flickr

Gov. proposes 'Walz Checks' for most Minnesotans

The governor wants to use $700 million of the state's surplus to fund the payments.


kim crockett facebook sos

Republican who doubts 2020 election results wants to oversee MN elections

Kim Crockett announced she is running for Secretary of State in 2022.

Biden Minnesota visit stream screengrab - 11.30.31

What Biden said during his visit to Minnesota Tuesday

The president spoke at Dakota County Technical College.

jennifer carnahan

After intense campaign, Jennifer Carnahan reelected MN GOP chair

This will be her third term leading Minnesota Republicans.

Debates set as Wisconsin candidates gear up for gubernatorial rematch

Milwaukee Mayor Tom Barrett and Republican Governor Scott Walker will debate at least twice before the June fifth recall election. The two faced each other 18 months ago. But much has changed since Walker's victory.

Beyond the headlines: 5 takeaways from the final presidential debate

Digging deeper than the "nasty woman" quote and who "won."

Daniel and Daryl Johnson - Jan 6 Capitol riot screengrab DOJ charges

MN man admits to rushing Capitol police during Jan. 6 siege

He and his father, who is from Iowa, were together in the Capitol during the attack.