Skip to main content

Minn. High Court upholds overturned conviction of HIV-positive man

  • Author:
  • Updated:
    Original:

The Minnesota Supreme Court sided with a Minneapolis man who is HIV positive and accused of illegally passing the virus to another man.

According to a court opinion filed Wednesday, the state's High Court affirmed the appellate court's decision to reverse an attempted first-degree assault conviction of Daniel James Rick, 32, because of the ambiguity of the law.

Two subdivisions of the law applied to this case. In 2011, a Hennepin County jury found Rick not guilty of the first subdivision, which involves sexual penetration without first informing the other person about a communicable disease.

However, the jury found Rick guilty of the second subdivision, which criminalizes the "transfer of blood, sperm, organs, or tissue, except as deemed necessary for medical research or if disclosed on donor screening forms.”

The Minnesota Court of Appeals said the second subdivision suggests transfers for medical reasons, not sexual activity, and overturned Rick's conviction.

The judges concluded that the provision is subject to more than one reasonable interpretation and it's up to state lawmakers to change the wording.

The opinion said, "it is the Legislature’s prerogative to reexamine the communicable-disease statute and amend it accordingly."

Gay rights groups said the state’s interpretation of the statute violated the rights of HIV-positive adults to engage in consensual sex even if they have told their partners about the disease, the Associated Press reported.

Hennepin County Attorney Mike Freeman tells the Star Tribune that his office will proceed with other pending cases against Rick while encouraging the Legislature to clarify the law.

Next Up

Muhammad Masood

Guilty plea: Ex-Mayo Clinic researcher tried to fly to Syria and fight for ISIS

Muhammad Masood, 30, pleaded guilty to attempting to provide material support to a designated foreign terrorist organization in U.S. District Court Tuesday.

police lights squad car dark - Unsplash

Man says he was pistol-whipped, robbed at gunpoint by trio

The incident allegedly happened in Brooklyn Park early Friday morning.

Melissa Turtinen - MN State Fair 2021

Is the State Fair heatwave real, or an urban legend?

Sven Sundgaard checks the data behind the notion that the State Fair is Minnesota's 'last summer hurrah.'

Stillwater Prison

Investigation after inmate found dead in cell at Stillwater prison

Drug paraphernalia was found by officers inside the cell.

2 (3)

Focus is on family fitness at this year’s Twin Cities Marathon

Don’t miss out on the running, racing and all the fun things to do for the whole family

Screen Shot 2022-08-18 at 2.29.47 PM

Family's tributes to mother killed by partner in St. Paul murder-suicide

The 30-year-old was killed by her partner, who then killed himself.

FatalEaganCrashSceneAug18

Eagan man killed after crashing into traffic signal

The 30-year-old crashed into a traffic light early Wednesday morning.

Melvin Carter

What's in Mayor Melvin Carter's budget proposal?

Here's what the St. Paul mayor is putting his focus on for the upcoming year.

WCCO building

Digital, streaming employees at WCCO-TV vote to unionize

The 15 employees will join on-air talent and producers as members of the SAG-AFTRA union.

unnamed-3

Police arrest man suspected of sexual assault, weapons threat in Eagan

The investigation prompted a SWAT response in an Eagan neighborhood on Tuesday.

Related