Skip to main content

Minnesota high court reverses convictions in aiding-suicide case

  • Author:
  • Updated:
    Original:

The Minnesota Supreme Court on Wednesday reversed the convictions of a former nurse accused of encouraging two people he met online to kill themselves and deemed part of a state law that makes it illegal to encourage suicide unconstitutional.

The court ruled that the language in the state's assisted-suicide law is unconstitutional when it comes to "encouraging" suicides, but it found the part of the law that bans "assisting" suicide is constitutional, the Associated Press says.

William Melchert-Dinkel, 51, worked as a licensed practical nurse in a Fairbault nursing home. He was accused of seeking out depressed people in online suicide chat rooms and offering instructions on how they could kill themselves, and he lost his license as a result of the allegations.

Melchert-Dinkel was convicted on two counts of "encouraging, advising or assisting another in committing suicide" in the deaths of 32-year-old Mark Drybrough, of Coventry, England, who hanged himself in 2005; and 18-year-old Nadia Kajouji, of Brampton, Ontario, who jumped into a frozen river in 2008. In 2011, he was sentenced to a year in jail, but the sentence has been on hold pending the outcome of his appeal.

In July 2012, the Court of Appeals agreed with the lower court and affirmed the conviction. Melchert-Dinkel then appealed to the Supreme Court.

Melchert-Dinkel argued that the law was too broad and his conduct was protected speech.

In Wednesday's decision, the Supreme Court said the portion of the law that criminalizes "assisting" suicide does not violate the First Amendment "because it is narrowly drawn to serve a compelling government interest," the Fairbault Daily News says. But the district court made no findings about whether Melchert-Dinkel "assisted" in the suicides – he had been convicted on the basis of "encouraging" suicide, according to the Pioneer Press. So the high court sent the case against Melchert-Dinkel back to the district court for more hearings on the issue of whether he assisted in the suicides.

The Minnesota Supreme Court will also hear arguments in a similar case, but proceedings in that case have been stayed pending the outcome of the Melchert-Dinkel case, the Pioneer Press reports. In that case, members of the Final Exit Network are accused of helping former musician Doreen Dunn, 57, of Apple Valley commit suicide in May 2007.

Next Up

bmw-g1a1c50760_1280

Police: Teens 'careen recklessly' in stolen BMW, Mercedes in north metro

They ended up crashing the stolen vehicles, with two arrested and two others on the run.

fire truck

Fire table sparks blaze at Edina home

The fire remains under investigation, but fire officials believe it was accidental.

money hundred dollar bills

Charges: California woman embezzled over $1M from MN employer

Mai Xiong faces several federal charges in the case.

Hsa Law Yaw Say

Shot woman who sparked appeal found injured at Twin Cities hotel

Authorities began searching for Hsa Say early Monday morning.

image

Development may bring changes to Stonebrooke Golf Club in 2023

The popular southwest metro golf course offers scenic views of O'Dowd Lake.

image

Homeowners alert DNR to grouse hunting complaints in Northland

Some hunters are allegedly shooting directly in front of houses.

STPTeensChildTortureRCJ

Charges: Teen couple tortured children while babysitting in St. Paul

A doctor called this "the worst case of abuse he has seen in over 20 years."

Myth

New apartment proposal could spell the end for Myth Live

Myth Live in Maplewood has a spotty past with the surrounding community.

Hsa Law Yaw Say

Police trying to find woman, 18, who was shot at in St. Paul

Police are looking for help finding the woman.

image

Is an Amazon grocery store coming to Woodbury?

There's six rumored stores in the Twin Cities.

ambulance

Man sentenced to life in prison for 2021 murder of girlfriend

Lacy Jo Krube, 36, was found unresponsive at her St. Paul home, after she'd been beaten in Brooklyn Park.

Related