Skip to main content

Environmental impact statement for Line 3 pipeline 'inadequate,' appeals court rules

It's a setback for pipeline company Enbridge.

The proposed route of the Enbridge pipeline.

The Minnesota Court of Appeals has ruled that the environmental impact statement into the Enbridge Line 3 oil pipeline across Minnesota is inadequate.

In an opinion released Monday, the court ruled that the EIS is "inadequate because it does not address the potential impact of an oil spill into the Lake Superior watershed."

As a result of the ruling, the court has reversed the decision by the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission, which had found the statement to be acceptable.

A legal challenge had been brought by environmental groups and tribal bands on whose land the replacement pipeline would bisect.

However, the appeals court did reject "most" of the arguments made by the groups, with the Lake Superior watershed but one area where the judges agreed.

The sticking point came in the seven different models presented in the EIS that looks into the potential impact of a crude oil spill.

The court noted that none of the sites looked at for these spill models were in the Lake Superior watershed.

"Throughout the environmental-review process, environmental organizations and members of the public raised concerns about the impact of an oil spill on Lake Superior and its watershed, including the St. Louis River Estuary," the court opinion said.

"In spite of these persistent concerns, neither the [EIS[] nor the responses to comments directly address the failure to analyze potential impacts of an oil spill on Lake Superior and its watershed."

Sign up: Subscribe to our daily newsletters

The Star Tribune reports that having to redo the EIS could take "months," providing another potential delay to the long-planned project.

In a statement, Enbridge said the EIS approved by the PUC was the "most extensive ... study of a pipeline project in state history."

It'll now consult with the PUC and the State of Minnesota about the next step.

Frank Bibeau, the attorney for Honor the Earth, one of the groups that challenges the EIS, said: "Honor the Earth commends the Minnesota Court of Appeals ruling today, as [the EIS] blatantly ignored any impacts to four major water bodies in northern Minnesota.

"The Husky refinery fire made them realize that an oil spill release into our waterways was much more real than hypothetical. The ruling will allow adequate time for the PUC and Minnesota Department of Commerce to fix those deficiencies in the FEIS."

Less concerned is House Minority Leader Kurt Daudt, a long-time supporter of the project, who said it's positive that the court found against most of the arguments made by environmental and tribal groups.

"It's encouraging that the court rejected nearly all of the challenges brought by environmental groups who oppose this pipeline and the thousands of jobs that come with it," he said.

"Replacing aging infrastructure is the right thing to do for Minnesota; it's good our economy, it will grow jobs, and it will enhance environmental protection. This ruling should not change that, and should not stop this important project.

Next Up

police tape

3 at trauma centers in critical condition after rural MN attack

Two victims and the alleged attacker are in critical condition.

grinch neighbor

Neighborhood 'grinch' sends letter to Burnsville family over holiday lights

A Burnsville family's holiday decorations were the subject of an anonymous complaint.


Anthropologie shutters Grand Avenue store, opening planned for Rosedale Center

The popular holiday shopping weekend marked the last for customers of the Grand Avenue store.

hospital, emergency room

Woman found on side of highway after hit-and-run

The 41-year-old was airlifted to a hospital with life-threatening injuries.

Jorden Nicole Borders

Charges: Minnesota woman tortured her kids, removed boy's blood

Warning: This story contains upsetting content.

first snow

Will narrow band of 6+ inches of snow hit Twin Cities Tuesday?

The NWS says a band of 6+ inches is looking likely. It's now a matter of where.


Siblings, ages 19 and 14, killed in crash on icy MN highway

The crash happened around 1:15 a.m. Saturday in Carlton County.

Nicholas Kraus

Man sentenced for fatally striking woman during Uptown protest

Nicholas Kraus, 36, of St. Paul drove into a protest in Uptown last year, killing Deona Marie Knajdek.

Flickr - police lights squad siren - Edward Kimmel

Fleeing suspect crashes into vehicle in Woodbury, 2 injured

The crash occurred Friday afternoon after a pursuit with Woodbury police.

Screen Shot 2022-11-26 at 2.34.44 PM

Yes, that's MN native Jenny Taft in a State Farm commercial

Jenny Taft got her broadcasting career started in Minneapolis in 2011.

crime scene tape - police tape

23-year-old woman critical after shooting in Plymouth

A 23-year-old woman was shot Friday night in Plymouth.

white Christmas

2 MN towns among most 'magical' winter locations in the country

The list was compiled by Trips Discover and published earlier this month.


MN Supreme Court deals blow to opponents of Line 3 pipeline

The Supreme Court declined to take up a challenge against the project.

enbridge energy line 3

Oil will flow through Enbridge's Line 3 pipeline starting Friday

The controversial project is complete, Enbridge says.

enbridge energy line 3

MN appeals court upholds Line 3 pipeline approval

The decision is a blow to Tribal leaders and environmentalists fighting the project.

enbridge line 3

Minnesota DNR grants 2 approvals for Line 3 pipeline

The Enbridge pipeline replacement project would replace a crude oil pipeline in northern Minnesota.


Officials investigating possible spill near Enbridge pipeline in Wisconsin

It comes as another water spill is being reported at Enbridge's Line 3 pipeline in Minnesota.

Flickr - Enbridge Line 3 Palisade - Lorie Shaull

DNR orders Enbridge to pay $3.32M over Line 3 environmental violations

The pipeline company breached a groundwater aquifer, causing water to flow uncontrolled into a trench.

Enbridge Line 3

Line 3 pipeline worker rescued after being trapped underwater

It happened in Hubbard County, northwestern Minnesota.

jane fonda line 3

Jane Fonda in MN to join in protests of Line 3 pipeline

Construction on the Minnesota portion of the pipeline began in December.