House, Senate disagree on policing bills with time running out in Special Session

House leaders say the Senate's bills don't do enough to enact systemic change.
Publish date:

The two chambers of the Minnesota Legislature are considering largely different bills on policing in the wake of George Floyd's killing, which doesn't bode well for bills getting passed by the end of the Special Session seeing as the Senate says it will end on Friday

The Special Session was initially intended to deal with issues related to the COVID-19 pandemic, but the focus shifted to sweeping policing changes in Minnesota after the May 25 death of Floyd.

"So far, we're still in gridlock. So far, we've had the entire week to move things. But now is the time," Gov. Tim Walz said during a news conference Thursday, urging Senate Republican leaders to work with House Democrats on police reform bills

The Senate approved five bills this week related to police reform, including a ban on most chokeholds, a requirement for law enforcement to report use-of-force data to the state and requiring a duty to intervene and report for officers on the scene of an excessive force incident. 

But the legislation, which still needs to be passed by the Democratic-controlled House before it becomes law, has been criticized for not doing enough to enact real change and because Senate Republicans didn't work with senators of color in coming up with the legislation.

In a news release from House Democrats on Wednesday, House Speaker Melissa Hortman said: "Not a single item in the Senate proposals addresses the problem of a lack of accountability for police.

"The House proposals, shaped by working with members of our communities, would take the first steps in making systemic change that will lead to accountability.”

The House is slated to take up its police reform legislation Thursday night. According to Session Daily, the Democratic-controlled chamber has three main public safety and law enforcement accountability bills amended onto Senate files to include the House language. 

Among the legislation the House is looking to pass include provisions that would require police officers to intercede with another officer is using excessive force and report the incident to supervisors; establish law enforcement citizen oversight councils and police officer residency requirements; ban chokeholds and prohibit "warrior-style training"; increase training and transparency for police officers, and clarify when police can use deadly force.

The proposals go a step further and aim to address systemic issues beyond just policing. Those provisions, if passed, would restore voting rights to convicted felons when they're released from prison regardless of supervision status, and eliminate the need for cash bail for most misdemeanor offenses. 

Next Up

Facebook - Conway Community Center fire June 20 2021 - SPFD

Fire at St. Paul community center may have been started intentionally

The blaze was reported in the early hours of Sunday morning.

TCF Bank Stadium

Gophers announce sporting events will be at full capacity in 2021-22

Teams had to play in front of empty arenas and stadiums in 2020 due to COVID-19.

YoUTube - ISD 197 screengrab

School board approves new name for Henry Sibley High School

But the decision to rename the Mendota Heights school wasn't unanimous.

Stock market chart

Charges: 2 Minnesota men made thousands on 'pump-and-dump' scheme

They're accused of hijacking shell companies and pumping up stock prices before selling them for profit.


Edina executive slams Delta after he's accused of trafficking daughter with special needs

The letter comes after a recent flight in which he was accused of human trafficking.

police tape, crime scene

More human body parts found in Minneapolis

The body parts have now been found in three locations.

Screen Shot 2019-08-19 at 8.08.05 PM

Three people shot outside bar in Dayton's Bluff neighborhood

Police were called to the scene early Sunday morning after two men and a woman were shot outside Cheers Pub.

Byron Buxton

Buxton's latest injury overshadows SanĂ³'s walk off bomb

The Twins outfielder could miss a month with a fractured left hand.

Jaylen Twyman

Vikings rookie Jaylen Twyman shot in Washington D.C.

The sixth-round pick is expected to make a full recovery



MN Senate ends special session with no deal on police reform

Lawmakers failed to agree on other critical legislation as well.


MN Senate passes public safety bill without DFL-backed police reform measures

Democrats say the bill doesn't do enough to address police accountability.


Walz announces new special session to pass police reform, bonding

Gov. Tim Walz has called a special session that starts Monday.

State Capitol

MN House passes omnibus public safety bill with police reform measures

The Senate previously passed its omnibus public safety bill without police accountability legislation.


Special session Monday to focus on COVID-19 relief for businesses, workers

After disagreeing on how long unemployment benefits should last, it appears lawmakers have reached a deal.

State Capitol.

DFLers demand more police reform, GOP says it'll hold hearings on proposals

Democrats have been calling for change since Daunte Wright's death, and now Republicans say they'll hold hearings on bills but haven't made promises it'll lead to anything getting passed.