Judge denies Let Them Play MN lawsuit related to youth sports

The group is appealing the judge's decision.
Author:
Publish date:

A federal judge has denied a group of parents' lawsuit against  Gov. Tim Walz over their right to protest the pause on youth sports. 

Let Them Play MN, which has more than 24,000 Facebook members, filed the lawsuit on Dec. 10 challenging Walz's executive order, saying it violated their First Amendment rights to protest the pause.

And on Friday, Judge John Tunheim denied their motion for a preliminary injunction because the lawsuit failed to prove the group's claims. The judge also denied the group's request for expedited discovery related to state COVID-19 data regarding youth sports. 

Tunheim wrote: 

"The state’s temporary restriction on social gatherings that is the subject of this challenge is another grim result of the rapid spread of a dangerous virus that has ravaged Minnesota as it has the United States and much of the world. No one is in favor of limiting cherished constitutional rights, nor should they be. But the State’s measured response, focused directly on the likely causes of the recent surge, satisfies judicial scrutiny. It is hoped that the restrictions on public activity will prove successful and brief."

Let Them Play MN is appealing the decision, MPR News' Brian Bakst tweeted. In a news release, the group said it has filed an emergency appeal asking for the court to overturn Tunheim's order and requesting a new judge, citing the judge's conflict of interest. 

“Gov. Walz’s ban on youth sports hurts 500,000 kids and does not slow the spread of COVID,” Dawn Gillman, founder of the group, said in a statement. “And the same executive orders forbid protests about our disagreement. Minnesota and Minnesota’s kids deserve better.”

Walz's latest executive order allows sports practices to resume on Jan. 4. No dates have been announced when games can resume.

Next Up

Image from iOS (1)

Victim killed in multi-vehicle crash that closed Hwy. 62 ID'd as woman, 23

The four-vehicle crash closed the eastbound highway for several hours.

protest, Daunte Wright, Brooklyn Center

Photographer reports being maced and punched by police, other journalists detained

It came just hours after a court order prevented law enforcement from using force against the news media.

51119874206_73072b910b_k

Police move in swiftly to make arrests on 6th night of Daunte Wright protests

What started out peaceful took a turn as the night drew in.

Michelle missing outing

Man pleads guilty in 2019 murder of Outing woman

Joshua Emil Karjala's sentencing is set for June.

Screen Shot 2020-12-06 at 7.25.01 AM

Sven Sundgaard is suing former employer KARE 11

The meteorologist, who now works with Bring Me The News, was fired in May 2020.

Related

basketball

Let Them Play MN sues Walz over youth sports mask mandate

The CDC says masks may make it hard to breathe in high-intensity sports.

hockey

Parents file federal lawsuit against Gov. Walz over pause on youth sports

Let Them Play MN filed the lawsuit on behalf of several unnamed youth players and coaches.

hockey rink ice arena

Masks required: Youth, high school sports games can begin Jan. 14

Additional guidance on games and spectators is forthcoming.

softball

Youth sports games can resume outdoors next week, indoors in July

The latest guidance issued by the Minnesota Department of Health came out Friday afternoon.

covid, bars

MDH claims it's seeing increase in COVID cases traced to dining, sports

The increases were expected with some restrictions being lifted.

court gavel

Judge makes point about officer's racist language in lawsuit opinion

The judge made sure to call out the officer for his potentially racist remarks.

state hockey tournament, mshsl

MN health leaders want prep sports halted amid COVID-19 surge

Gov. Walz said new guidance will be released "within the next day or so."