Skip to main content

Byron Smith's attorneys tell Minnesota Supreme Court murder trial was unfair

  • Author:
  • Updated:

Minnesota's highest court is now deliberating over whether Byron Smith, the Little Falls man who was imprisoned for life for killing two teens, had been given a fair trial when he was convicted last year.

Smith's defense lawyers spent much of Thursday trying to persuade state Supreme Court justices that he hadn't, pointing to a "brief courtroom closure" that may have been improper, the Star Tribune reports.

When the attorneys filed their appeal of the conviction earlier this year, they also argued that the presiding judge had made several errors which prevented them from providing Smith a "complete defense."

The six justices questioned both sides about the 2014 court proceedings, the Star Tribune notes, with the prosecutors arguing the courtroom closure – which they said was used to "instruct attorneys" on proper conduct – had "no impact" on the fairness of the trial.

The facts of the case

The 66-year-old Smith was originally put in the defendant's chair over the fatal Thanksgiving 2o12 shooting of cousins Haile Kifer, 18, and Nick Brady, 17, both of whom had broken into Smith's home.

Smith said he'd fired on the pair to defend his property, but prosecutors argued that he acted excessively when he continued to shoot the teens even after they were injured and no longer a threat.

For their part, the juveniles had been linked to other area robberies, and court documents revealed Brady had broken into Smith's house and garage before.

Nonetheless, prosecutors called it a "premeditated ambush," and jurors found him guilty. He was eventually sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of release.

As for how the arguments went on Thursday, WCCO reports the Supreme Court justices "seemed to agree" with Smith's attorneys that the presiding judge was in error when he closed the courtroom during the period in question.

The station points out that the court is not expected to arrive at a decision immediately, and that it could take them several months to hand down a ruling.

Next Up

Pixabay - gray squirrel

Squirrel blamed for Friday power outage impacting over 5,000 homes

There's no telling when or where the squirrels will strike next.

Screen Shot 2022-09-30 at 8.11.55 AM

Seattle man federally indicted in massive Bloomington fentanyl bust

The case is believed to represent the largest fentanyl bust in the Midwest.

Screen Shot 2022-09-30 at 9.27.53 AM

Nicollet Diner to launch new, expanded home with a drag show

The new location will still feature the diner's classic offerings, as well as a new cabaret venue and cocktail lounge.

police tape, crime scene

Woman found dead at Minneapolis home was stabbed multiple times

LaTiffany Altanette Lessley was found dead in a north Minneapolis home Tuesday.

Screen Shot 2022-09-29 at 4.48.45 PM

Bloomington PD announce what's likely 'largest fentanyl bust in Midwest'

The case is under investigation by the U.S. Attorney's Office.


Minnesota's COVID-19 update for the week ending Sept. 27

This week's report represents data collected Sept. 21-27.

Screen Shot 2022-09-29 at 2.56.10 PM

MN health officials warn of potential for measles outbreak amid rise in cases

A recent case among a child with no travel history is prompting heightened concern.

skid steer

Four-year-old boy dies in accident on western Wisconsin farm

The boy was struck by a skid steer, according to police.

Screen Shot 2022-09-29 at 2.41.51 PM

Psycho Suzi's Motor Lounge hits the market for $6M

The restaurant will remain open while the property is on the market.

Screen Shot 2022-09-29 at 12.27.48 PM

Apartments, brewery proposed for site of former Minneapolis lumberyard

The developer is proposing two buildings connected via skyway.

Screen Shot 2022-09-29 at 1.27.38 PM

'Exceptionally rare' meteorite impact crater found in the Twin Cities metro

Had it struck in today's world, much of the Twin Cities would've been wiped out.

Grand Old Day

Organizers seeking ideas for 'reimagining' of Grand Old Day

A task force is set to begin meeting next month to reimagine the event.