Skip to main content

Report: Cases alleging police misconduct cost St. Paul $1M in 2012

  • Author:
  • Updated:

The city of St. Paul paid out about $1 million in alleged police misconduct cases in 2012, the highest amount in the 17 years of records of settlements the city attorney had access to, the Pioneer Press reports.

The paper says the costs stem from eight cases alleging police misconduct that were settled last year. Six of the cases stem from claims made during current Chief Thomas Smith's tenure, which began in 2010, while two cases were from John Harrington's term as chief, from 2004 to 2010.

The claims in the cases under Smith's watch cost the city almost $800,000, while the Harrington-era cases cost about $230,000.

Among the largest cases settled in 2012 was an award of $400,000 to a woman was left with serious burns after St. Paul police used a flash-bang distraction device while executing a search warrant at her home.

City Attorney Sara Grewing told the paper that the largest payout went out to people with significant injuries, but larger conclusions shouldn't be drawn to settle recent cases. She said the decision to settle a lawsuit is based on "what's in the best interest of the city in terms of dollars and cents."

The St. Paul Police Federation also warns people not to make swift judgments about settlements, because "officers have seconds to decide life-and-death situations."

"Attorneys and city management who have very little concept of police tactics can sit back for months and months to debate what we did, and officers had the luxury of seconds," union president Dave Titus told the Pioneer Press.

Still, the president of the St. Paul NAACP wants officers held "accountable for what they do and not put their misdeeds on the backs of taxpayers of St. Paul."

Jeff Martin told the Pioneer Press that there has "to be some equity in the system -- if you're an officer who cost the city some money, you should be held to a higher standard, whether that's losing your job or maybe some of your pension."

Comparing settlements in officer conduct-related claims in the Twin Cities in 2012, the Pioneer Press found that the St. Paul averaged about $113,000 for its eight claims, while the city of Minneapolis averaged about $46,000 per case in its 16 settlements, or a total of approximately $736,000.

Next Up

Brandon Gardas

St. Michael standoff suspect charged, bail set at $10 million

A judge on Monday set the high bail due to "very significant concerns of public safety" regarding Brandon Gardas.


Minnesota's premier trauma center housed at HCMC

The Minneapolis center is nationally recognized in pediatric trauma

Crisp & Green

Crisp & Green opening 13th store in Twin Cities in July

The fast-casual salad and grains restaurant has exploded onto the food scene.

FLickr - Target Field 2019 - mark grabe

Twins to host post-game concert with country star at Target Field

Country singer Cole Swindell is expected to perform for up to 75 minutes after the conclusion of the Blue Jays-Twins contest.


Canton Restaurant closes after nearly 40 years in Burnsville

It's the end of an era in the Twin Cities restaurant world.

Screen Shot 2022-06-27 at 12.47.20 PM

Luck strikes in Minnesota: lottery winners in Duluth, Grand Marais

The North Shore just so happened to be a lucky place to be this past weekend.


Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Monday, June 27

BA.5 is expected to become the dominant subvariant in Minnesota.

police lights squad car

60-year-old woman arrested after firing shots inside Spicer home

SWAT evacuated nearby residents during the incident.

Florida Georgia Line

Florida Georgia Line booked to play at the Minnesota State Fair

The band is the second country music act to be booked this year.


First case of monkeypox confirmed in Minnesota

The Minnesota Department of Health says the risk to the public is "considered low" at this time.


City of St. Paul expected to settle police brutality case for $400K

The St. Paul City Council Wednesday was expected to settle for $400,000 a case of police brutality filed by a mother and a son over an alleged incident at their home involving St. Paul police in October 2010. The settlement was the largest in a case of police brutality in the city's history.

Ex-St. Paul cop to get $665K in data breach case

Former St. Paul and Eden Prairie police officer Anne Rasmusson, who accused other officers across the metro of digging into her driver's license file for personal information, is likely to reap about $665,000 in settlements from Twin Cities municipalities, the Star Tribune reports.