Skip to main content

Minnesota Supreme Court tosses 'depraved-mind murder' conviction of Mohamed Noor

He will be resentenced, but only on the manslaughter conviction.
Mohamed Noor

The Minnesota Supreme Court has thrown out the third-degree "depraved-mind" murder conviction of former Minneapolis police officer Mohamed Noor in connection with Justine Ruszczyk's shooting death,

Noor, in April of 2019, was convicted of both third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter for his actions the night of July 15, 2017. He shot and killed the pajama-clad Ruszczyk as she approached his squad car, with Noor saying he pulled the trigger thinking there was a threat.

He was given 12 1/2 years in prison, a sentence based solely on the third-degree murder charge — a crime that involves acting with a "depraved mind, without regard for human life."

The Hennepin County Attorney's Office, led by Mike Freeman, prosecuted the case. The jury's guilty verdict marked the first time in state history a police officer was convicted of murder in connection with an on-duty incident.

But Noor appealed that depraved-mind murder conviction, citing the precedent of a "particular-person exclusion." He argued that, if a person's behavior is specifically and intentionally directed at one person, the perpetrator cannot be convicted of that third-degree murder charge. 

The court of appeals in February upheld the third-degree murder conviction, though the panel members were divided on the matter. Noor then appealed to the state Supreme Court. 

Screen Shot 2021-09-15 at 11.05.03 AM

In a Wednesday opinion (read it here), the justices sided with his argument, agreeing that this "particular-person exclusion" did indeed apply to his case. They cited a number of previous cases that had clearly defined this exclusion with regards to third-degree murder.

"Applying the particular-person exclusion to the facts of Noor’s case, as we must, we hold that the State presented insufficient evidence to prove that Noor acted with a 'depraved mind, without regard for human life,'" the opinion reads.

The Supreme Court sent the case back to district court, saying Noor must be sentenced only on the second-degree manslaughter conviction.

Under Minnesota law, second-degree manslaughter is punishable by a sentence of up to 10 years in prison, and/or a fine up to $20,000.

Next Up

hennepin sheriff hutchinson screengrab facebook

Hennepin Co. Sheriff Dave Hutchinson on paid leave for health reasons

The sheriff, who was recently convicted of drunk-driving, is set to stand down later this year.

Crane Lake

Flooding expected to worsen in MN's Arrowhead region

Hundreds of private homes are at-risk in northern St. Louis County.

St. Paul Police crash

St. Paul police: Kids in stolen car rammed squad, hid in porta-potty

The incident sent the Minnesota Capitol into a brief lockdown.

IMG_7030

Watch: Storm updates after heavy hail slams Twin Cities

Sven Sundgaard is providing an update after Thursday's flash hail storm.

kim crockett facebook sos

MN GOP apologizes over antisemitic sequence in candidate's campaign video

Party leader says candidate didn't know the imagery perpetuated an antisemitic trope.

storm, severe

Tornado, severe thunderstorm watches issued in Minnesota

In addition to possible tornadoes, there is a threat for damaging winds and very large hail.

House sale keys door

High prices, stiff competition putting off homebuyers in Twin Cities

Prices continue to rise in the metro, but there are signs of buyer fatigue.

Screen Shot 2022-05-19 at 1.59.51 PM

Series of explosions at manufacturing plant injures 6 in Wisconsin

The blast rocked the Wisconsin town just before 7:45 a.m.

police lights squad car dark - Unsplash

Medford man dies in Le Sueur County crash

The 49-year-old was not wearing a seatbelt at the time of the crash.

Denisovan molar

MN researcher part of team behind 'revolutionary' discovery of ancient tooth in Laos

The molar found in a remote cave is believed to have belonged to a Denisovan girl who lived 164,000-130,000 years ago.

Eagle Ridge Middle School

Charges: Sting catches MN principal trying to hire child prostitute

Authorities alleged Mohamed Selim attempted to meet a 15-year-old girl for sex on Tuesday.

Related

Mohamed Noor

Appeals court upholds Mohamed Noor's conviction in Justine Damond's death

It's not clear if Noor will appeal to the Minnesota Supreme Court.

Mohamed Noor

Mohamed Noor guilty of murder, manslaughter in death of Justine Damond

The 10-person jury began deliberations Monday afternoon.

Mohamed Noor

Ex-Minneapolis cop Noor resentenced to 57 months in prison

Justine Ruszczyk Damond's fiancé said he forgives Noor.

Mohamed Noor

What's the latest with the Mohamed Noor trial?

The former Minneapolis police officer is charged with the murder and manslaughter of Justine Damond.

Mohamed Noor

Decision to limit media access in Noor trial causes uproar

Journalists and media outlets are "vehemently" opposing the judge's ruling.

Mohamed Noor

What happened at Mohamed Noor's pre-trial hearing?

The former Minneapolis officer pleaded not guilty in the killing of Justine Damond.

Mohamed Noor

Mohamed Noor moved to prison in other state for 'safety reasons'

He was sentenced last month for the murder of Justine Damond.

An overview of the jury in Justine Damond shooting trial

Opening statements are set to begin Tuesday.