Skip to main content

Officer who kicked man during arrest should get his job back, arbitrator rules

The city settled with the man who was kicked for $2 million.

An arbitrator says an officer fired for kicking a man during an arrest in June should get his job back.

Officer Brett Palkowitsch was fired from the St. Paul Police Department after he was seen on video kicking Frank Baker three times in the chest on June 24, 2016.

Baker – who matched a description of an armed suspect but wasn't the suspect – was on the ground being bitten by a K-9 officer at the direction of the dog's handler Brian Ficcadenti when Palkowitsch kicked him.

Baker had to be hospitalized for two weeks. He was treated for dog bites, broken ribs and two partially collapsed lungs.

The incident resulted in a $2 million settlement to Baker – the largest in the city's history – which the St. Paul City Council unanimously approved Wednesday afternoon.

A review of the officer's actions

After the incident, St. Paul Police Chief Todd Axtell called for a review of the officers' actions.

The commission that reviewed Baker's arrest found the officers' use of force was "excessive and improper." The commission recommended Ficcadenti be suspended for 10 days and Palkowitsch be suspended for 30, according to the arbitrator's ruling, which was published by KSTP.

But Chief Axtell chose to suspend Ficcadenti for 30 days and fire Palkowitsch for violating the department's use-of-force policies, the ruling says.

Palkowitsch appealed that decision, and this week an arbitrator ruled he shouldn't have been fired. Instead, the arbitrator said Palkowitsch should receive a 30-day suspension without pay – the same punishment that was handed down to Ficcadenti, KSTP reports.

In a statement Wednesday, Axtell said, in part, this incident has been difficult for the department, adding he's "disappointed that an officer used excessive force, put his colleagues' safety in jeopardy and severely injured an innocent man. ... and I stand by my decision to hold everyone in our department to the highest possible standards."

Chris Wachtler, who's the attorney for the St. Paul Police Federation, said in a statement to the Pioneer Press Palkowitsch “looks forward to returning to proactively serving the citizens of St. Paul, and helping keep our streets safe.”

Next Up


22 dogs taken in by Animal Humane Society from shuttered breeder

The dogs were taken in after a report stated there were too many on a single property.


Latest on the 2 snowstorms set to impact Minnesota

The first arrives Thursday night into Friday before a bigger system comes next week.


Cop who pepper-sprayed downtown protesters received $150K payout

Samantha Belcourt said she "feared for her life."

Powerball Minnesota lottery

$1 million Powerball prize won in Twin Cities

The winning ticket was sold in Chanhassen for Wednesday's draw.

Screen Shot 2022-12-08 at 9.16.18 AM

Animales Barbeque Co. looks to open brick-and-mortar location

The popular food truck has partnered with the owner of Billy Sushi.

Christmas presents

Here are some 2022 holiday shipping deadlines to keep in mind

Most deadlines are a few days before Christmas Eve.


Minneapolis will waive pet adoption fees on Friday

Pet licensing fees still apply to adoptions at the event.


Family who endured car theft ordeal surprised with trip to Universal Orlando

A father rescued his four children after a thief jumped in his car while he was getting something from his trunk.


Update: Man sought after Crookston woman's death arrested in Twin Cities

Investigators said he may know something about a woman who was found dead Wednesday morning.

Black pedestrian arrested by Edina officer is suing him, the city

Larnie Thomas says he was "maliciously discriminated" against.

Sealy will pay workers who were harassed with racist jokes and symbols

Sealy says it happened three years ago, and the company took swift action.

Mpls. cop fired over pushing a woman will get his job back

There are some mixed feelings about his return.