Skip to main content

Sorry, Grandma Elsie: Women who lost citizenship over marriage get apology

  • Author:
  • Updated:

A Minnesota man got the U.S. Senate to apologize to his grandmother on what would have been her 123rd birthday.

Daniel Swalm spent more than a year drawing attention to the injustice done to his Grandma Elsie and thousands of other women who lost their U.S. citizenship because they married men from foreign countries.

Elsie Knutson was born on Minnesota's Iron Range. But as the Chicago Tribune reports, when she married Swedish immigrant Carl Moren her citizenship was stripped under a 1907 law called the Expatriation Act. Among other effects, it meant that when women gained the right to vote in 1920 there was no ballot for Elsie Moren.

Elsie died in childbirth in 1926 but nearly 90 years later her grandson took up her cause.

Swalm told Pioneer Press columnist Ruben Rosario in March he was researching his family tree at a genealogy center in Chisholm when he learned that his Grandma Elsie had lost her citizenship. Rosario writes that anti-immigrant sentiment ran high early in the Twentieth Century and was reflected in the legislation of the time.

One provision in the text of the 1907 law reads "any American woman who marries a foreigner shall take the nationality of her husband."

The law was modified in 1922, the Tribune says, but was not repealed until 1940. And the women who lost their citizenship never had it reinstated.

Swalm embarked on a crusade to change that. While he did not get Grandma Elsie's citizenship posthumously restored, his work did lead to the resolution sponsored by Minnesota Democrat Al Franken and Wisconsin Republican Ron Johnson which the Senate unanimously approved Friday.

In a statement issued by Franken, Swalm says "When I started this quest a year and half ago, I never dreamed we would be here today. Shepherding this resolution through the Senate and achieving justice for Elsie and her forgotten sisters is the most important thing I have ever done in my life."

An article from The Constitutional Sources Project takes a closer look at the Expatriation Act of 1907.

Next Up


Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Friday, June 24

The next daily update will be provided Monday, June 27.

Pro choice rally

Walz, Jensen react to historic Supreme Court reversal of Roe v. Wade

After voting to overturn Roe, conservative Justice Clarence Thomas has hinted contraception and same-sex marriage protections should follow.

16362 County Rd 81, Maple Grove, Minnesota - October 2021 (4)

2-year-old killed in crash on County Road 81 in Maple Grove

The crash occurred Thursday evening on County Road 81.

police tape

BCA issues new details about St. Michael standoff, shooting

New details say a St. Cloud police officer struck the suspect with gunfire.

Screen Shot 2022-06-23 at 2.21.45 PM

92-year-old driver killed in rural Scott County crash

The crash happened around 12:30 p.m. Thursday.

Screen Shot 2022-06-24 at 7.29.06 AM

Big-time rain totals flood Highway 10 in central Minnesota

More rain and storms are expected Friday and Saturday morning.


Charges: Driver had just left local bar before deadly Shakopee crash

Witnesses said they were unable to help the 19-year-old Eden Prairie man who died in the crash after becoming trapped.

Chet Holmgren

Thunder selects Chet Holmgren 2nd overall in NBA Draft

The Minneapolis native becomes the highest-drafted Minnesotan in NBA history.

Screen Shot 2022-06-23 at 2.21.45 PM

One airlifted after crash on rural Scott County highway

The State Patrol shut down Highway 282 in both directions Thursday afternoon.

Flickr - police lights squad siren - Edward Kimmel

Police investigating after two men found dead in Maple Grove

Few details are known about the investigation.

12-web-or-mls-12 Dining room

Gallery: Charming, Northeast Minneapolis Home is perfect for first-time homebuyers

Located in the Holland neighborhood, it's near the Eastside Co-op, tons of amazing restaurants, breweries, and a distillery

US-169 BUS, Shakopee, Minnesota - June 2019 (1)

Eden Prairie 19-year-old killed in crash near Valleyfair is ID'd

Alcohol is believed to be a factor in this crash, involving a 26-year-old driver from Hopkins.


Local DJ fighting for citizenship

Local DJ Sothiphakhak and his family fled to the United States from a refugee camp in Thailand when he was just 2-years-old. Now, he has discovered that his father -- who passed away when he was a young boy -- never completed the process of making him a U.S. citizen.