Skip to main content

Klobuchar's proposal to hold Facebook, Google and Twitter accountable for shady election ads

Sen. Amy Klobuchar has a proposal that would close the online election ad loophole.

When someone buys a political ad on TV or radio in the weeks before an election, they generally have to file a report. It includes things like who bought the ad, how much money was spent, and which candidates are referred to.

When someone buys a political ad online, say through Facebook or Google? None of that needs to be disclosed.

It's those "outdated" laws that Sen. Amy Klobuchar and two of her colleagues are taking aim at, introducing a bill to make internet election ads far more transparent.

The Honest Ads Act would bring paid internet and digital advertisements more in line with the standards TV and radio are held to, according to Klobuchar's announcement.

Any digital platform with at least 50 million monthly viewers (peanuts to Facebook) would have to keep a public file of all "electioneering communications" (election-related ads, paid for in the couple months before the election) if the ad buy was more than $500. It would have to include:

  • A digital copy of the ad.
  • A description of the audience the ad targeted.
  • How many views the ad got.
  • The date and time it was published.
  • How much the ad cost.
  • And contact information for whoever bought it.

Those online platforms would also be required to undertake "all reasonable efforts" to make sure foreign individuals and groups are not buying ads to try to interfere with an election.

Klobuchar painted it as "an issue of national security."

"Russia attacked us and will continue to use different tactics to undermine our democracy and divide our country, including by purchasing disruptive online political ads," she said. 

She introduced the proposal Thursday with Sens. Mark Warner (Democrat from Virginia) and John McCain (Republican from Arizona).

Why this is a big deal

Facebook in September revealed thousands of ads were purchased by Russian accounts leading up to and after the 2016 election. The goal of those ads was generally to inflame and manipulate political discussion by touching on hypersensitive topics: gun control or racial justice, for example.

After Facebook came forward, the New York Times said Google found Russia-linked election ads had been bought on its websites, such as YouTube and Gmail. Russian-linked Twitter accounts also spent more than a quarter-million dollars on that platform, CNBC said.

Foreign nationals can not give money or help in connection with any election in the U.S. It's also illegal for them to donate to any political party or organization, at any level, or advocate for (or against) a specific candidate. It's all in the FEC's rules.

But according to Reuters, the law only covers TV and radio – it does not mention online.

Whether election laws were violated in this whole Russia-online ads saga is not clear right now, as the Washington Post explains. If the Russian accounts had any type of help or coordination with a campaign, or if the ads clearly endorse a candidate, then yeah, it probably was illegal.

If the ads were broader, then there might be some legal wiggle room, the Washington Post says.

Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg in late September announced new rules about ad transparency, including better review of political ads. 

But the technology shift over the past 15 years has created an online loophole in the laws of the U.S. (Slate dives into it more here) that Klobuchar, Warner and McCain argue should be closed.

"This bipartisan legislation would help protect our democracy by updating our laws to ensure that political ads sold online are covered by the same rules as TV or radio stations – and make them public so Americans can see who is trying to influence them," said Klobuchar.

Next Up

Governor Tim Walz

Walz, judge in dispute over Feeding Our Future case

A Ramsey County judge disputed Walz's claims that the Minnesota Department of Education was ordered by the court to resume payments to Feeding Our Future.

ambulance

2 dead, 1 with life-threatening injuries in Hwy. 7 crash

Both drivers were not wearing their seatbelt, according to the State Patrol.

Screen Shot 2022-09-25 at 11.50.33 AM

15-year-old Richfield football game shooting suspect arrested

A 16-year-old accused of instigating the altercation is also in custody.

Police tape

3 arrested after homicide, burglary in Inver Grove Heights

Charges of first-degree murder and first-degree burglary are pending.

fire, firefighter

Woman dies after becoming trapped in Waseca house fire

Police tried to enter the home but heavy smoke prevented them from getting inside.

ambulance

1 dead, 2 with life-threatening injuries in Minnesota crash

The crash happened just after 7:30 p.m. Friday.

Image (1)

School bus carrying students plunges into river southwest of Fargo

None of the kids suffered life-threatening injuries, though some were taken to area hospitals.

Richfield High School

Richfield High School cancels weekend events after shooting

Two men were shot outside the school's football stadium

Screen Shot 2022-09-23 at 10.21.38 PM

Sound of shots, mass panic at Richfield football game streamed live on YouTube

Gunfire caused panic at a varsity football game Friday night.

J. Gordon

K-9 search leads to $36K fentanyl seizure during traffic stop

A traffic stop was made after the vehicle was seen speeding through the area.

Related

Watch: Al Franken loses his mind while quizzing Facebook lawyer about Russian ads

The senator shouted at Facebook's lawyer about ads bought with Russian roubles.

Update: Franken explains why Russian ads on Facebook bring up 'serious concerns'

Facebook said Russian accounts ran ads specifically about divisive issues in America.

Report of Russian cyberattack days before election has Klobuchar concerned

A leaked NSA document published by The Intercept says Russian intelligence launched a cyberattack days before the election.

Instagram Stories is getting photo and video ads

Instagram rolled out Stories last August, and has added a bunch of new features – including ads now.

Facebook's new endorse a candidate feature is a glorified status update

Because what we all need is more chances to talk politics in Facebook comments.

Facebook's big change to your news feed shows it still doesn't know how to fix its problems

An upcoming change to your news feed indicates the company doesn't know what to do.

Facebook is trying to make fewer crappy links show up on your feed

You know the ones – where the page you go to is full of an absurd number of ads.

Klobuchar asks what steps were taken to protect 2016 election from cyber threats

Sen. Amy Klobuchar – with 25 other supporters in the Senate – wants a detailed explanation.