Skip to main content

Chicago man arrested in connection with fatal road rage shooting of Jay Boughton

He was taken into custody Aug. 24 with the help of Decatur police and U.S. Marshals.

A 33-year-old Chicago man is in custody in connection with the July 6 killing of youth baseball coach Jay Boughton.

The Plymouth Police Department Thursday said the suspect was arrested in Decatur, Illinois, on Aug. 24. Plymouth police located the suspect, and Decatur police as well as members of the U.S. Marshals Service helped take him into custody without incident, Plymouth Police Chief Erik Fadden said at a Thursday afternoon news conference.

Fadden said he could not comment on whether authorities were looking for more suspects, or when criminal charges might be filed. The suspect was arrested on a second-degree murder warrant however, he said. 

Investigators have been searching for the suspect shooter or shooters for weeks, publishing multiple grainy images of a suspect vehicle and issuing pleas for tips as the case dragged on. Bouhgton had been driving home from a baseball game with his son around 10 p.m. when he was shot in the head while on Highway 169 south of Rockford Road.

Police said another motorist traveling in the same direction opened fire, and Fadden Thursday stressed this was not a "back-and-forth" road rage incident, though that there may have been a minor altercation beforehand.

Fadden said staff have put more than 1,500 hours into the case so far, saying efforts have been painstaking and tireless.

The investigation "continues to be very active," he said. noting there is "still a lot of work to be done." They're continuing to interview people and follow up on leads, and still want tips from the public if anyone has additional information.

Sign up: Subscribe to our BREAKING NEWS newsletters

The suspect is in custody in Illinois, waiting to be extradited to Minnesota, Fadden said. Boughton's family was told of the arrest the day it occurred, with the police chief describing them as "grateful."

Fadden could not comment on what they believe the suspect's role in Boughton's killing was, nor what the man was doing in Minnesota at the time.

Bring Me The News does not typically name suspect that have not yet been charged with a crime.

Next Up


New Raptor Center data shows 'substantial drop' in bird flu patients

However, the virus remains a serious health threat for birds.

Screen Shot 2022-05-18 at 6.16.34 PM

Suspect kills himself after shooting woman and baby at Fargo restaurant

The suspect was found dead in a stolen vehicle in Minnesota.

CK Kyle Kasio

Charges: Guest stabbed three men as they slept in Albert Lea

Investigators believe the suspect is related to all three victims.

Kandiyohi County Courthouse

2 charged for fentanyl overdose death of 19-year-old

The-19-year-old died from a fentanyl overdose last month.

storm, severe weather

Severe thunderstorm watch: Hail, 65 mph gusts, tornadoes possible

The watch is just north of the Twin Cities metro area.

Lake Minnetonka

The staggering rise of Minnesota's most famous lakes this spring

Imagine dumping Lake Minnetonka into Lake Superior 47 times.

Marijuana, cannabis

Minnesota Senate shoots down latest marijuana legalization attempt

The bill didn't receive the required votes for further consideration on Wednesday.


Minneapolis wants to use $1M in federal cash to plant 200,000 trees

The goal is to have these trees planted by the year 2040.

Screen Shot 2022-05-18 at 12.54.22 PM

MOA theater to debut wrap-around, 270-degree movie screen

The new technology will expand the movie screen onto the side walls of the theater auditorium.


Plymouth Hwy 169 shooting - New Image July 22 - 1

New photos of suspect vehicle in fatal Hwy. 169 road rage shooting released

Youth baseball coach Jay Boughton died from a gunshot wound to the head.

Jay Boughton

Suspect arrested in Highway 169 shooting that killed baseball coach

A press conference is planned for 2 p.m. Thursday.

hwy 169 shooting

Police release video, map of suspect vehicle in road rage killing

The family of Jay Boughton also spoke at the Friday press conference.

Screen Shot 2021-08-30 at 6.59.14 AM

SWAT team arrests suspect in connection with fatal shooting in St. Paul

The victim had been driving an SUV when gunshots were fired from another vehicle.

Plymouth Hwy 169 shooting - New Image July 22 - 1

Plymouth police find SUV matching suspect vehicle in fatal Highway 169 shooting

Investigators are processing the vehicle in hopes of gathering evidence.

Jamal Smith

New 1st-degree murder charge for man accused in youth coach's killing

A grand jury indicted the suspect in connection with the shooting of Jay Boughton.

Screen Shot 2021-08-29 at 6.15.05 PM

Charges: 'Road rage incident' precipitated fatal shooting on I-94

The victim and suspect allegedly got into a dispute on the highway's entrance ramp.