Skip to main content

New Medicare data show how Minnesota doctors compare

  • Author:
  • Updated:

Minnesota ranks in about the middle among the states when it comes to Medicare doctor reimbursements, according to new data released this week by the the Center for Medicare Services.

In Minnesota in 2012, health care providers were reimbursed an average of 30 percent of the costs of Medicare-related bills.

This breaks down to an average of almost $33,000 per provider for the 819,803 Medicare beneficiaries in the state, according to an analysis of the federal data by USA Today.

That's just over the country’s median payment — the point at which half the amounts are higher and half are lower — of $30,265, The AP reports.

Check out this map. 

In all, the data show, Medicare paid 880,644 health care providers a total of $77.4 billion in 2012. The number of procedures, total pay and reimbursement rates varied by provider type.

More on Minnesota docs

The numbers are the most detailed data ever released in Medicare’s nearly 50-year history, The New York Times reports.

The unprecedented data reveal the wide range of reimbursements to doctors, clinics and other health care providers that provide Medicare services across the country.

Just a small fraction of the 880,644 health care providers who accept Medicare took home nearly a quarter of the roughly $77 billion paid out to them under the federal program, receiving millions of dollars each in some cases in a single year.

The New York Times reports in 2012, just 100 doctors received a total of $610 million, ranging from a Florida ophthalmologist who was paid $21 million by Medicare to dozens of doctors, eye and cancer specialists chief among them, who received more than $4 million each that year.

While more money by far is spent for routine office visits than any other single expenditure, one of the most heavily reimbursed procedures — costing a total of $1 billion for 143,000 patients — is for a single treatment for an eye disorder common in the elderly.

About 1 in 4 of the top-paid doctors — 87 of them — practice in Florida, a state known both for high Medicare spending and widespread fraud.

Rounding out the top five states were California with 38 doctors in the top group, New Jersey with 27, Texas with 23, and New York with 18, The AP reports.

One ophthalmologist alone, Salomon Melgen, took in more than $20 million from Medicare in 2012, USA Today reports.

Last year, Melgen's offices were raided by the FBI and Department of Health and Human Services. Melgen has said he had done nothing wrong.

Federal officials say they released the data now to enhance transparency, Niall Brennan, acting director of the Center for Medicare Services Office of Enterprise Management.

Although Medicare is financed by taxpayers, the data have been off limits to the public for decades. Physician organizations went to court to block its release, arguing it would amount to an invasion of doctors' privacy.

But employers, insurers, consumer groups and media organizations lobbied for the release of the data. They argued the data could help guide patients to doctors who provide quality, cost-effective care.

A federal judge last year lifted the main legal obstacle to release, and the Obama administration recently informed the American Medical Association it would open up the claims data.

The American Medical Association expressed concern that the release of raw payment data may lead patients to the wrong conclusions.

“The AMA is concerned that CMS’ broad approach to releasing physician payment data will mislead the public into making inappropriate and potentially harmful treatment decisions, and will result in unwarranted bias against physicians that can destroy careers,” Ardis Dee Hoven, president of the Chicago-based group, wrote in an e-mail to Business Week.

Some of the numbers may be inaccurate and doctors haven’t been given a chance to review the data and make corrections, Hoven says.

The data doesn’t show whether charges and payments under one doctor’s name apply to procedures done by other doctors in their employ, potentially increasing the amount of money they receive and the number of patients they care for.

But the data offer valuable insight into doctors’ billing practices across a variety of specialties.

USA Today reports the new access to the data also could help law enforcement track down fraud in the system.

And the data could be used by the consumers themselves, says Gail Wilensky, former Medicaid program director under President George H.W. Bush.

"This will be part and parcel of what we're trying to do in this country of getting more consumer involvement," she says. "An employer group can look at outcome data. They have big samples. And they can look at other physician groups with similar populations."

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-06-25 at 11.01.17 AM

Woman breaks free after being kidnapped and taken to Brooklyn Park

The woman was taken by force as she arrived at her work in Plymouth.


How the fastest animal on the planet returned to MN after local extinction

The fastest animal on Earth had once vanished from Minnesota and Wisconsin.


St. Paul's new 'skate trail' brings non-traditional park to life

Gateway Park is the first of four parks to open in the Highland Bridge redevelopment.


80 mph winds, large hail possible with severe storms in MN

A severe thunderstorm watch is in effect for much of the state until 3 a.m. Saturday.


30 people evacuated as flooding hammers small town

It's assumed that at least eight inches of rain fell in Randall, with more heavy rain expected Friday night into Saturday morning.

Intersection in Rochester.

Boy dies in motorcycle crash in Rochester

Police are investigating as of Friday afternoon.

Tab2FileL (13)

Numerous severe storms likely in Minnesota Friday night

Watch the video for the full details with meteorologist Sven Sundgaard.

court room

Teen pleads guilty in shooting death of 15-year-old girl in Columbia Heights

Damico Jamal-Tokyo High will receive a sentence in juvenile court, along with an adult prison sentence.

Screen Shot 2022-04-25 at 11.00.01 AM

Walz wants to use surplus money to send direct payments to Minnesotans

It's a renewed effort from a previous proposal from Walz and Lt. Gov. Peggy Flanagan's supplemental budget in January.

Ron Johnson

Jan. 6 committee says aide for WI senator tried to give fake elector info to Pence

The attempt was discovered through text messages in the ongoing public hearing held by the Jan. 6 select committee.

Stock U of M sign

Minnesota State colleges, U of M boosting tuition again

The Minnesota State system's Board of Trustee's approved the increase Wednesday.