Environmental group argues Line 3 pipeline replacement is no longer needed

Honor the Earth filed the petition with the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission Tuesday.
Publish date:

A Minnesota environmental group is asking the state to reconsider the proposed Enbridge Line 3 pipeline replacement project through Northern Minnesota, stating that the Canadian energy company no longer needs it thanks to expanded capacity on other pipelines.

On Tuesday, Honor the Earth filed a petition with the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission, asking the agency to investigate how efficiency and capacity improvements made by Enbridge over recent years impact the need for the Line 3 project.

The Enbridge Line 3 crude oil pipeline replacement will allow transportation of crude oil in Minnesota, Eastern Canada and other neighboring states. The project will increase capacity by replacing the existing 34-inch diameter pipeline with a 36-inch diameter pipeline.

The project recently received two of the ten necessary approvals from the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

However, the petition filed by Honor the Earth claims that capacity additions made by Enbridge between 2016 and 2019, including to lines 2, 4 and 65, have allowed the company to import an additional 400,000 barrels through Minnesota per day.

Honor the Earth also points to expansions to Lines 4 and 67 that would increase capacity by 178,400 barrels of crude oil per day.

Coupled with a decreased demand for Canadian crude oil due to COVID-19, the petition claims that the existing expansions outweigh the need for the Line 3 project, which it says would bring in 370,000 barrels per day.

“Together, these efficiency-based expansions create far more capacity than would be provided by the proposed Line 3 Pipeline’s net capacity increase of 370,000 bpd,” said Paul Blackburn, staff attorney for Honor the Earth, in a statement. “As a result, Enbridge has already met the need that formed the basis for the PUC’s approval of the Line 3 Replacement Project.”

Follow Bring Me The News on News Break

Enbridge acknowledged ongoing efforts to increase capacity and efficiency in a statement to the Star Tribune.

“There have been several initiatives that Enbridge has implemented in recent years to optimize its pipeline network to better meet customer demands,” the statement reads 

“We’ve talked about these optimizations and efficiency-led capacity increases in a variety of public forums.”

The latest forecast from Novak Weather

Next Up

Marijuana, cannabis

Minnesota adds 2 more qualifying conditions for medical marijuana

There will be 17 conditions that qualify people to obtain medical marijuana in Minnesota.

Matt Birk

Ex-Viking Matt Birk confirms interest in future run for governor

The next gubernatorial election in Minnesota is Nov. 8, 2022.

Screen Shot 2020-12-01 at 10.59.59 AM

Handsome Hog in St. Paul to close temporarily

Executive chef Justin Sutherland cited inaction by state and federal leaders during the COVID-19 pandemic.


Dept. of Education adding more gender options when collecting student data

The public can comment on the implementation of the nonbinary gender options until Dec. 13.

police tape, crime scene

Police ID couple found dead in home, murder-suicide suspected

The bodies were found in St. Louis County after the pair failed to show for work.

State Capitol

Minnesota's budget forecast improves, shows $641M surplus for 2020-21

"Higher general fund revenues and lower expected spending result in a projected surplus," MMB said.

Screen Shot 2020-08-14 at 6.45.53 PM

Brooklyn Park shooting leaves 2 injured

Two victims sustained non-life threatening injuries during the Monday evening incident.

Screen Shot 2019-10-14 at 10.38.01 PM

Worthington settles police brutality lawsuit for $590,000, agrees to reforms

The lawsuit was filed on behalf of Kelvin Francisco Rodriguez, who spent five days in the ICU after being arrested.

Michael Munoz

Rochester superintendent admits he plagiarized letter to staff

Med City Beat broke the story, prompting the superintendent to apologize.

police tape, crime scene

Man and woman, aged 55 and 62, found dead in their home

The St. Louis County Sheriff's Office is investigating.


Preferred Line 3 route

Walz administration files appeal against Line 3 pipeline

The action is the latest in a year-long process surrounding the controversial project.

enbridge line 3

Minnesota DNR grants 2 approvals for Line 3 pipeline

The Enbridge pipeline replacement project would replace a crude oil pipeline in northern Minnesota.

MN Supreme Court deals blow to opponents of Line 3 pipeline

The Supreme Court declined to take up a challenge against the project.

No need for a new MN pipeline, state agency says

Commerce Dept. opposes Enbridge line but they don't have final say

Screen Shot 2020-11-30 at 1.31.42 PM

Enbridge gets final approval to start construction on Line 3 replacement

The project has attracted criticism from environmental and tribal groups.

enbridge line 3

MPCA advisory group members resign, calling Line 3 approval the 'final straw'

"We cannot continue to legitimize and provide cover for the MPCA's war on black and brown people," their resignation letter states.

Pipeline opponents ride the proposed route on horseback

A final review of the Enbridge project comes out Thursday