Skip to main content
Publish date:

Court reverses PolyMet permits in major boost for conservation groups

Another delay for the long-planned project.
Author:

The Minnesota Court of Appeals on Monday reversed two permits issued by the Minnesota DNR for the PolyMet copper-nickel mine project in northern Minnesota.

In a setback for Canada-based PolyMet Mining, the court ruled that the mine and dam safety permits issued by the DNR in 2018 require additional review.

The NorthMet project would see the refurbishment of the former LTV Steel Mining processing plant near Hoyt Lakes and Babbitt, with mining then going as deep as 700 feet beneath the surface, generating 225 million tons of ore over its two decades of operation.

But the court found that the DNR had made an error by not holding "contested case hearings" on the permits to discuss potential environmental concerns, with objections having been raised by the Fond du Lac Band of Lake Superior Chippewa and several environmental groups including the Friends of the Boundary Waters.

The court also found that the DNR should not have issued a permit without it having a defined time limit for operations to begin.

"The DNR’s decision to deny a contested-case hearing in relation to the NorthMet project was based on errors of law and unsupported by substantial evidence, and the DNR also erred by failing to include a definite term in the NorthMet permit to mine," wrote Chief Judge Edward Cleary. 

While the court has not rejected the permits outright, sending them back to the DNR will mean further delay on the long-planned PolyMet project, with the DNR now required to hold a contested-case hearing.

The Star Tribune reports it could complicate PolyMet's ability to get financing for the $1 billion project.

There could be more delays on the horizon as well. Last year, the Court of Appeals ordered a review into how the DNR handled the approval of a PolyMet water permit.

It comes after leaked emails between the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency and the Environment Protection Agency (EPA) showed the MPCA ask the EPA not to submit its concerns about the project during the public comment period.

According to court documents, the EPA’s comments on the permit were reduced to phone calls and interviews that “departed from typical procedures in addressing the NorthMet permit." Some of the comments were left off of the official administrative public record.

The Associated Press reports that a Ramsey County judge will open a 5-10-day fact-finding hearing on this issue next week.

Next Up

Mike Zimmer

Vikings fans clamor for change after latest bad loss under Mike Zimmer

The "fire Mike Zimmer" tweets are raging on Twitter again.

Tony Oliva

Tony Oliva and Jim Kaat are finally heading to Cooperstown

The Twins legends were elected to Baseball's Hall of Fame on Sunday night.

Tanner Morgan

Report: Gophers to play in Guaranteed Rate Bowl

The Gophers will reportedly head to Phoenix to take on West Virginia.

Adam Thielen

Winless Lions beat Vikings on final play of game

Adam Thielen also left early with an ankle injury

Payton Willis / Gopher Basketball

Gophers improve to 7-0 on Willis' late 3-pointer

The Gophers earned back-to-back road victories for the first time since January 2017.

Flickr - police lights squad siren - Edward Kimmel

Woman in critical condition after being shot in the head in St. Paul

Officers responded to the incident at around 2:45 a.m. Saturday.

Alexander Mattison

Vikings-Lions: 5 things you can count on

It's a great time for the Vikings to play the Lions.

covid

Omicron variant confirmed in Wisconsin man who traveled to South Africa

Five other cases have been confirmed and linked to a Wisconsin wedding.

Sharon Mollerus - duluth - snow plow car

Sunday snowstorm walloping MN's North Shore with huge totals

Just ridiculous snow totals expected the rest of Sunday.

Screen Shot 2021-12-05 at 6.49.03 AM

Saturday snow causes havoc on Twin Cities roads

There were countless spinouts and crashes across Minnesota.

Related

Leaked email calls into question approval of PolyMet mine permit

The EPA was apparently asked to keep its concerns about the project out of the public record.

polymet mining

Environmentalists, PolyMet both claim victory after Supreme Court ruling

Both sides are claiming a win after the Supreme Court issued a ruling related to the proposed mine in northeastern Minnesota.

DNR gives green light to PolyMet mine in northeast Minnesota

The project is opposed by eco-groups over pollution fears..

Court orders inquiry into PolyMet mining project permit

The Minnesota Court of Appeals found "irregularities" in comments submitted by the EPA.

PolyMet gets final permit for controversial NorthMet mine

This decision clears the way for the project's construction.

wetlands

Army Corps of Engineers pulls PolyMet's wetlands permit

This comes as the EPA is doing a 90-day review of the project.

wetlands

Investigation finds EPA mishandled oversight for PolyMet mine permits

A new report found the EPA didn't follow its own procedures when it submitted comments on the proposed project.