Mystery surrounds discovery of 4 Twin Cities friends found dead in abandoned SUV

Here's what is known about the case so far — and what questions remains.
Loyace Foreman III (top left); Nitosha Lee Flug-Presley (top right); Jasmine Christine Sturm (bottom left); Matthew Isiah Pettus (bottom right).

Loyace Foreman III (top left); Nitosha Lee Flug-Presley (top right); Jasmine Christine Sturm (bottom left); Matthew Isiah Pettus (bottom right).

Update: Authorities on Thursday afternoon announced the arrest of one suspect wanted in connection with the quadruple killing. They are still searching for a second suspect, considered "armed and dangerous" and likely in the Twin Cities area.

Days after four Minnesota residents were discovered shot to death in an abandoned SUV in rural Wisconsin, there remain more questions than answers.

A 911 caller around 12:18 p.m. Sunday told emergency dispatch they'd spotted a black SUV in a corn field off County Trunk Highway VVV in Sheridan Township. There were multiple people inside who appeared to not be moving, the caller reported, the Dunn County Sheriff's Office has said. 

Deputies and first responders arrived 12 minutes later and discovered four individuals, dead in the vehicle:

  • Nitosha Lee Flug-Presley, 30, Stillwater
  • Matthew Isiah Pettus, 26, St. Paul
  • Loyace Foreman III, 35, St. Paul
  • Jasmine Christine Sturm, 30, Saint Paul

No suspects had been taken into custody as of Wednesday afternoon.

Here's a look at what we do and don't know at this point.

The circumstances surrounding their deaths

Authorities have revealed how they died, with the medical examiner determining all four victims died from gunshot wounds.

Little else is known, and Dunn County Sheriff Kevin Bygd said during a Tuesday news conference there are details they simply cannot talk about, so as not to jeopardize the investigation.

Bygd said they believe the SUV was intentionally driven into the corn field. 

The motive, as of Tuesday afternoon, was a "mystery," he said.

Follow Bring Me The News on Facebook

There had been no indications it may be linked to organized crime, nor anything to that point suggesting the motive was drug-related. New information could change that during the investigation, Bygd added.

Authorities did not have an exact time of death, though Bygd said they believe it was within 24 hours of the SUV's discovery.

He could not say whether the victims had been shot in Dunn County, or killed elsewhere and driven to the location they were found. He also said he did not know the type of firearm used in the killings.

Bygd declined to say how many times each victim was shot, where in the vehicle they were located or to whom the abandoned SUV was registered.

The suspect (or suspects)

Sheriff Bygd repeatedly referred to the "suspect or suspects" during Tuesday's news conference, and indicated he did not know at that point exactly how many suspects might be involved. 

"Everybody is a suspect at this point," he said, noting they're looking into every possibility as the investigation gets going.

Bygd did express confidence the suspect or suspects are not from Dunn County, and said they left the area — presumably in a vehicle — before the abandoned SUV and bodies were found, returning to their "home base." Where that might be, Bygd did not say.

The sheriff said there seems to be "no connection" between the suspect or suspects and the area, other than "possibly randomly driving out of the Twin Cities." Investigators are very confident the victims were "randomly brought to" the corn field in Sheridan Township, he said.

They do not believe the public is in danger.

Authorities have received numerous tips to this point. They're also waiting for more information, including surveillance video from highway or bridge cameras, to come in. It would take several weeks to work through all of that, Bygd said. 

Remembering the victims

Bygd said two of the victims were siblings, while the other two were in a relationship. The Pioneer Press reported Pettus was Sturm's brother; that Sturm was dating Foreman II; and that Sturm was a longtime, close friend of Flug-Presley.

A Go Fund Me for Foreman's family called his death "unexpected and horrifying," saying he loved music and the arts, and was a beloved father of two sons.

A fundraiser for Flug-Presley's family, meanwhile, called the killing of her and her three friend an "unthinkable tragedy." She had two children, 11 and 4 years old.

Bygd said he could not confirm reports the four were at a bar in St. Paul Saturday night, but that investigators were looking into it.

Next Up

Dean Evason

Wild fall flat against Predators, lose first game of season

The Wild couldn't stay out of the penalty box in a 5-2 loss.

Screen Shot 2021-10-24 at 10.11.36 AM

Search for Wisconsin woman whose vehicle was found near Hinckley

Ashley L. Miller, 33, was reported missing on Sep. 24 after her vehicle was found without her in it.

Dak Prescott

Report: Dak Prescott will be 'ready to go' for matchup with Vikings

The Dallas quarterback is expected to be available for next Sunday's showdown.

Eddie Rosario

Where Eddie Rosario's championship series heroics rank since 2000

The former Twin put together an all-timer to help the Braves reach the World Series.

plane, Piper PA-32

2 dead after plane crashes near residence in rural Wisconsin

The aircraft also struck the house during the crash.

Screen Shot 2021-10-23 at 9.38.43 PM

1 dead after van crashes and lands on Highway 100 in Brooklyn Center

Northbound Highway 100 was shut down following the crash Saturday night.

Jess Peterson

Woman killed in crash ID'd as 'bad ass biker chick' with 'giving spirit'

The 30-year-old died in a motorcycle crash on Oct. 19.

Karl-Anthony Towns

Timberwolves' defense fuels win over Pelicans

The Wolves' have bought in on the defensive end as part of a 2-0 start.

Minnesota Wild

Ryan Hartman's OT goal helps Wild stay undefeated

The Wild improved to 4-0 with a win over the Ducks.

Mar'Keise Irving / Gopher Football

Gophers pound Maryland to stay in Big Ten West race

Four different players scored a rushing touchdown in a 34-16 victory over Maryland.


FLickr - crime scene tape do not crozz

4 dead in abandoned SUV were from Twin Cities, had been shot

The vehicle was found abandoned in a western Wisconsin corn field.

Dunn County WI homicide suspect

1 arrested in quadruple killing, with 'armed and dangerous' suspect at large

The four victims were found in an abandoned SUV in rural Wisconsin.

Dunn County WI homicide suspect

Charges: Man who killed 4 friends, drove bodies to WI said he 'snapped'

Charges filed Tuesday reveal more details about the grisly case.

Darren McWright Osborne - Dunn County WI - crop

Father of man accused in quadruple slaying now charged

The victims were found dead in an SUV that had been abandoned in a Wisconsin cornfield.

Go Fund Me - Adam Richard Johnson

Remains in Mississippi mark 4th discovery of man's dismembered body parts

Officials on Tuesday confirmed the remains found July 4 are those of Adam Johnson.

Foreman tl - Flug-Presley tr - Sturm bl - Pettus br - Go Fund Me and Facebook

St. Paul PD takes over quadruple killing probe after it emerged they died in Minnesota

A "thorough investigation" reveled where the four Minnesotans were killed.