MPCA advisory group members resign, calling Line 3 approval the 'final straw'

"We cannot continue to legitimize and provide cover for the MPCA's war on black and brown people," their resignation letter states.
A group rallied at the governor's residence on Nov. 14 demanding Gov. Tim Walz stop the Line 3 pipeline replacement project.

A group rallied at the governor's residence on Nov. 14 demanding Gov. Tim Walz stop the Line 3 pipeline replacement project.

A dozen members of the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency's (MPCA) Environmental Justice Advisory Group (EJAG) have resigned after the agency approved a water permit for the controversial Enbridge Energy Line 3 pipeline replacement project

Twelve members of the 17-member EJAG resigned in a strongly worded letter criticizing the MPCA, which was made public Tuesday. The EJAG was formed in 2016 to, among other things, advise the MPCA Commissioner on the implementation of the agency's environmental justice framework.

That's according to the EJAG webpage, which was deleted from the MPCA's website on Tuesday.

The letter, dated Nov. 16, says the group members – which includes activist Winona LaDuke and other Native leaders – are submitting their "collective and public resignation" because "we cannot continue to legitimize and provide cover for the MPCA's war on black and brown people." 

The resignation comes days after the MPCA on Nov. 12 issued a 401 water quality certification to Enbridge Energy for the project and approved the capped air emissions and National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System wastewater (NPDES) permit for Line 3. 

“The MPCA has used sound science and thorough analysis to ensure that necessary safeguards are in place to protect Minnesota’s waters. The 401 certification requires Enbridge to meet Minnesota’s extensive water quality standards instead of lower federal standards,” MPCA Commissioner Laura Bishop said in a statement. “Thousands of Minnesotans provided valuable comments that strengthened the 401 certification and the rigorous review during the contested case hearing validated the proposed stream and wetland crossing safeguards. The result is a certification and permits that are strong, enforceable, and protective.”

These permits are among the few approvals Enbridge Energy still needs before it can start construction on the pipeline replacement, which will replace an aging crude oil pipeline in northern Minnesota with a larger pipeline along a different route that will connect the tar fields in Canada to Superior, Wisconsin, via northern Minnesota. 

The Line 3 route. 

The Line 3 route. 

This project has been controversial from the start. Proponents have said the pipeline will create jobs, while opponents, including Native American tribal members and environmental groups, have been fighting against the project in court, saying the pipeline will usurp Indigenous treaty rights and contribute to climate change.

Similar sentiments are echoed in the EJAG members' resignation letter. They write the pipeline will cross over 200 bodies of water "inevitably poisoning rivers, wetlands, and wild rice beds" and emit greenhouse gases that cannot be offset even if every other sector of the state gets to carbon neutral. The letter also says the pipeline threatens the further spread of COVID-19 at a time when cases and hospitalizations are surging.

"Line 3 will mean violated treaty rights, heightened risk of sexual trafficking and sexual violence, and an insult to three tribal nations that strongly oppose construction," the letter reads. "Any perceived economic benefits are extremely short-term ... it is obvious that Line 3 is a poor economic choice for Minnesota's working and middle classes," pointing to Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer's recent action to shut down Enbridge's Line 5 pipeline

The letter states that the approval of the water permit "sends a clear message that the Walz Administration and the MPCA hold no regard for the well-being of Minnesotans or our relatives around the world." They called the approval the "final straw after increasing disappointment in the MPCA's failure to build on the hard work of dedicated EJAG members over the years."

Sign up for our BREAKING NEWS newsletters

The resigning members say the transition to MPCA Commissioner Laura Bishop has resulted in the EJAG being left out of important decisions and members being been dismissed and discouraged from sharing their thoughts and opinions. 

"While we have seen small actions taken internally to improve understanding, measures, and culture in the agency, our communities demand action and this agency cannot claim to promote justice without results that improve our lives," the letter states. 

The group "demands" that Commissioner Bishop and the Walz Administration "reflect on the choices that were made," adding that their decision to "side with a Canadian corporation over your own people is reprehensible and devastating."

"We ask that you do everything in your power to repair the damage you have done and seek a healing path to justice with the communities you have harmed," the letter says.

In a series of tweets Tuesday afternoon, MPCA Commissioner Bishop said: 

"The MPCA thanks the environmental justice advisory group (EJAG) members for their steadfast commitment to ensuring that every voice and community is heard and engaged. I recognize the disappointment of some members regarding the Line 3 decision.

"The MPCA EJAG has made a significant difference in the way that the agency approaches its work, including integrating equity into agency grantmaking decisions, strengthening engagement during enforcement and permitting processes, and prioritizing permits in EJ communities.

"The MPCA will continue to eliminate and reverse environmental and health inequities and disparities in overburdened communities and ensure engagement remains at the forefront of our decision-making.

"The MPCA remains committed to ensuring that every Minnesotan has healthy air, sustainable lands, clean water and a better climate."

Bring Me The News has reached out to Gov. Tim Walz for comment on these resignations. 

A years-long process

The permits the MPCA issued last week, along with the ones the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources approved the same day, bring the Line 3 project even closer to construction.

The MPCA's recent approvals will trigger a decision from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers on its permit for the project, MPR News reported. That approval, as well as one more from the MPCA which is expected in the next month, is all Enbridge needs to begin building the pipeline. 

This comes following a years-long approval process that's been delayed by appeals and lawsuits. The state has approved this project twice – in 2018 and most recently in May, when the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission (PUC) approved the route and a certificate of need for the project.

However, the Minnesota Department of Commerce in August filed an appeal against the PUC approval, claiming the approval didn’t take into consideration a possible drop in oil demand as the COVID-19 pandemic continues. This marked the third time the Commerce Department has appealed the pipeline since the approval process began in 2015, and it ended up costing the department's commissioner his job.

Enbridge officials have said they hope to begin construction before the end of 2020, according to MPR News, noting it'll take 6-9 months to build.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2020-12-02 at 9.55.05 PM

Small plane lands on northbound I-35W in Twin Cities

A large police presence is at the scene.


Judge orders Minnesota gym that defied shutdown to close

Attorney General Keith Ellison sued the gym after it remained open.

montana cutbank

Charges: Man shot victim 'without provocation' using sawed-off shotgun

The incident happened on Nov. 24 in Ten Lake Township, located in Beltrami County.

Governor Tim Walz

Watch live: Walz, first responders address Minnesotans

Some departments have been forced to shift staffing or suspend service due to COVID-19.

covid-19, coronavirus

CDC says COVID-19 quarantine period can be cut to 10 or 7 days

You can come out of a 7-day quarantine following exposure provided you've had a negative test.

maple grove fire

1 person found dead inside Maple Grove business that burned down

A person had been unaccounted following the fire that destroyed Hanson Implement and Storage Tuesday night.

One-dollar bill, cash, money

Appeals court rules MN high school students can get unemployment benefits

They've been denied the benefits, and some were even asked to pay them back.

covid-19, coronavirus

Dec. 2 COVID-19 update: 77 more deaths in Minnesota

The death toll is closing in on 3,700 in Minnesota.

City Pages

Fan creates City Pages archive, Star Tribune tells him to remove it

After word spread that the defunct newspaper's website would go down, a fan created his own copy. Then he got a cease and desist letter.

Adam Thielen

Vikings activate Adam Thielen off COVID-19/reserve list

The star receiver missed last week's victory over Carolina.

Screen Shot 2020-12-02 at 10.27.14 AM

Naked man shot by St. Paul cop is charged for sexual assault of ex-girlfriend

The 31-year-old suspect remains at Regions Hospital after being shot.


Screen Shot 2020-11-30 at 1.31.42 PM

Enbridge gets final approval to start construction on Line 3 replacement

The project has attracted criticism from environmental and tribal groups.

enbridge line 3

Minnesota DNR grants 2 approvals for Line 3 pipeline

The Enbridge pipeline replacement project would replace a crude oil pipeline in northern Minnesota.

MN Supreme Court deals blow to opponents of Line 3 pipeline

The Supreme Court declined to take up a challenge against the project.

Preferred Line 3 route

Walz administration files appeal against Line 3 pipeline

The action is the latest in a year-long process surrounding the controversial project.

enbridge line 3

Complaint argues that Line 3 pipeline replacement is no longer needed

Honor the Earth filed the petition with the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission Tuesday.

bob kroll

Labor groups call for Bob Kroll to resign from Minneapolis police union

"He antagonizes and disparages members of the black community," Minnesota AFL-CIO President Bill McCarthy said.

gazelka paul

Another Walz-appointed commissioner forced out by Senate GOP

The move came as the legislature began its fourth special session.