Skip to main content

Franken asks feds to look into Apple's pricing policies for music streaming apps

  • Author:
  • Updated:

If you subscribe to Spotify's music streaming service through your computer, you'll pay $9.99 a month for the unlimited, ad-free, listen-anywhere service.

Subscribe through your iPhone's App Store though, and you'll pay $12.99 – for the exact same service. If you want Rdio, you're hit with a similar discrepancy.

That's got Al Franken concerned.

The Democratic U.S. Senator from Minnesota wrote a letter (click here to read it) to Attorney General Loretta Lynch and Federal Trade Commission Chairwoman Edith Ramirez, asking them to examine Apple's policies with its App Store and music streaming services, and whether those practices are anticompetitive.

At the heart of Franken's concern is the so-called "Apple Tax." It's a 30 percent fee that Apple charges app developers on any revenue made from in-app purchases that are operated on an Apple device.

In the case of Spotify or Rdio, the subscription cost is $9.99 – Apple then asks for a 30 percent cut on that platform, so the streaming services up their price to $12.99 only on that platform. (Rdio explains this briefly in its FAQ.)

Spotify actually sent out an email to users this month, telling them they can get their subscription cheaper through the Spotify website, Business Insiders notes.

This is all happening just a week after Apple launched its own streaming service, Apple Music – which is priced at $9.99 no matter where a user signs up, Variety notes.

Apps linking out 'will be rejected'

There's another problem, Franken argues: The App Store guidelines means the content provider can't explain the price difference to customers through that device.

The licensing agreements "have prevented companies from using their apps to inform users that lower prices are available through their own websites, to advertise the availability of promotional discounts, or to complete a transaction directly with a consumer within their app," Franken writes in the letter.

Indeed, in the App Store guidelines, it gives the example of offering a "buy" button in an app that directs users to an outside website to purchase an item, such as a book. It says apps that "link to external mechanisms for purchases or subscriptions ... will be rejected."

Franken says those restrictions "seem to offer no competitive benefit" and could undermine the competitive process, with consumers paying above what the current market is dictating.

The senator's letter actually came a day after The Verge reported that the Federal Trade Commission was already investigating Apple.

The tech news website says the commission is looking at the 30 percent "Apple Tax" and how it impacts music streaming services. The FTC has issued subpoenas to such services to gather more information about the matter, according to The Verge.

Next Up

State Patrol

2 killed after vehicle crosses center line near Silver Lake

A toddler in the vehicle survived the crash.

Screen Shot 2022-08-10 at 4.12.14 PM

The answer to winter woes: St. Paul's upcoming Palm Springs-style supper club

Take a first look at inside the menu at The Apostle Supper Club.

Muhammad Masood

Guilty plea: Ex-Mayo Clinic researcher tried to fly to Syria and fight for ISIS

Muhammad Masood, 30, pleaded guilty to attempting to provide material support to a designated foreign terrorist organization in U.S. District Court Tuesday.

police lights squad car dark - Unsplash

Man says he was pistol-whipped, robbed at gunpoint by trio

The incident allegedly happened in Brooklyn Park early Friday morning.

Melissa Turtinen - MN State Fair 2021

Is the State Fair heatwave real, or an urban legend?

Sven Sundgaard checks the data behind the notion that the State Fair is Minnesota's 'last summer hurrah.'

Stillwater Prison

Investigation after inmate found dead in cell at Stillwater prison

Drug paraphernalia was found by officers inside the cell.

2 (3)

Focus is on family fitness at this year’s Twin Cities Marathon

Don’t miss out on the running, racing and all the fun things to do for the whole family

Screen Shot 2022-08-18 at 2.29.47 PM

Family's tributes to mother killed by partner in St. Paul murder-suicide

The 30-year-old was killed by her partner, who then killed himself.


Eagan man killed after crashing into traffic signal

The 30-year-old crashed into a traffic light early Wednesday morning.

Melvin Carter

What's in Mayor Melvin Carter's budget proposal?

Here's what the St. Paul mayor is putting his focus on for the upcoming year.