Skip to main content

Google says it gave search data to Edina police – but not everything they asked for

A search warrant has asked Google for personal info on any resident that Googled someone's name over a five-week period.

Edina police got some type of data from Google as part of an investigation – but the internet giant says it wasn't nearly as much as authorities had asked for.

The original story in this case was first reported by Tony Webster. He found a detective with the Edina Police Department applied for a search warrant to obtain Google search records. What did the detective want?

"[N]ames, email addresses, account information, and IP addresses of anyone who searched variations of the victim’s name over a five-week period of time," Webster wrote.

The investigation involves a resident who was scammed out of $28,500 – Edina police are trying to identify the culprit, as the Star Tribune explained.

So if a resident Googled the victim's name during those five weeks, your personal information could have been turned over to police as part of an active investigation.

A judge in February signed off on the request, Webster said.

The latest: Edina got ... something

This week, CityPages reported court documents indicate Edina investigators were able to access and download the search warrant results from an online portal Google had set up.

What was in them exactly? A spokesperson for Edina told GoMN they still can't comment because it's an ongoing investigation.

But Google, in a statement sent to GoMN by a spokesperson, said it was able to push back and make changes.

"We objected to the warrant and significantly narrowed its scope to the point that only one record was produced," the spokesperson said, adding they're "pleased" it got resolved "in a way that preserves our users' privacy."

The spokesperson said they can't offer any more details than that, since it's an ongoing criminal case.

Why the concern?

The ACLU of Minnesota when the story first broke called the request an "unreasonable search," and therefore a violation of the Fourth Amendment.

The Fourth Amendment says your personal possessions can not be searched without getting a warrant – and that there has to be "probable cause" to issue it.

The ACLU described Edina's request as "overbroad," saying it "compromises the privacy and data security of thousands of innocent people, 99 percent, or maybe 100 percent, of whom are not even suspected of criminal activity, much less guilty of it."

Figuring out how exactly the Fourth Amendment works in a time where people have online lives is one of the most-discussed legal challenges right now.

NPR did a story in 2013 explaining how court rulings in the 1970s and 1980s said the government does not need a search warrant to look at personal documents or information if you've shared it with somebody already.

So when you search online, there's an argument you're technically sharing that information with your internet service provider, and the search engine company itself.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation, which argues for more legal protections of search history, has more information on the issue here.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-10-07 at 11.13.49 AM

Celebrated barefoot water skier died in accident on Brooklyn Center lake

Paul Oman died in a barefoot water skiing accident on Sept. 12.

Screen Shot 2022-10-07 at 10.49.51 AM

Sisters now living in MN win $80K over treatment at Texas border facility

Kerlin Sanchez Villalobos and her sister were awarded a settlement of $80,000.

Minneapolis Fire Department

Series of garage fires cause damage in south Minneapolis

Two of the fires occurred on the 4500 block of Snelling Avenue.

Cedric Alexander

Minneapolis’ public safety chief spends evening mocking, blocking on Twitter

The community safety commissioner responded to one user's question about downtown policing by calling them two-faced.

Screen Shot 2022-10-06 at 4.04.40 PM

Ramen bar announced for upcoming Eat Street Crossing food hall

The restaurant roster is filling up at Eat Street Crossing.

police lights squad car dark - Unsplash

Man dies after being shot during argument in Minneapolis

It's the 70th homicide in Minneapolis this year.

NearNorthEncampment

Minneapolis police, city employees clear out Near North encampment

This comes as colder weather moves through the state.

Screen Shot 2022-10-06 at 4.32.46 PM

New T.J. Maxx to open in the Twin Cities this month

Opening day will kick off with extended hours.

Screen Shot 2022-10-06 at 3.04.24 PM

Former Hennepin County commissioner arrested for DWI

The 61-year-old was being held in Hennepin County Jail as of Thursday morning.

Evie Carshare

Electric carshare network showing growth in Twin Cities

Over 25,000 trips have been logged in a six-month span.

Screen Shot 2022-10-06 at 1.11.01 PM

Popular Apple Valley ice arena could be replaced

A concept plan to transform the ice arena is being considered.

Related

What happened to the proposal to stop internet providers selling MN customers' data?

It got a lot of support – but right now isn't included in any bill. Here's what is going on.

New proposal: Internet companies should pay you if they use or sell your data

It's your data that's valuable – should you get compensated for it?

Forever 21 says it was probably hit by a data breach

If you bought something there with a card, this might affect you.

Minnesota internet provider says it will never sell your browsing history

"We have never sold member web browsing history and have no plans to do so in the future," said the ISP's CEO.

How big a deal is this hack of Minnesota government and MSU Moorhead servers?

Email addresses, encrypted passwords, user IDS – what someone could do with the information.

WikiLeaks leak claims CIA can get past phone encryption, hack into Smart TVs

This leak of more than 8,000 files has not been authenticated – though it appears legitimate.

Hacker continues to jab Minnesota institutions, this time going at the U of M

The hacker already accessed state government and MSU Moorhead data without authorization.