Skip to main content

Unusual sentence: Man gets a weekend in jail for next 10 years

  • Author:
  • Updated:

A Winona County District Court judge handed down an uncommon sentence for a 21-year-old Minnesota City man who was convicted in a crash that killed Ruth Doris Brendel, 85, of Winona.

Robert John Tofstad pleaded guilty to criminal vehicular homicide last year.

The Winona Daily News says on the morning of Feb 19, 2012, Tofstad, who was 19 at the time, was behind the wheel of a car that struck Brendel as she was walking to a Sunday church service in downtown Winona.

The woman died at the hospital later that day.

Investigators said the right side of the car's windshield and all the side windows were frosted over, preventing Tofstad from seeing anything to the right of his vehicle where Brendel had been walking.

Tofstad had a blood-alcohol content of 0.014 percent from "a few drinks" the night before, the newspaper reported.

Judge Jeffrey D. Thompson sentenced Tofstad on Oct. 3 to 60 days in jail and 10 years probation. Thompson also added a provision that Tofstad spend the weekend closest to Feb. 19, the anniversary of Brendel's death, in jail every year for the duration of his probation.

Next Up

Semi into house near Sturgis, South Dakota

Semi drives into house near Sturgis, South Dakota

The force from the semi was so strong that the foundation of the house was moved.


18-year-old from Zumbrota dies in Goodhue County crash

The crash happened in rural Goodhue County around 8:45 a.m. Wednesday.

thomas beach, bde maka ska - lake calhoun

3 Minneapolis beaches closed due to E. coli contamination

No illnesses have been reported, according to the MPRB.


'Hockeyland' documentary debuting in Minnesota movie theaters

The documentary has received great reviews at numerous film festivals.

Flickr - police lights squad siren - Edward Kimmel

Former Minnesota Olympic runner accused of driving drunk in Eden Prairie crash

Police said the man's blood alcohol level was three times the legal limit.


Man, 79, killed in ATV rollover near Faribault

The man was declared dead at the scene.

minneapolis police

Woman fighting for her life after shooting in Minneapolis

The woman was shot only about a half-hour after a 14-year-old suffered critical injuries in an apparent accidental discharge.

prior lake high school

Two students face discipline over racist messages at Prior Lake High School

Families and students were largely uncooperative with the investigation.

Sharon and Herb Vasser

Cause of Hopkins house explosion that killed couple revealed

Sharon and Herb Vassar were killed in the explosion. Herb built the home back in 1962.

Arrows on target

Charges: Minnesota camp counselor fired arrows at kids, injuring boy

An 8-year-old boy was shot in the arm with an arrow.

North Shore Mayor Chris Swanson.

Two Harbors votes overwhelmingly to recall Mayor Chris Swanson

The mayor had been scrutinized for several things leading up to the vote Tuesday.

Screen Shot 2022-08-10 at 8.43.50 AM

Suspected gunman at large after homicide near Albert Lea

The 32-year-old suspect was last seen in a 2004 white Ford F-150 with Minnesota license number EUZ-057.