'Nobody is holding them against their will': Rep. Jim Hagedorn's border comments spark backlash

The Congressman addressed constituents last week in Rochester.
Publish date:
Screen Shot 2019-07-05 at 9.42.28 AM

Minnesota Republican Rep. Jim Hagedorn faced backlash for his comments about conditions on the U.S. southern border at a recent Rochester town hall.

Addressing the audience at Rochester Community and Technical College last week, one constituent asked 1st District Rep. Hagedorn why he supported what they called “government-sponsored child abuse.”

Hagedorn pushed back on the accusation and the comparison of detention centers at the border to concentration camps, prompting some boos from the crowd.

But it was his comments that followed that gained widespread attention on social media.

“The people there, they can leave. Nobody is holding them against their will,” Hagedorn said.

This drew another negative response from the crowd as well as on social media, with one town hall audience member asking him how a young child is expected to just get up and walk out of a detention center.

"Fair enough," Hagedorn said. "You want them reunited with the parents and.the parents can make the decision."

As The Daily Beast notes, children and adults being held in immigration detention centers can't leave unless they're eligible for and pay a bond while their removal proceedings go through the immigration court.

The freshman congressman then went on to lay out his stance on immigration. He said he welcomed the millions of legal immigrants living in the country, who he said able to immigrate because “we had a system of legal immigration that is the best in the world and the most generous in the world.”

He said he supports an “orderly, systemic process” and claimed a majority of asylum seekers do not show up for court hearings, a claim previously uttered by VP Mike Pence that has since been rated "4 Pinocchios" by the Washington Post's fact-checkers.

“I support securing America’s borders,” Hagedorn went on to say. “I support physical barriers to make sure we have an orderly system to ensure when people come into the country, they come through checkpoints.”

Sign up: Subscribe to our BREAKING NEWS newsletters

Hagedorn recently voted in favor of a bill that granted federal funds to provide migrants at the border food and shelter. The legislation drew criticism from progressives who said it didn’t go far enough to improve the treatment of refugees. 

Following the town hall, protesters gathered outside of Hagedorn's office in Rochester Tuesday to oppose conditions at the border. According to Fox 47, the protest drew around 140 people. 

You can watch the immigration segment of Hagedorn's town hall here:

Next Up

Karl-Anthony Towns

Wolves-Grizzlies game off, KAT tests postive for COVID

The Timberwolves star was among several players that are dealing with COVID-related issues.

minnesota state fair

Planning for the 2021 Minnesota State Fair is underway

The fair suffered huge financial losses due to COVID-19, but organizers are moving forward with planning "different scenarios" for this summer.

Screen Shot 2021-01-15 at 2.16.44 PM

Heather Brown named as new WCCO 'This Morning' anchor

She will be joining Jason DeRusha on the CBS affiliate's Morning Show.

DPS John Harrington

DPS Commissioner: No credible threats to state Capitol, but ready if something arises

Local and state law enforcement officials have a plan in case a threat arises.

snow, slush (submitted photo, ok to use)

Here are snow totals from Thursday-Friday winter storm

It's a slushy mess in the metro, but snow did pile up in southern counties.

tim walz

Walz fury after report that government's COVID vaccine reserve is nonexistent

The Washington Post reported Friday that the Trump Administration has shipped out all the vaccines it has already, with none in reserve.

closed sign

What's open and closed in Minnesota on MLK Day 2021?

Local government offices will generally be closed on Monday.

BMTN 900x450 (8)

Company that falsely promised student loan forgiveness banned from MN

It's also been ordered to repay $11,499 in fees taken from Minnesotans.

covid-19, coronavirus

Here is Minnesota's COVID update for January 15

Hospitalizations are the lowest in Minnesota since October 25.


Osterholm: B117 COVID strain could become major issue in 6-8 weeks

The B117 variant is believed to be more easily transmitted.


Screen Shot 2019-07-05 at 9.42.28 AM

Rep. Jim Hagedorn to no longer allow office visits from liberal group

Hagedorn told members of the St. Peter/Mankato Indivisible they may no longer visit his office.

Phillips and omar

How did Minnesota lawmakers vote on the border aid bill?

The House backed the Senate's bill funding aid at the border, drawing criticism from progressive Democrats.

Screen Shot 2019-07-05 at 9.42.28 AM

Pressure on Rep. Jim Hagedorn rises as DFL calls for ethics probe

Hagedorn spent tax dollars on mailings from a company owned by one of his staffers.

Screen Shot 2019-09-25 at 9.43.55 AM

Rep. Jim Hagedorn calls Elizabeth Warren a 'national socialist'

Hagedorn changed the comment, but not before it had caused a backlash.

Jim Hagedorn

Rep. Jim Hagedorn fires chief of staff over spending controversy

A recent report found Hagedorn was the top spender in Congress in Q1.

jim hagedorn

1st District Rep. Jim Hagedorn has cancerous kidney removed

Hagedorn was diagnosed with Stage 4 kidney cancer in February 2019.

Screen Shot 2019-07-01 at 8.41.51 AM

Protesters march in Minneapolis over U.S. immigration policies

The Sunday march was protesting ICE, family separation and immigration bans.

Jim Hagedorn

1st District Rep. Jim Hagedorn updates his battle against kidney cancer

The 57-year-old was diagnosed with stage 4 kidney cancer in Feb. 2019.