Skip to main content

A Minnesota trucking company has agreed to pay $500,000 as part of a settlement in a sex discrimination lawsuit after it used strength tests that screened out qualified women drivers. 

Stan Koch and Sons Trucking, based in Minneapolis, revoked the job offers of women who failed isokinetic strength tests, resulting in the company discriminating against women truck drivers because of their sex, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) said in its federal lawsuit against the company. 

A federal judge found Koch did not present evidence to show the CRT Test, developed by Iowa-based Cost Reduction Technologies, was job-related and consistent with business necessity, an EEOC news release said. 

And Koch's use of the test disproportionately screened out women who had been given conditional job offers to work as truck drivers. It also screened out women who were already working at Koch and were required to take the CRT test to return to work following an injury,

“This case should serve as a reminder to employers that when they use a hiring screen they cannot rely on justifications like ‘It seemed like common sense’ or ‘Of course it’s better to have stronger employees if the job has some physical tasks.’ Employers have to demonstrate with valid evidence that the tests they use can actually predict the outcomes they are looking for," EEOC attorney Gregory Gochanour said in a statement. 

The EEOC and Koch recently reached a settlement. A five-year consent decree resolves the federal lawsuit and requires that Koch pay $500,000 in monetary damages, as well as make job offers to women whose job offers were revoked after they failed the CRT test.

The decree also prohibits Koch from using the CRT test, and if it chooses to use other physical abilities tests that have a disparate impact on women drivers, it must first show the test is job-related for the position and consistent with business necessity.

Sign up: Subscribe to our BREAKING NEWS newsletters

Koch is required to make regular reports to the EEOC regarding its hiring practices for the duration of the five-year decree. 

The EEOC filed the lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Minnesota against Stan Koch and Sons Trucking after first attempting to reach a pre-litigation settlement through the EEOC's conciliation process, the release said.

The lawsuit said Koch violated the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits workplace discrimination, including using practices that have a disparate impact on women because of their sex and that are not job-related and consistent with business needs. 

The EEOC recently won a similar case against Schuster Co., an Iowa-based trucking company, for using the same CRT test. 

Next Up

crystal police department

2 women found dead in Crystal home, police investigating

Authorities investigating the incident as a murder-suicide.

Screen Shot 2022-01-27 at 9.15.45 PM

Buckeyes crash the glass, fend off Gophers

E.J. Liddell dominated in the paint to help No. 16 Ohio State.

nicolas blouin flickr fire hose

Fire departments decry drivers running over hoses, endangering crews

It happened in two separate Northland cities this week.

All Energy Solar - Bringing Panels to Roof

All Energy Solar reaches growth milestones with higher goals yet for 2022

Minnesota solar company continues to thrive through building a strong workforce

Royal Canadian Mounted Police maintoba crossing crop

Authorities ID family found frozen to death at MN-Canada border

They're still trying to unravel how they got there and who might have helped them.

covid

Mayo Clinic specialist: 'The omicron surge is not over'

Experts expect a rapid decline over the next month followed a period of calm.

police lights

Charges: Man in stolen Jeep leads police on 110 mph chase

He crashed into a light post near the Capitol and then fled on foot, the complaint says.

kua dog go fund me

Puppy in back of stolen Audi found, reunited with owner

The 4 1/2-month-old bullmastiff had been missing more than a week.

Fuzzy Gerdes Flickr Franks Diner Kenosha

WI's best 'hole-in-the-wall' diner is Guy Fieri-approved

Come for the "garbage pile," stay for ... even more breakfast food.

FKISmwPWUAYZJW6

Minnesota's pre-pro women's soccer team unveils name, logo

The new name and look was unveiled after community owners voted on a winner.

fentanyl DEA

21 people charged in connection to drug trafficking in northern MN

Police say the organization sold more than 10 pounds of heroin and fentanyl in northern Minnesota.

Band Box Diner Courtney Mault Flickr

MN's 'best hole-in-the-wall diner' is, sadly, currently closed

MSN recently published its pick for best diner in each state.

Related

frizzell furniture

MN furniture company wouldn't hire applicant who is transgender

Frizzell Furniture didn't hire the applicant because he is transgender, saying he wouldn't "mix well with the customers."

Roseville food company fined for paying women less than men

They were paying men more for doing the same job as women.

crutches

Eden Prairie company to pay $95K to woman fired because she was on crutches

The woman says she was fired because she needed crutches after having knee surgery.

ambulance, crash

Garbage truck driver killed in rollover in southern Minnesota

The crash happened on Interstate 90 near Austin.

mankato crash

Wrong-way driver dies in head-on crash with truck on Highway 169

The crash closed the southbound lanes of the highway for hours on Tuesday.

ambulance

Minnesota driver dies after crashing into semi-truck and rolling

He rear-ended the truck, went into the media and rolled.