Skip to main content

Hamline University faculty voted Tuesday to ask President Fayneese Miller to resign amid criticism of how she responded to a Muslim student's complaint surrounding an image of the Prophet Muhammad shown in an art history class

Following the student’s complaint, school officials decided not to ask then adjunct professor Dr. Erika López Prater back for another semester, the New York Times reported.

López Prater included advanced notice about the image in the course syllabus and again warned students before displaying the 14-century painting during an online class, according to the NYT. No students reached out to López Prater to voice concerns.

The course syllabus, reviewed by MPR News, stated the course would introduce students to several religious traditions and the visual cultures they've produced historically, which would include showing depictions of holy figures, including the Prophet Muhammad.

In the aftermath of the incident, Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR-MN) Executive Director Jaylani Hussein said such images are widely considered sacrilegious and hate speech within the Muslim community. 

The incident sparked global debate over free speech and academic freedom and Prater has since brought a lawsuit against the university over the matter. 

Over 86% of Hamline faculty who took part in Tuesday's vote supported Miller's resignation, according to Jim Scheibel, president of the Hamline University Faculty Council. 

In an interview Monday with the Star Tribune, Miller described the incident as a "learning experience." 

Aram Wedatalla, the Hamline student who made the complaint, has commended Miller's response and support for Muslim students. 

Next Up

Fire truck department firefighters

Smoking likely caused motorized scooter fire that killed woman in Ely

Police said the woman was a resident at the Boundary Waters Care Facility.

Minnesota State Patrol

Burnsville man killed, two others injured in Wednesday crash

The crash occurred Wednesday afternoon at the intersection of Highway 61 and 190th Street East.

Family remembers woman killed by suspected drunk-driver in St. Louis Park

A 38-year-old man is charged in connection with her death.

Sean Sherman

Sean Sherman will open new restaurant in Seward Co-op Creamery building

The new hub will be the headquarters of NATIFS with a commissary kitchen and counter-service restaurant.

St. Cloud Mayor Dave Kleis provides fis 20th and final State of the City speech on Tuesday, Jan. 7, 2025 in St. Cloud, Minn.

St. Cloud's longest-running mayor Dave Kleis gives final State of the City speech

Kleis is set to leave office next week after serving the role for the past 20 years.

EGGFLIP/SUSHIFLIP

Sushi, Korean-style egg sandwiches headed to Minneapolis food hall

The Market at Malcolm Yards will welcome a new addition this month.

Screenshot 2025-01-08 at 2.08.29 PM

New York Times story on 'great New York slices' features 2 Minneapolis restaurants

The praise comes just months after the paper named Chef Ann Kim's Young Joni as one of the best pizza hubs in the country.

Related

image

Hamline University president announces retirement months after art controversy

The university will conduct a national search to find Fayneese Miller's successor.

Screen Shot 2023-01-13 at 12.25.21 PM

Hamline University at the center of far-reaching debate over academic freedom

The private institute in St. Paul continues making headlines around the globe.

Hamline University - 1537 Hewitt Ave, St Paul, Minnesota - June 2019

Hamline University requiring COVID vaccine for upcoming school year

The president, citing a goal of returning to normal, called the mandate "necessary."

Marcheta Evans

St. Catherine University selects Marcheta Evans as its 12th president

Evans will become the first Black president of the St. Paul institution.

Street View - Mitchell Hamline campus - St Paul

COVID vaccinations required for students, faculty on Mitchell Hamline campus

The new policy goes into effect Aug. 1 and will last through the fall semester.

University of Minnesota President Eric Kaler stepping down

Kaler has been on the job at the U of M for more than seven years.

image

One dead in overnight shooting in St. Paul's Hamline-Midway neighborhood

Police are investigating a fatal shooting on a residential street.