Skip to main content

Minnesota leaders call national COVID-19 model 'overly optimistic'

A University of Washington model has gotten a lot of attention.

Gov. Tim Walz and Minnesota Department of Public Health Commissioner Jan Malcolm were clear Monday that COVID-19 models forecasting what could happen during the pandemic are not going to be perfect.

One model that has received a ton of attention is from the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME) at the University of Washington’s School of Medicine. It's a model that Gov. Walz referred to as "overly optimistic," while Malcolm called it "particularly optimistic." 

As we explained previously, the Washington model only goes out four months, until Aug. 4, which it considers to be the first wave of the novel coronavirus pandemic. The model has been updated five times since it went public March 26, starting with a projected death toll in Minnesota around 2,000. It has since lowered that estimate all the way down to 632. 

It's encouraging to see the numbers drop, but as Malcolm explained, the model has some "particularly optimistic assumptions" that don't match what's actually happening in Minnesota, much less the entire country. 

"The Washington model has some particularly, we would say, optimistic assumptions. First of all on social distancing, that Washington model assumes a level of stay at home social distancing that we just could not as a practical matter expect to see in the United States or Minnesota," said Malcolm. "It also only goes out four months. Our model goes out a year. The data just aren't apples to apples in terms of the totals." 

U of M infectious disease expert Dr. Michael Osterholm criticized the Washington model during a radio appearance on KFAN last week, saying it assumed a "Wuhan-style" lockdown in all 50 U.S. states. Wuhan, China, is where the novel coronavirus is believed to have began, and it led to the Hubei province issuing extreme quarantine guidelines for nearly three months. 

Meanwhile, a model from the Minnesota Department of Health and University of Minnesota is evolving as more Minnesota-specific data is being added daily. 

The first iteration of the Minnesota model estimated 50,000 to 55,000 deaths from COVID-19 over 12 months, according to a report from the Pioneer Press. Those numbers were based on data that Walz says was "too sparse at the time to drive any definitive conclusions." 

It's unclear if the new Minnesota-specific data will decrease that estimate, but either way it's a much more pessimistic forecast than the University of Washington model predicts, even if its a 12-month estimate compared to the four-month prediction from the Washington model. 

"I can't afford to be too short and I can't afford to be too late," said Gov. Walz. "I am still not comfortable that we have all of the ICU beds, all of the ventilators, and all of the personal protective equipment that will come. 

"We want to get the most accurate modeling, but those that want to lean towards overly optimistic modeling could be making the same mistakes in the criticism about leaning towards overly pessimistic models. 

"Yes, an overly pessimistic model will end up with more hospital beds than we might need, but that is a much better scenario than ending up with too few."

Malcolm agreed: "We'd rather plan for a higher level of need. We sure don't want to be underestimating what that need is."

It's expected that the Minnesota model will produce updated simulations in the very near future, at which point it is possible that the governor will share those findings with the public. 

Next Up

storm, radar, severe weather

Monitoring severe storm threat Saturday-Tuesday in Minnesota

The holiday weekend won't be a washout, but multiple rounds of strong and severe storms are possible.

Screen Shot 2022-05-26 at 4.45.15 PM

Charges: St. Cloud meth dealer had numerous weapons. body armor

Shawn Lawrence Jacobs, 38, faces 12 felony-level charges.

3100 Bloomington Ave.

South Minneapolis tenants declare rent strike; allege unsafe conditions

A group of Powderhorn Park residents say they'll withhold May rent due to health and safety concerns.

Screen Shot 2022-05-26 at 3.11.26 PM

Threats involving 2 students at West St. Paul middle school

Police said there is no reason to be concerned for the safety of the rest of the student body at Heritage E-Stem Magnet Middle School.

North Shore Mayor Chris Swanson.

Controversial Two Harbors mayor told: Resign or face recall election

The mayor has come under scrutiny for unusual behavior this year.

Lakeville Minnesota Solar Installation - All Energy Solar

Tips for selecting a reputable solar installer

Installing solar panels is a major investment. The solar solution provider you choose should be stable and trustworthy.

3M Maplewood

3M fined $2.8M for hazardous waste violations in Cottage Grove

The company's violations spanned more than two decades.

Christopher Payne and Kaley Wethern

Couple charged after $75k worth of fentanyl pills seized during traffic stop

Christopher James Payne and Kaley Maria Wethern have been charged in the seizure.

Kellace McDaniel

Kellace McDaniel named Brooklyn Center police chief

McDaniel will officially begin his new job on Monday, June 27.

Related

coronavirus, covid-19

Explaining MN's coronavirus model and higher death toll estimate

The model's findings were revealed to the public on Friday.

coronavirus, covid-19, doctor

Coronavirus: Big differences in Minnesota model, national model

Minnesota leaders are confident in the model they're developing.

coronavirus, covid-19, don't give up

National model lowers death estimates for MN in 1st wave of pandemic

"Minnesotans should consult a variety of sources to reach their conclusions," said a health official.

Tim Walz modeling

Here's why Minnesota extended the Stay at Home order

The Minnesota model is estimating at least 6,000 deaths over a 12-month period.

Governor Tim Walz

Walz to modify stay-at-home order, unveil new model data Wednesday

The governor provided a glimpse of what's to come during his Tuesday media briefing.

coronavirus

COVID-19 outbreak brings new daily high for deaths in Minnesota

Anyone with symptoms is urged to go in for a test as soon as possible.

covid-19, coronavirus, PPE

Washington COVID-19 model updates death projection for MN

Minnesota has averaged about 5.5 deaths per day since July.

coronavirus, covid-19

Mayo Clinic experts discuss high COVID-19 death toll projections

Just how far out can the models accurately predict the future?