Minnesota Supreme Court rules on rights for those suspected of DWIs

The court ruled individuals do not have a right to legal counsel before deciding to comply with a blood test if the police have a warrant.
Publish date:

In a 4-3 decision, the Minnesota Supreme Court ruled Wednesday on when a person suspected of driving while intoxicated has the right to legal counsel.

Brought on by a DWI case in Dakota County, the court went against a previous ruling by a lower court. Wednesday’s ruling determined that, if police have a warrant, a person suspected of a DWI does not have the right to legal counsel before deciding to comply with a blood test. 

The court did maintain that the person must be informed that choosing not to comply with the test is a crime.

The Minnesota Supreme court ruled in Friedman v. Commissioner of Public Safety that people have the right to legal counsel at all “critical stages” of criminal prosecution. Wednesday’s ruling states the blood test stage of a DWI does not fall into that category if police have a warrant.

In 2017, a woman was pulled over for a suspected DWI in Dakota County. Presented with a warrant, she was told refusing to comply with a blood or urine test is a crime. 

After submitting a blood test, she was charged with a DWI. She argued her blood tests should be suppressed because she was not given the right to counsel during what she argued was a critical stage of the prosecution. A district court agreed with her, and her tests were suppressed.

A court of appeals reversed that decision and the Supreme Court sided with the court of appeals Wednesday.

Justice Natalie Hudson wrote in the dissent that the blood test does fall into the critical stages category and that people facing a DWI should be allowed counsel as they make a “critical and binding” decision. 

Next Up

Sen. Julia Coleman

'No one's business': State senator calls out attack on her pregnancy

Sen. Julia Coleman represents Minnesota's District 47.

Willmar Police Department

'Errant bullet' goes through garage wall, kills Willmar man

The man was working in his garage when he was shot, witnesses said.

Screen Shot 2021-01-16 at 10.59.00 PM

Wild tie Kings with 2 seconds left, win in overtime

Another incredible finish for the Wild.

Screen Shot 2021-01-16 at 6.53.17 PM

Mike Lindell's MyPillow offering discounts using the code 'Qanon'

The Shakopee-based company is under the microscope because of the recent actions of its owner.

Surly Brewing

Facing aluminum can shortage, Surly unveils solution: 'Cantyhose'

The brewery came up with a creative way to repurpose unused cans.

Liam Robbins

Gophers stay perfect at home by crushing 7th-ranked Michigan

Liam Robbins and Marcus Carr were too much for the previously undefeated Wolverines.

police lights

Four teens arrested over robberies in Minneapolis

They teens were found in a vehicle that was taken during an earlier carjacking.

Boundary Waters/BWCA

All BWCA visitors will now have to watch three 'Leave No Trace' videos

Visitors left an "unacceptably high amount" of damage last year.


Ten fatal overdoses in past 6 weeks reported in region of northern MN

Law enforcement agencies have issued a plea to the general public.


St. Paul trash collection must go on ballot, MN Supreme Court rules

St. Paul Mayor Melvin Carter said decentralizing trash collection could lead to a property tax increase.

MN Supreme Court hears arguments for St. Paul trash collection lawsuit

Residents have sued the city over a centralized trash collection system.

You can steal a car in Minnesota just by sitting in it, court rules

The Minnesota Supreme Court ruled a car doesn’t have to move to be stolen.

State Supreme Court rules that schools must report campaign spending

The Minnesota Supreme Court ruled Friday that school districts need to be more accountable in reporting campaign spending. The ruling stems from a 2010 complaint filed against the St. Louis County School District, which alleged district leaders and school board members violated state campaign laws by using public funds to promote the passage of a school building bond referendum -- and not reporting it to the state as campaign spending.

court gavel

MN Supreme Court rules in favor of employment protections for unpaid interns, students

The case stemmed from a St. Mary's University doctoral student's experience at a practicum.

What happens if you're pulled over for suspected DWI, and what are your rights?

Experienced attorney Charles Segal takes you through the traffic stop process.