Skip to main content

During Shelter in Place order, Supreme Courts say Wisconsin vote will go ahead

The court overturned Gov. Tony Evers executive order to delay Tuesday's election by two months.

Wisconsin's presidential primary and state election will go ahead on Tuesday, despite Gov. Tony Evers' attempt to delay it by two months due to the coronavirus pandemic.

The Wisconsin Supreme Court on Monday blocked the Democratic governor's decision to delay the election to June, overturning his executive order after it was challenged by the state's Republican-controlled Legislature.

Hours later, the Supreme Court of the United States decided in a partisan 5-4 vote to overturn the ruling by a lower court in Wisconsin that would have extended the deadline for absentee ballots by 6 days, at a time when many voters are still waiting for their ballots to arrive in the mail.

As well as the Democratic primary between Joe Biden and Bernie Sanders, Wisconsinites are also voting on a crucial seat on the Wisconsin Supreme Court.

The Legislature had been adamant that the election go ahead, while Evers himself had intended for Tuesday's vote to take place as recently as last month, before having a change of heart as the COVID-19 crisis continued to escalate in Wisconsin.

As of Monday, Wisconsin had documented 2,440 positive COVID-19 tests, 77 deaths and 668 patients who have required hospitalization. 

Wisconsin is under a "Shelter in Place" order until April 24, and the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reports that the state's top health official has warned that voting in person will "without question" lead to more illness and death.

The huge demand for postal votes has meant that election day has arrived while many thousands are still waiting for their mail-in ballot to arrive, leaving them with a choice of either voting in-person and risking their health, or not voting at all.

Meanwhile those whose ballots have arrived have to ensure that their vote is postmarked no later than Tuesday and must arrive by April 13. 

Many other states with primaries planned for March and April have pushed them back because of COVID-19.

Evers issued the order after a Special Session convened by the Legislature on Saturday ended within seconds with no action taken to delay the vote.

"People have bled, fought, and died for the right to vote in this country," Evers wrote in his order. "But tomorrow in Wisconsin, thousands will wake up and have to choose between exercising their right to vote and staying healthy and safe."

Sign up for our BREAKING NEWS newsletters

But the Wisconsin Supreme Court ruled that the Evers didn't have the authority to unilaterally move the date of the election.

Later, an unsigned opinion by the Republican-leaning justices on the U.S. Supreme Court said the lower court's decision to extend absentee voting violated the "Purcell principle," which says courts shouldn't meddle in elections immediately before the vote.

This is despite the unprecedented situations created by the pandemic that has seen the Supreme Court itself delay oral arguments for the duration of April due to the risk of coronavirus.

Dissenting were the liberal-leaning justices, with Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg writing that Wisconsinites will "have to brave the polls, endangering their own and others’ safety. Or they will lose their right to vote, through no fault of their own."

Next Up

Screen Shot 2023-01-25 at 4.17.31 PM

New preschool and daycare to be built in Eagan

The 12,600-square-foot building will be constructed on vacant land.

Screen Shot 2023-01-13 at 12.25.21 PM

Hamline University faculty urge President Fayneese Miller to resign

Fayneese Miller has served as president since 2015.

Police tape

Man in 40s dies in Minneapolis shooting

The victim was pronounced dead at the scene.

image

Burnsville High School student killed in crash involving 15-year-old driver

The single-vehicle crash happened shortly after midnight.

CrashMNHighway

Watch: Driver sent airborne after being struck by sliding car

The person was seen on MnDOT cameras tending to their vehicle prior to the crash.

Plow 2 (1)

Minneapolis shifting to one-sided street parking starting Thursday night

EMS vehicles, firetrucks and buses have struggled to drive on city streets due to snow.

Screen Shot 2023-01-25 at 10.04.12 AM

Watch: 2 arrested north of Twin Cities after burglary, police pursuit

The suspects are seen on MnDOT cameras attempting to flee law enforcement.

Related

masks

Wisconsin Supreme Court overturns state's face mask mandate

The Wisconsin Supreme Court has a conservative majority.

Tony Evers, Wisconsin governor

Wisconsin to allow retail stores to re-open, with strict customer limit

It's the latest 'turn of the dial' on Gov. Tony Evers' Stay at Home order.

masks, coronavirus, covid-19

Wisconsin Assembly votes to overturn Gov. Tony Evers' face mask mandate

The GOP-led Legislature has opposed the Democratic governor's COVID measures.

Screen Shot 2020-04-22 at 7.55.53 AM

Western Wisconsin sheriff says he will allow businesses to reopen

The state's Stay at Home order is being extended as of Friday.

Bar beer

Patrons pack Wisconsin bars after court strikes down Stay at Home order

Some bars opened almost immediately after the Wisconsin Supreme Court ended the state's Safer at Home order.

1024px-Morris_Hall_University_of_Wisconsin-La_Crosse_near_Wing_Tech_Center_Building

UW-La Crosse imposes 2 week 'Shelter in Place' after spike in COVID-19

Many students have left campus, despite the university asking them to stay put.

Tim Walz

Gov Walz: No 'shelter-in-place' order yet, but situation could change

The governor provided an update to Minnesota's coronavirus efforts on Friday.