Skip to main content

Charges: Woman fatally shot cousin, but witnesses say she was trying to protect her

The victim was in a physical altercation with a neighbor when she was shot. The neighbor was also hit in the arm.
nicole love smith mugshot

A woman accused of fatally shooting her cousin and another woman in St. Paul over the weekend has been charged.

Nicole Love Smith, 42, of St. Paul, was arrested Sunday and was charged Monday with second-degree unintentional murder and second-degree attempted murder in the death of 44-year-old LaWanda Wade, of St. Paul. A 43-year-old woman was also shot in the arm. 

According to the Ramsey County criminal complaint, officers responded to a "chaotic scene" at the parking lot of 76 Stevens St. W at about 9:30 p.m. on Oct. 10, where they found Smith trying to help her cousin, Wade, who was lying face down on the ground. 

Wade was taken to the hospital, where she was pronounced dead shortly thereafter. The Ramsey County Medical Examiner's Office says the gunshot entered her back and went through her left lung and heart, causing her to bleed to death, court documents state.

Meanwhile, officers at the scene followed a trail of blood to a man and woman's apartment, where they found a woman "actively bleeding" from a gunshot wound. She was taken to the hospital and the couple was taken into custody, the complaint said. 

Smith told police that Wade had been arguing with the couple, who also live in the building, and at one point Wade threw a grill at them. The couple then allegedly hit Wade several times with baseball bats.

Wade was reportedly arguing with the couple because Wade had been hitting on the man, who is the boyfriend of the woman who was shot in the arm.

This woman told police she had been jumped by Wade and "several other women" outside, and so she went to get a bat and began to fight with Wade. At one point, Wade got on top of her and she heard a gunshot but didn't see who fired. 

Officers recovered one 9mm casing in the parking lot near a vehicle that is registered to Smith's sister. Witnesses said they saw two women, including one who matched the description of the shooter, in that vehicle with Wade prior to the fighting and shooting. 

Smith was taken into custody after police determined she matched the description of the shooter provided by the 911 caller, who said the shooter "accidentally shot her friend." 

Smith denied shooting anyone, the complaint said. But police did overhear her on the phone saying she was willing to protect herself, she's tough and would carry a weapon if needed.

Sign up for our BREAKING NEWS newsletters

Witnesses say she shot cousin accidentally

Witnesses, who gave varying accounts of how many gunshots they heard, said they thought Smith was trying to shoot the woman Wade was fighting with, but accidentally shot Wade, charges say. One man said based on how Smith was acting after the shooting he thought she was genuinely grieving. 

Wade's sister, Darnella Wade, told the Pioneer Press that she too believes Smith did not intend to shoot her cousin but was trying to protect her, noting LaWanda Wade had people over to her apartment prior to the shooting to grill up the meat from her freezer since it broke. 

Darnella Wade's son was critically wounded when he was shot in the head in St. Paul in 2016, inspiring her to start the nonprofit Black Truce Peace Organization. LaWanda Wade was a board member who helped behind the scenes, Darnella Wade told the paper.

LaWanda Wade's death was the 26th homicide of the year in St. Paul, police said.

Next Up


New Raptor Center data shows 'substantial drop' in bird flu patients

However, the virus remains a serious health threat for birds.

Screen Shot 2022-05-18 at 6.16.34 PM

Suspect kills himself after shooting woman and baby at Fargo restaurant

The suspect was found dead in a stolen vehicle in Minnesota.

CK Kyle Kasio

Charges: Guest stabbed three men as they slept in Albert Lea

Investigators believe the suspect is related to all three victims.

Kandiyohi County Courthouse

2 charged for fentanyl overdose death of 19-year-old

The-19-year-old died from a fentanyl overdose last month.

storm, severe weather

Severe thunderstorm watch: Hail, 65 mph gusts, tornadoes possible

The watch is just north of the Twin Cities metro area.

Lake Minnetonka

The staggering rise of Minnesota's most famous lakes this spring

Imagine dumping Lake Minnetonka into Lake Superior 47 times.

Marijuana, cannabis

Minnesota Senate shoots down latest marijuana legalization attempt

The bill didn't receive the required votes for further consideration on Wednesday.


Minneapolis wants to use $1M in federal cash to plant 200,000 trees

The goal is to have these trees planted by the year 2040.

Screen Shot 2022-05-18 at 12.54.22 PM

MOA theater to debut wrap-around, 270-degree movie screen

The new technology will expand the movie screen onto the side walls of the theater auditorium.


wallace family St. Paul

Ex-boyfriend charged with murder of woman, her 2 kids in St. Paul

The mom and her two kids were killed Jan. 30 in their St. Paul home.


Charges: Cold Spring woman gave neighbor drugs that killed her

The 30-year-old woman is accused of giving her neighbor methadone and amphetamines, which killed her.

Screen Shot 2021-09-11 at 7.42.42 AM

Charges: Woman fatally stabbed boyfriend, child's father

The man died from a single stab wound that struck an artery.

Cole Leon Venables - edit

Charges: Impaired pizza delivery driver fatally hit woman in Hopkins

The woman who was killed was walking down the sidewalk when she was hit and killed.

st. paul police shooting jackston street

Man fatally shot outside St. Paul bar is identified

The Burnsville man was shot Sunday night and died early Monday.

anthony wicklace

Charges: Minnesota YouTuber sexually assaulted victim, Tased her

He offered the woman a ride after she was removed from a residence in St. Paul, charges say.