It looks like the insulin bill everyone agrees on won't get passed

An apparent clerical error has caused the issue, and a blame game has ensued.
Publish date:

Despite bipartisan support, a bill aimed at providing Minnesotans with more affordable insulin failed to make its way into final budget negotiations, leaving lawmakers on both sides pointing fingers.

The Alec Smith Emergency Insulin Act is named for the Minnesota resident and diabetic who died at age 26 after he was unable to afford insulin. 

The bill would establish a manufacturer fee for Minnesota’s three largest insulin providers in order to fund an assistance program for those who cannot afford the life-saving drug.

Senate and House versions of the policy previously passed with bipartisan support (the Senate amendment passing unanimously 67-0), with the family of Alec Smith having lobbied in support of the bill, meeting with lawmakers throughout the session.

But a miscommunication between chambers left the bill out of final budget negotiations.

There were late efforts in the early hours of Saturday morning via an emergency insulin amendment in the Senate, but that failed in a near-party line vote 33-34, with only one Republican breaking with caucus to vote in favor of the amendment, Rochester Sen. Carla Nelson.

In a tweet, Senate Majority Leader Paul Gazelka noted that his Republicans had passed other measures to reduce the cost of insulin.

How did we get here?

A conference committee of House and Senate lawmakers had been tasked with passing the health and human services omnibus bill during the recently-declared special session. But the final bill list for the committee did not include the Alec Smith act.

Speaker of the House Melissa Hortman said in a press conference Friday that the bill would not move forward.

“The very last thing that we fought with the Republicans for and we were unable to achieve that this year. I’m hopeful we might be able to do it next year,” she said.

Senate Health and Human Services Finance and Policy chair Sen. Michelle Benson (R-Ham Lake) said the policy was not a part of the final negotiating spreadsheet provided by the House in closed-door negotiations.

As a result, she and other Republican Senators have claimed, the provision was not included in the final health and human services budget.

Benson’s stated the issue had become a “political punching bag” and highlighted other insulin affordability measures in the final budget. She said lawmakers now need to move forward with the negotiated budget.

Sign up: Subscribe to our daily newsletters

Sen. Jim Abeler (R-Anoka), chair of the Human Services Finance and Policy committee, also took to Twitter, stating the bill was not included or mentioned in any negotiations he was part of.

“The word 'insulin' was not mentioned in our large working group meetings. Nor in the two tribunal meetings I was part of. Also no bonafide spreadsheet offer was made,” he tweeted.

DFL lawmakers have fired back at the claims. Rep. Michael Howard (DFL-Richfield), an author of the House bill, said in a statement Thursday that Senate Republicans have refused to reopen negotiations to include the policy in the budget.

“Senate Republicans owe Minnesotans an explanation for why they would go out of their way to stop such an important, life-saving bill that had broad, bipartisan support,” Benson’s statement reads.

In a letter to the conference committee Thursday, Sen. John Marty (DFL-Roseville) urged lawmakers to reopen negotiations and include either the House or Senate versions in the final omnibus bill. 

Next Up


Golf spots still available for the Rod Simons Memorial Golf for the Gift of Adoption

The annual golf tournament is THIS TUESDAY at Troy Burne in Hudson, Wisconsin.

police tape, crime scene

Police investigating Saturday homicide in Austin

Officers responded to a report of a woman shot in a house in Austin just before 2 a.m. Saturday.

fire, firefighter

2 dead in Wadena County house fire, boy survives

The fire was reported around 3:50 a.m. Sunday.

Jose Berrios

BerrĂ­os dominates in first start with Blue Jays

The former Twin made a great first impression with his new team.

Lauri Markkanen

Report: Timberwolves interested in sign-and-trade for Lauri Markkanen

The Wolves will look to upgrade at power forward in free agency.

Suni Lee

Suni Lee, Regan Smith take home Olympic medals Sunday

Lee won bronze in the uneven bars final, while Smith won silver in the 4x100-meter medley relay.

Screen Shot 2021-08-01 at 9.16.26 AM

'Zero respect for authority': Olmsted Co. Fair wracked by wave of juvenile disturbances

Fair officials imposed strict new rules to deal with the problem.

ambulance, crash

Baby dies, 5 injured when SUV flips over fence onto I-94 in Brooklyn Center

Alcohol was detected on the driver, according to the State Patrol.

minneapolis police

Police say officers were shot at in north Minneapolis

Officers were checking into a suspicious activity report when gunfire erupted.


Walmart to mandate COVID vaccine for some managers, corporate employees

The company will also reinstate mask mandates for employees in high-transmission areas.

Minneapolis police

Driver plows into crowd after downtown Minneapolis brawl

Two suspects have reportedly been identified.


Minnesota House passes emergency insulin bill, despite GOP opposition

There remains disagreement over how affordable insulin access should be funded.


What's holding up insulin price bills in the Legislature?

House DFLers are pointing the finger at Senate Republicans.


MN lawmakers work on emergency insulin bill, disagree on funding

There's hope an insulin bill can pass sooner than later.

What happened to Minnesota's $500M infrastructure bill?

There wasn't enough time to get a bonding bill over the line, amid pushback from Republicans.


Health insurer to cap insulin prices for Minnesota patients

The move comes as rising costs have prompted action at the state Capitol.


Another MN-based insurer will cap insulin prices

The move comes as officials continue to debate how to address rising insulin costs.