Skip to main content

Read the letter of support the judge in the Yanez trial wrote to jurors

"You were never asked to decide whether racism continues to exist."

The people who served on the jury during Jeronimo Yanez's manslaughter trial got some support from the judge who presided over the case.

Judge William Leary III wrote a rare, post-trial letter to the jury that acquitted Yanez in the death of Philando Castile. Last month's verdict sparked days of protests and strong reactions from people in the community who continue to demand justice for Castile.

Leary wrote in part that "the criticism of the verdict some have expressed is likely due to a failure to understand what you were asked to do and that you faithfully fulfilled the difficult task you were asked to undertake."

In his letter, Leary also said the criticism focused on reaction to dashcam video and on issues jurors were never asked to consider.

"You were never asked to decide whether racism continues to exist, whether certain members of our community are disproportionately affected by police tactics, or whether police training is ineffective. You were simply asked to determine, beyond a reasonable doubt, whether a crime had been committed," Leary wrote.

The judge detailed the law prosecutors had to prove in order to convict Yanez, including if the St. Anthony officer acted with gross negligence and recklessness when he fatally shot Castile during a traffic stop on July 6, 2016.

A 'fair interpretation of the evidence and the law'

Leary didn't give his opinion on the verdict, but he wrote that the jury's verdict "was fully supported by a fair interpretation of the evidence and the law you were obligated to apply."

To end the letter, Leary wrote he hopes the jury's work "will soon be understood for what you were asked to do and respected for what you did do" in order to protect the jury process "now and in the future."

Leary's letter, which you can read in full here, was dated June 23 – one week after the jury found Yanez not guilty. The Star Tribune says a judge will often talk to the jury after a trial ends (Leary did in this case), but it's not common for a judge to send a letter to jurors days later.

The paper spoke to a few local attorneys, who said the letter was a good move on the judge's part, especially because the Yanez case was so historic and followed so closely.

Yanez is believed to be the first Minnesota police officer charged with fatally shooting someone while on duty.

Next Up

Brandon Gardas

St. Michael standoff suspect charged, bail set at $10 million

A judge on Monday set the high bail due to "very significant concerns of public safety" regarding Brandon Gardas.


Minnesota's premier trauma center housed at HCMC

The Minneapolis center is nationally recognized in pediatric trauma

Crisp & Green

Crisp & Green opening 13th store in Twin Cities in July

The fast-casual salad and grains restaurant has exploded onto the food scene.

FLickr - Target Field 2019 - mark grabe

Twins to host post-game concert with country star at Target Field

Country singer Cole Swindell is expected to perform for up to 75 minutes after the conclusion of the Blue Jays-Twins contest.


Canton Restaurant closes after nearly 40 years in Burnsville

It's the end of an era in the Twin Cities restaurant world.

Screen Shot 2022-06-27 at 12.47.20 PM

Luck strikes in Minnesota: lottery winners in Duluth, Grand Marais

The North Shore just so happened to be a lucky place to be this past weekend.


Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Monday, June 27

BA.5 is expected to become the dominant subvariant in Minnesota.

police lights squad car

60-year-old woman arrested after firing shots inside Spicer home

SWAT evacuated nearby residents during the incident.

Florida Georgia Line

Florida Georgia Line booked to play at the Minnesota State Fair

The band is the second country music act to be booked this year.


First case of monkeypox confirmed in Minnesota

The Minnesota Department of Health says the risk to the public is "considered low" at this time.


As Jeronimo Yanez case draws to a close, 3 key points from the trial

The jury is expected to begin deliberations Monday.

Video: What exactly the jury has to decide in the Jeronimo Yanez trial

We spoke with a legal expert to learn more about what the jury has to consider.

Jeronimo Yanez found not guilty in Philando Castile's death

Jurors deliberated for five days before reaching a unanimous decision.

Jurors see dash cam footage of Yanez shooting Castile

Opening arguments in the cop's manslaughter trial included video.

ICYMI: Charges against Jeronimo Yanez reveal Philando Castile's final moments

Castile's last words, recorded at 9:06.04, were: "I wasn't reaching for it."

So what happens if a jury can't come to a decision?

The jury in the Yanez manslaughter trial appears to be deadlocked.