Skip to main content

Minnesota landlords accused of blowing up home for insurance money

The explosion happened in Montgomery in 2018.
Fire, firefighters

Three years after a house exploded in a Montgomery, Minnesota, neighborhood, the married couple who owned it are facing prison time. 

The couple, who live in Lakeville, were charged Friday with multiple counts of insurance fraud and conspiracy to commit arson.

Court documents say Christopher and Isabella Hale, 32 and 29 years old respectively, forged documents to take out an insurance policy on the home — located on the 100 block of Third Street SW — and then plotted to collect on that policy by blowing up the home.

The house, which was vacant at the time, was "completely destroyed" by fire on July 17, 2018. Fire investigators subsequently found evidence of a gas can as well as a "grill style butane lighter" in the rubble.

Police also had help from a pair of witnesses: two of the Hales' tenants at another property. 

According to the charges, the two revealed to investigators that Christopher Hale had told them he "intended on burning the property" on Third Street SW, and that he'd "prepped the house for a fire by cutting holes in the floor and walls to help spread the fire."

One of the witnesses provided investigators with photographic evidence of that latter detail, while the other told them Mr. Hale had threatened to "shoot" him if he told anyone about the scheme.

Per the documents, Hale also arranged to have wooden pallets stacked in the basement of the house to "to increase the fire load."

One witness said he told Hale it was a "stupid idea and someone is going to get hurt," and that they wanted "nothing to do with the Hales and their plan."

There was also a complex scheme to defraud the insurance company, the charges indicate. 

Christopher Hale inquired with his insurance agent multiple times about how much he'd be paid "if the house were to burn down," the documents say. He and his wife are also accused of forging a signature in order to take out a policy on the property, and then submitting a counterfeit invoice for a roof repair on the house — an upgrade the insurance company had demanded. 

Investigators followed up on that invoice by checking with the company that had allegedly issued it. The owner of that company said that while he hadn't worked with the couple since 2016, and that "he did not generate that invoice and never received any money from the Hales."

A third person seems to have been involved as well. The charges say that, around the time of the explosion, an associate of the couple suffered injuries consistent with igniting gasoline.

That person does not appear to have been charged yet; BringMeTheNews typically does not name suspects until they've been charged with a crime.

The Hales are each facing decades in prison. They're both charged with multiple counts of insurance fraud, each of which carries a possible sentence of 20 years. 

The other charge, conspiracy to commit first-degree arson, carries a maximum sentence of 10 years in prison. 

Per KSTP, "Hale submitted a claim to State Farm for about $360,000" following the fire. 

The charges were filed by summons, and it's not clear when the Hales will make their first court appearance. 

Next Up

u.s. attorney's office

St. Paul man sentenced for 2021 robbery spree

Warren Dean, 27, admitted to robbing seven St. Paul businesses in a span of three days.


Stevens County may have been hit the hardest by Thursday storms

The entire county was without power after the storms blew through Thursday evening.

State Patrol

3 killed, 1 critical after trio of crashes in Minnesota Thursday

One person also faces life-threatening injuries in a crash that happened in Olmsted County.

Screen Shot 2022-05-13 at 1.25.08 PM

Mora woman saves pelican caught in fishing line for days

A birthday fishing trip shapes into a heroic tale.

Kelsey Peterson in the documentary, "Move Me."

Doc depicting MN dancer's journey with paralysis debuts at Twin Cities film festival

The film surrounds St. Paul-born Kelsey Peterson, who continues to pursue her passions in dance after being paralyzed from the chest down in 2012.

Milwaukee Ave

Gallery: Rare opportunity to own a home on historic Milwaukee Avenue

All the houses on the avenue front onto a pedestrian mall in south Minneapolis.

US Secretary of Defense COVID vaccine flickr

Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Friday, May 13

The next update will be provided Monday.


Minnesota part of the top 2 hurricane force wind events since 2004

Photo above shows the ominous view in Marshall, Minnesota as a dangerous line of storms approached Thursday afternoon.

Screen Shot 2022-05-13 at 9.24.48 AM

DFL efforts to pass abortion, reproductive health bills blocked in Senate

The push to pass a slate of abortion and healthcare-related bills comes after a leaked Supreme Court opinion draft indicated Roe v Wade will be overturned.


police lights

Woman, 20, killed in home explosion in Le Sueur County

She was reportedly housesitting at the time of her death.

Screen Shot 2022-02-28 at 10.35.03 AM

Tributes to Augsburg student, 20, killed in southern MN home explosion

Mach, who is originally from Montgomery, Minnesota, died in the explosion Saturday night.

Fire, firefighters

Home explodes in southern MN; injured person found nearby

The explosion and fire was reported around 6:30 a.m. Friday.

fire truck

Woman returns home to find her house has exploded, husband injured

The explosion happened in Oak Grove, Anoka County, Friday evening.

Fire, firefighters

Report: Minneapolis RV fire leads to discovery of woman's body

It happened on the city's north side Sunday morning.

Hardy Wills-Traxler

Charges: Man stabbed his father, set his home on fire

The 25-year-old has been charged with second-degree murder and first-degree arson.

Fire, firefighters

'Severe damage' reported after marina fire on Lake Minnetonka

It happened Saturday morning on Maxwell Bay's North Shore Marina.