Minnesota House passes emergency insulin bill, despite GOP opposition

There remains disagreement over how affordable insulin access should be funded.
Publish date:

The Minnesota House passed a bill that levy fees on drug companies to provide access to emergency insulin, but there remains debate over whether this is the best way to make the drug affordable for diabetes patients.

The House passed HF 3100, otherwise known as the Alec Smith Insulin Affordability Act, by a vote of 75-52 on Wednesday night.

The bill is named for Alec Smith, who died at the age of 26 while rationing his insulin medication, for which he was being charged $1,300-a-month.

The bill would provide eligible Minnesotans with diabetes up to three months' supply of emergency insulin, as well as provide assistance to help them secure a long-term supply of the drug.

In order to pay for this, a fee would be levied on drug companies that Democrats hold responsible for the skyrocketing cost of insulin, which has tripled in the last 10 years. If 70 percent of diabetics eligible for the program use it, the fees would cost drug companies $38 million, according to Session Daily.

Copays for regulated health plans meanwhile would be called at $30 per month, with pharmacies required to take part in the insulin program in order to do business in the state.

Per Session Daily:

"To be eligible for the insulin program, people would have to be uninsured; have drug coverage through Medicare and have incurred more than $1,000 in annual out-of-pocket drug costs; or have private insurance with cost sharing that exceeds $50 for a month’s supply of insulin. Participants’ household income could not exceed 400% of federal poverty guidelines."

Here's how the vote went: 

Insulin vote

"Why are diabetics getting their medication for free?" lawmaker asks

Despite 52 voting against the bill on Wednesday, it looks likely that some form of deal will be reached, with Republicans in both the House and Senate keen on passing an insulin bill, while disagreeing with how it should be funded.

Rep. Kurt Daudt argues that health insurance companies and insulin manufacturers have already been making efforts to provide affordable insulin, with several Minnesota insurers announcing low co-pays for the drug late last year.

But Rep. Michael Howard (DFL-Richfield) said that despite this, at least two people in Minnesota have died since the end of the last legislative session because they couldn't get insulin.

Alternative plans have been proposed by Republicans, including one that would fund an emergency insulin program using state funds, rather than charging manufacturers a fee.

The Star Tribune reports that on the Senate side, Sen. Scott Jensen (R-Chaska), himself a medical doctor, has proposed a bill that instead of charging drug companies a fee, would instead just require them to provide insulin for distribution free of charge, which he says would cost between $10-$20 million.

Whichever form of bill passes the Republican-controlled Senate will have to be reconciled with what passed the House on Wednesday, but there appears motivation on both sides to pass a bill, after last year's effort failed at the last minute.

Among those opposing the House bill on Wednesday night was Rep. Jeremy Munson (R-Lake Crystal), who questioned why diabetics should get their medicine "for free" and not cancer patients, questioning whether it's because they have "the best lobbying groups out there?"

The campaign to pass the Alec Smith Emergency Insulin Bill has predominantly been a grassroots effort led by, among others, Alec Smith's mother, Nicole Holt Smith, along with other diabetes patients.

Pharmaceutical and health products companies, on the other hand, spent $228 million on lobbying efforts through three quarters of 2019, per Open Secrets.

Next Up

Eddie Rosario

Report: Twins place Eddie Rosario on outright waivers

The outfielder's time with the team appears to be coming to an end.

radio station, microphone

Christian music broadcaster revealed as buyers of Go Radio

Educational Media Foundation. operates the K-Love brand, which has a presence already in the Twin Cities.

Screen Shot 2020-12-01 at 5.04.39 PM

St. Paul police chief reportedly fires officer who shot naked, unarmed man

Chief Todd Axtell said the officer's use of force was not reasonable.

Trevor May

Report: Trevor May leaving Twins to sign with Mets

The right-hander will sign a two-year deal to head to New York

Car crash

'Grim' milestone: Minnesota's traffic deaths reach 364, tying 2019 total

“With fewer vehicles on the road during the 2020 pandemic, the loss of life on Minnesota roads is beyond disappointing."

Devin Weiland

Charges: Albert Lea man, 21, fired around 90 shots at police, residents

Weiland was arrested after a standoff that lasted more than eight hours.

Body storage warehouse

Body storage warehouse 'ready if needed for COVID-19 fatality management'

The warehouse is currently storing PPE and testing supplies.


Signs come down at Giordano's restaurant in Uptown

It appears the restaurant has closed for good.

State Capitol.

Walz eyes COVID-19 relief package totaling $300-$600 million amid budget surplus

The state forecasted a budget surplus for the remainder of the biennium.

Bar beer

Walz non-committal on extension of restaurant, gym closures

He has suggested that the ban on mixing with people outside your household could continue over Christmas.



MN lawmakers work on emergency insulin bill, disagree on funding

There's hope an insulin bill can pass sooner than later.

Jeremy munson

Lawmaker's Walmart insulin video criticized as 'irresponsible'

Democrats have pointed out that over-the-counter insulin isn't suitable for many diabetics.


Clinic security guard charged with stealing boxes of insulin

There is currently high demand for affordable insulin for diabetes sufferers.

Screen Shot 2020-04-08 at 9.05.59 AM

House Majority Leader sorry for giving the finger during insulin presser

Rep. Ryan Winkler said he was frustrated over Republicans' comments about a bipartisan insulin affordability deal.

It looks like the insulin bill everyone agrees on won't get passed

An apparent clerical error has caused the issue, and a blame game has ensued.


On day MN's new insulin law goes into effect, drug group sues to stop it

The Alec Smith Emergency Insulin Act goes into effect July 1.


Blue Cross and Blue Shield the latest to slash patient insulin costs

The insurer is the latest provider to tackle the rising cost of insulin.

What's in the tax reform bill just passed by the House?

Also, find out how your Minnesota representative voted on it.