Skip to main content

Mining, the forest, and Trump: Why two MN Democrats are in a public fight

It's all over possible mining projects in 234,328 acres of the Superior National Forest.

The argument over mining in northeastern Minnesota's forest lands has two of the state's Democratic congressmen publicly at odds.

Rep. Rick Nolan (who represents the Iron Range and North Shore) wants 230,000 acres in the Superior National Forest to remain open to possible mining projects. And Rep. Betty McCollum (of St. Paul and the eastern Twin Cities area) is calling him out, accusing him of not protecting the environment after he asked President Donald Trump's administration for help.

Here's what led to their quarrel, and what each has said so far.

How we got here

OK, let's back up.

In January, the U.S. Forest Service – in its final days under the Obama administration – submitted a plan to make 234,328 acres of Superior National Forest land off limits to mine exploration. (Here's the order.) The reason was to protect the area from "potential adverse environmental impacts" that could come from exploring or developing mining operations.

That land all falls within Nolan's district (CD8), which covers the entire northeastern quadrant of Minnesota. That's an area where mining is a huge jobs creator.

When the Forest Service submitted that plan, Nolan called it "an anti-mining tactic and a waste of taxpayer dollars."

Nolan goes to the Trump administration

Fast forward a couple weeks. The Obama administration is out, the Trump administration is in.

Nolan sent a letter this week to the new faces at the U.S. Department of Agriculture, asking them to reverse the U.S. Forest Service's submitted plan to stop mine exploration on those acres because of its "negative impact" on his district. Though he reiterated he thinks water quality and wildlife needs to be protected.

"That being said, we should also never be afraid of exploration and discovery, or using science and facts to dictate important decisions," he said, arguing projects should go through the "proper, rigorous and thorough environmental process" that we've set up.

McCollum responds

Well, McCollum was none too pleased.

In a statement Wednesday, McCollum chided her fellow Minnesotan and Democrat Nolan for the letter, saying she's "deeply disappointed" in his request and saying the "assault on this natural treasure is misguided."

"Particularly disturbing is that Representative Nolan thinks the Trump administration will make its decision using ‘science and facts,’ which puts an outrageous amount of faith in an administration that denies climate science and has openly peddled ‘alternative facts,'" she said.

And Nolan fires back

Nolan responded later Wednesday, noting he was an original cosponsor of the legislation that established protections for the Boundary Waters Canoe Area (which is true).

And he doubled down on the process that's in place, noting there aren't any specific projects planned for the land right now. This U.S. Forest Service proposal would stop projects even before anyone has the chance to explore whether it could be done safely, he argued.

"Denying any business activity before you know what it is – and what kind of pollution abatement technology they will use or how effective it will be – lacks common sense and subverts the good, thorough and elaborate environmental review process we have in place," he said.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-08-14 at 10.24.22 AM

Teen driver crashes into parked payloader; 16-year-old passenger dies

The crash happened early Saturday morning in Waconia.

Screen Shot 2022-08-14 at 10.10.50 AM

Barrage of gunfire injures boy in Brooklyn Park; vehicles, apartments damaged

Police say they recovered evidence that more than 40 rounds were fired in the shooting.

Screen Shot 2022-08-14 at 9.15.07 AM

Minnesota Wild back away from thin blue line T-shirt giveaway

The giveaway backfired when word of it reached social media.

Screen Shot 2022-08-13 at 1.26.13 PM

Workers at Minneapolis Trader Joe's become 2nd in nation to unionize

The vote was certified by the National Labor Relations Board Friday.

ATV, all-terrain vehicle

Driver killed in ATV crash in Brooklyn Park

The crash occurred in Monroe Park Friday night.


Woman killed by suspected drunk-driver in St. Louis County

The crash occurred on Highway 21 in Embarrass Township Friday night.

Jaelyn Campbell

11-year-old girl missing from Mille Lacs County

Jaelyn Campbell was last seen in Onamia.

Screen Shot 2022-08-12 at 1.58.08 PM

2 ejected, 1 killed in crash that closed southbound I-35

The State Patrol says neither were wearing seat belts.

best buy

Best Buy makes job cuts weeks after warning of soft sales

The Richfield retailer has been dealing with a shift in consumer trends.

Screen Shot 2022-08-12 at 10.26.20 PM

Man makes 'vague comments' about Jewish people, smashes own car with club

It happened at a course that was founded as a Jewish country club 100 years ago.

Screen Shot 2022-08-12 at 9.59.07 PM

4 abandoned puppies found in a bucket in Willmar

The puppies were in good health when they were discovered.

Minneapolis police

Suspect of home invasion, murder in Minneapolis arrested in Wisconsin

There have been 57 deaths reported as homicides in Minneapolis this year.


What MN's lawmakers have said about the EPA, Trump's executive order

A look at MInnesota's U.S. senators and representatives, and their comments on the environment.

What the big mining and environment meeting in Duluth was all about

This all centers around more than 234,000 acres in the Superior National Forest.

Trump administration scraps Superior National Forest mining ban

The Forest Service had sought to protect 234,000 acres of forest from mining exploration.

PolyMet gets the forest land it wanted for that copper-nickel mine

PolyMet got the land. But what else has to happen before the mine gets approved?

Plans for a copper-nickel mine near the BWCA have been blocked

People worried about the environment are happy. The mining company is not.

A MN Democrat actually agrees with a Donald Trump suggestion

Longtime Democratic Rep. RIck Nolan had nice things to say about a proposal from Republican President Donald Trump.

Trump officially moves to advance the Dakota Access and Keystone pipelines

The two contested pipeline projects – Dakota Access and Keystone XL – have the official backing of the White House.

What Minnesota lawmakers thought of President Trump's address

What Minnesota's U.S. representatives and senators had to say about the president's speech.