Skip to main content

Ruling in election dispute: toss out 35 random ballots

  • Author:
  • Updated:

A Douglas County judge says Minnesota law requires randomly selecting and discarding 35 ballots to correct a polling place error in a disputed legislative race.

The case involves Republican State Rep. Mary Franson, who was declared the winner of her re-election race by a margin of one vote on Election Night. A closer look later found 35 people who don't live in the district were mistakenly given the wrong ballots and allowed to vote in Franson's race with DFL challenger Bob Cunniff.

At Tuesday's hearing Cunniff's lawyer argued tossing out a like number of randomly selected ballots amounts to disenfranchising voters. But Judge David Battey ruled that's what state law requires.

Ramsey County Elections Director Joe Mansky tells WCCO the process is "terribly unfair." Mansky says the law has been on the books since the 1800's and was passed to fight corrupt candidates who were hiring voters to stuff ballot boxes.

A recount in the Franson-Cunniff race is scheduled to begin Nov. 28th, after the result has been certified.

Next Up

police lights

Las Vegas man identified as victim killed near 38th and Chicago

The 25-year-old died at the scene Sunday afternoon.


Beloved Eagan Dairy Queen says goodbye

A summer staple has shuttered in Eagan.

Screen Shot 2022-08-16 at 3.44.22 PM (2)

Bridge damage closes westbound Hwy. 62 between Richfield, Edina

The Minnesota Department of Transportation said bridge maintenance work is in progress.

Michael Miller

Charges: Drunk driver killed former chair of Hibbing Chamber of Commerce

Michael Miller's blood-alcohol content was nearly three times the legal limit at the time of the crash.

Mystic Lake

Charges: Man attacked Mystic Lake security with 2x4

A chaotic scene unfolded after the man approached the bell stand late Friday.


SWAT presence in Eagan neighborhood Tuesday morning

There's a developing story out of Eagan.


More questions could be headed to Minnesota's 2012 ballot

The marriage amendment may not be the only proposed Constitutional amendment put to the state's voters this year. Republican lawmakers are considering ballot questions on other issues. Those include needing an ID to vote, needing a supermajority to pass a tax increase, and making union membership voluntary.

Voter ID amendment headed for November ballot

Minnesotans will vote this fall on a Constitutional amendment that would make a photo ID a requirement to vote. The Republican-backed measure passed the Legislature on party-line votes. Now supporters and critics of the change will ramp up campaigns to influence the public.

Lawsuit targeting Republican Tom Emmer tossed out

A former client claimed Emmer -- who ran a law firm while serving in the state Legislature -- put up a shoddy defense for him in a civil case that cost him his the license for his roofing company.