Publish date:

Minnesota Supreme Court tosses 'depraved-mind murder' conviction of Mohamed Noor

He will be resentenced, but only on the manslaughter conviction.
Mohamed Noor

The Minnesota Supreme Court has thrown out the third-degree "depraved-mind" murder conviction of former Minneapolis police officer Mohamed Noor in connection with Justine Ruszczyk's shooting death,

Noor, in April of 2019, was convicted of both third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter for his actions the night of July 15, 2017. He shot and killed the pajama-clad Ruszczyk as she approached his squad car, with Noor saying he pulled the trigger thinking there was a threat.

He was given 12 1/2 years in prison, a sentence based solely on the third-degree murder charge — a crime that involves acting with a "depraved mind, without regard for human life."

The Hennepin County Attorney's Office, led by Mike Freeman, prosecuted the case. The jury's guilty verdict marked the first time in state history a police officer was convicted of murder in connection with an on-duty incident.

But Noor appealed that depraved-mind murder conviction, citing the precedent of a "particular-person exclusion." He argued that, if a person's behavior is specifically and intentionally directed at one person, the perpetrator cannot be convicted of that third-degree murder charge. 

The court of appeals in February upheld the third-degree murder conviction, though the panel members were divided on the matter. Noor then appealed to the state Supreme Court. 

Screen Shot 2021-09-15 at 11.05.03 AM

In a Wednesday opinion (read it here), the justices sided with his argument, agreeing that this "particular-person exclusion" did indeed apply to his case. They cited a number of previous cases that had clearly defined this exclusion with regards to third-degree murder.

"Applying the particular-person exclusion to the facts of Noor’s case, as we must, we hold that the State presented insufficient evidence to prove that Noor acted with a 'depraved mind, without regard for human life,'" the opinion reads.

The Supreme Court sent the case back to district court, saying Noor must be sentenced only on the second-degree manslaughter conviction.

Under Minnesota law, second-degree manslaughter is punishable by a sentence of up to 10 years in prison, and/or a fine up to $20,000.

Next Up

motorcycle

Crash in southern Minnesota kills motorcyclist

The crash happened Saturday at Highway 42 and County Road 14 in Highland Township.

Oli Udoh

Vikings-Cardinals: 5 things you can count on happening

The Vikings need a win in the desert but will they get one on Sunday?

Kyler Murray

How can the Vikings stop Kyler Murray?

The Cardinals quarterback accounted for five touchdowns against the Titans.

Red's Pizza in Oshkosh, Wisconsin

'Landmark' Wisconsin pizza joint to close amid worker shortage

The restaurant has been a local favorite since 1957.

Ky Thomas

Potts, Gopher defense dominate Buffaloes

Trey Potts ran for three touchdowns in a 30-0 victory in Boulder.

police tape, crime scene

Suspect dies by suicide after 11 hour standoff in Wisconsin motel

The standoff occurred at a motel in Balsam Lake.

U.S. district court minnesota - federal court

Four sentenced for home invasion on northern Minnesota reservation

The incident took place in October 2019 on the Red Lake Indian Reservation.

Screen Shot 2021-09-17 at 10.42.39 AM

4-year-old girl killed by falling branch in Mankato is identified

She is from South Dakota, and was attending the Mahkato Annual Traditional Powwow.

Screen Shot 2019-09-24 at 6.35.24 AM

No. 1 Lakeville South dominates No. 2 Eden Prairie

The Cougars ran away with the Class 6A showdown.

Lake Nokomis

Boy hospitalized after being rescued from Lake Nokomis has died

He was one of two children pulled from the Minneapolis lake.

Related

Mohamed Noor

Appeals court upholds Mohamed Noor's conviction in Justine Damond's death

It's not clear if Noor will appeal to the Minnesota Supreme Court.

Mohamed Noor

Mohamed Noor guilty of murder, manslaughter in death of Justine Damond

The 10-person jury began deliberations Monday afternoon.

Mohamed Noor

What's the latest with the Mohamed Noor trial?

The former Minneapolis police officer is charged with the murder and manslaughter of Justine Damond.

Mohamed Noor

Decision to limit media access in Noor trial causes uproar

Journalists and media outlets are "vehemently" opposing the judge's ruling.

Mohamed Noor

What happened at Mohamed Noor's pre-trial hearing?

The former Minneapolis officer pleaded not guilty in the killing of Justine Damond.

Mohamed Noor

Mohamed Noor moved to prison in other state for 'safety reasons'

He was sentenced last month for the murder of Justine Damond.

Mohamed Noor

Ex-Minneapolis cop Noor sentenced to 12 1/2 years in prison

Noor was found guilty of murder in the shooting death of Justine Damond.

An overview of the jury in Justine Damond shooting trial

Former police officer Mohamed Noor is charged in her killing.