Skip to main content

Osterholm: Stop mischaracterizing my comments about face masks

The leading epidemiologist has cleared the air over his previous comments on mask wearing.
Michael Osterholm

Leading epidemiologist Dr. Michael Osterholm has sought to clear the air on his views surrounding face masks, after comments he has previously made regarding their use have been mischaracterized by those for and against mask-wearing alike.

The director of the University of Minnesota's Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy (CIDRAP) says he has come in for increasing criticism over statements he's made during the course of the COVID-19 pandemic.

His name is cited regularly on social media by anti-maskers in arguments about the effectiveness of cloth face coverings, while he has also been criticized by pro-mask site #Masks4All for comments he made to WCCO Radio in May.

During an interview in early May, Osterholm said non-medical cloth masks have "little impact, if any" in preventing the spread of COVID-19, and followed that later in May after Minneapolis enacted a face mask mandate, saying it could do "more harm than good."

But he says these comments are now being mischaracterized and are not being discussed in their full context, namely that he doesn't want people wearing face masks to feel they're invulnerable to the virus, and as such don't follow more effective ways of limiting transmission of the virus, such as social distancing.

He wrote:

"At the outset, I want to make several points crystal clear:

  • I support the wearing of cloth face coverings (masks) by the general public.
  • Stop citing CIDRAP and me as grounds to not wear masks, whether mandated or not.
  • Don't, however, use the wearing of cloth face coverings as an excuse to decrease other crucial, likely more effective, protective steps, like physical distancing
  • Also, don't use poorly conducted studies to support a contention that wearing cloth face coverings will drive the pandemic into the ground. But even if they reduce infection risk somewhat, wearing them can be important."

He also wanted to dispel the notion that he's "anti-mask," referencing a June 2 podcast in which he said he's working with tech leaders to develop a reusable, washable N95 medical-grade mask that does provide more protection from airborne droplets.

"If these masks can become a reality and many, many millions of them made and distributed to the public around the world in the next few months, this could be a real game-changer," he said.

"So anyone who claims I don't think masks are important, they are just plain wrong. I do."

As for cloth masks, he said: "Again, I want to make it very clear that I support the use of cloth face coverings by the general public. I wear one myself on the limited occasions I'm out in public," he adds.

"In areas where face coverings are mandated, I expect the public to follow the mandate and wear them."

Osterholm criticizes CDC guidance

Osterholm says he takes issue with the pronouncements from, among others, the CDC that suggest face masks are a panacea for the virus, referencing "unfortunate" comments made by CDC leaders that the pandemic could be "driven to the ground" if everyone wore masks for 4-6 weeks.

"If this were true, why do we need a vaccine to end this pandemic? Just 'mask our way' to control. When put into this context, it's obvious how the CDC statement is unrealistic and misleading." 

He says science is "ever-evolving" and that that the COVID-19 response should be conducted with the best data available, and not "on popular opinion or even well-meaning movements within the scientific community."

Sign up for our BREAKING NEWS newsletters

He says that public health messaging "should include a more precise discussion of the effectiveness of cloth face coverings in preventing transmission of SARS-CoV-2."

"We need to be clear that cloth face coverings are one tool we have to fight the pandemic, but they alone will not end it," he said. "And we need to underscore the key role that physical distancing plays – even when you wear a face covering."

"The messaging that dominates our COVID-19 discussions right now makes it seem that – if we are wearing cloth masks – you're not going to infect me and I'm not going to infect you," he continues.

"I worry that many people highly vulnerable to life-threatening COVID-19 will hear this message and make decisions that they otherwise wouldn't have made about distancing because of an unproven sense of cloth mask security."

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-05-24 at 5.21.04 PM

Ex-South St. Paul coach dies by suicide 2 days before sentencing

Matthew McCollister was to be sentenced for fraud in federal court on Wednesday.


Minnesota 'glampground' named one of 10 best in U.S.

In Nevis, Minnesota, campers can stay in a refurbished 1905 train car.

Screen Shot 2022-01-28 at 9.04.12 AM

Two men charged over terrifying armed robbery at Newport apartment

They shot the woman who lives in the apartment in the abdomen, and put a gun to a man's head.

Minneapolis police

Minneapolis 2-year-old identified in suspicious death case

The cause of death has not yet been revealed due to an ongoing investigation.

Arianna Vos

Victim of wrong-way driver crash ID'd as Hutchinson 19-year-old

Three women, ages 19, 20 and 20, were in the vehicle struck by a wrong-way driver early Sunday morning.

Julissa Thaler

Eli Hart killing: Police investigating multiple crime scenes

An announcement Tuesday confirmed potential crime scenes in Mound and Minnetrista.

SEIU Healthcare Minnesota strike.

Twin Cities mental health workers gather for 1-day strike

More than 400 mental health workers are participating in the unionized strike on Tuesday.

Bloomington Fire

HAZMAT team at Bloomington hotel following chemical spill in pool

The fire department said two hotel employees are being evaluated by paramedics.

Screen Shot 2022-03-24 at 9.21.32 AM

Big Brothers Big Sisters Twin Cities gets $6M of Mackenzie Scott donation

The donation is the largest the organization has ever seen from a single individual.

Hennepin Avenue S.

Minneapolis accused of backtracking on 24/7 bus lanes for Hennepin Ave.

The Minneapolis City Council is set to vote on Thursday.

Pexels - face mask covid holding

Duluth brings back masking in city buildings amid COVID surge

Duluth, in one of the state's current COVID hotspots, has brought back a mask requirement in city buildings.


masks, coronavirus, covid-19

Osterholm: It's time for a mask mandate, but social distancing more important

The state epidemiologist backs Gov. Walz ordering a mask mandate.

coronavirus, masks, covid-19

Medical group urges MN leaders to make face masks mandatory

Thirteen states already have mandatory mask policies.

coronavirus, pandemic, masks

Map shows where Minnesotans are wearing masks, everywhere they're not

In most of Minnesota, people are not wearing face masks in public despite the fact it can help prevent the spread of the virus that causes COVID-19.

Michael Osterholm

U of M's Osterholm named to President-elect Biden's COVID-19 advisory board

The board has prominent doctors and scientists tasked at guiding Biden's transition to president and planning for the federal response to the virus.

coronavirus, masks, covid-19

Lunds & Byerlys, Kowalski's will require shoppers to wear masks

The main protection people get from masking occurs when others in their communities also wear face coverings, the CDC says.

Edina minnesota

Edina votes to extend its mandatory face mask requirement

The citywide policy was put in place for three days, but is now extended for the foreseeable future.

PPE, coronavirus, covid-19

U of M's Dr. Michael Osterholm discusses the future of the pandemic

Osterholm has been preaching what he calls "straight talk" about the pandemic.

Screen Shot 2020-05-27 at 1.47.56 PM

Osterholm reiterates COVID-19 going dormant could be bad signal

The infectious disease specialist has said this a few times now.