Skip to main content

NTSB reveals probable cause of fatal gas explosion at Minnehaha Academy

Workers thought that a gas valve was closed, when it was actually open.

The National Transportation and Safety Board has released the results of its investigation into the 2017 gas explosion at Minnehaha Academy that killed two staff members.

The NTSB found that two workers with Master Mechanical were preparing to move a gas meter in the basement of the south Minneapolis school on the morning of Aug. 2, 2017.

They believed a plug valve connected to the meter to have been in the closed position, with the wrench that turns the valve "stuck" in a perpendicular position, which usually indicates it is closed.

However, the NTSB found after the blast that while the wrench was in the perpendicular "closed" position, the valve itself was open, and that it was the responsibility of the workers to confirm it was closed.

The report also notes that both workers – a father and son duo – didn't have the required licensing and training to be carrying out the meter move.

"It is customary to align the handle so that it is parallel with the piping when the valve is open and positioning the handle perpendicular to the piping when the valve is closed. However, confirmation of this is the responsibility of the crew working on the piping. This confirmation would entail removal of the handle and noting the position of plug assembly and viewing the indicator or witness mark on the body of the valve."

As the workers proceeded to remove the piping, the open valve caused natural gas to flow out, with the workers unable to shut it down.

They began to raise the alarm, as did a school maintenance worker who heard a "horrendous flow of air" and then noticed a strong odor of natural gas.

"As he exited the basement, he [the maintenance worker] made an announcement over his handheld radio that there was gas in the building and to evacuate immediately," the report states.

"As he made his radio announcement, he ran up the stairs and searched for occupants. Less than 1 minute later, the building exploded."

Killed in the blast was 47-year-old school receptionist Ruth Berg and 82-year-old custodian John Carlson, with nine others injured.

Sign up: Subscribe to our BREAKING NEWS newsletters

The NTSB did find that there was a "lack of detailed documentation that clearly established the scope of work to be performed" on the day the meter was being moved.

In a statement, CenterPoint Energy said it has reviewed its procedures regarding the relocation of indoor meters to outside buildings, and said it now writes a letter each year to mechanical contractors in Minnesota "to remind them of the dividing line between our equipment and the customer's equipment and to emphasize that contractors are not authorized to work on or operate our equipment."

It has also reached confidential settlements with the Berg and Carlson families.

"We were saddened by the tragedy that occurred at Minnehaha Academy, and our deepest sympathy continues to be with everyone who was affected," the statement said.

Next Up

Xcel Energy Center

NHL announces make-up dates for Wild postponements

The Wild will play 40 games in the final 77 days of the regular season.

the mayo clinic - edit

Group says Mayo should be 'severely punished' over research puppy's death

The puppy died two days after undergoing a procedure at a Mayo research facility.

FLickr - minneapolis police - Tony Webster - Feb 2020 - crop

Charges: Man kidnapped woman, sexually assaulted her at gunpoint

The suspect faces three separate felony charges.

mn state capitol january 17 2021

St. Cloud 'Boogaloo Boi' who discussed attack on MN Capitol gets 2 years

He was charged with illegally possessing a machine gun.

Chris Smith

Gophers add All-Ivy League D-tackle from Harvard

Chris Smith will be eligible immediately as a graduate transfer.

school bus

High school basketball team returns from game to find bus driver dead

Members of the girls team returned to the bus to find the driver unresponsive.

covid-19 testing site sign

Minnesota AG sues COVID testing site, alleging it sent false results

Sometimes the company didn't send people their results at all, the lawsuit alleges.

optum headquarters chad davis wikimedia commons

UnitedHealth Group says it made $287B last year, $24B of it profit

The corporation's Optum business represented a significant chunk of that total.

covid

Omicron may have already peaked in Minnesota

Reported cases lag what's happening in real time, so the newly reported cases over the next week or so will still be very high.

MnDot snow plow cam I-35 12-10-21

MnDOT reveals 50 snowplow name finalists

Voting is open through Wednesday, Jan. 26.

gov tim walz

Walz's $2.7B infrastructure plan includes $940M for climate projects

Projects will help Minnesota prevent or adapt to climate change and mitigate its impacts, the governor says.

Related

A year since devastating explosion, a new start for Minnehaha Academy

The school held a ceremonial pillar raising on Thursday morning.

Here's how things unfolded Wednesday at Minnehaha Academy

A natural gas explosion caused part of the school to collapse.

Lawsuit blames gas line workers for deadly Minnehaha Academy explosion

The suit claims the workers ran to save themselves instead of warning people about the leak.

Video shows aftermath of the deadly Minnehaha Academy explosion

The explosion apparently happened when a gas meter was being moved.

Screen Shot 2019-03-08 at 12.57.05 PM

Fatal explosion that leveled St. Paul house was accidental

It was likely the result of an internal gas leak.

Firefighter killed after massive explosion in Wisconsin suburb

A punctured gas main sent gas leaking into a property, which then exploded.