South Dakota judge strikes down voter-approved marijuana legalization amendment

Voters approved the constitutional amendment in November, with recreational marijuana set to become legal in July. Legalization advocates plan to appeal.
Publish date:

A judge in South Dakota struck down a voter-approved Constitutional amendment that would have legalized recreational marijuana in the state. 

Hughes County Circuit Court Judge Christina Klinger ruled Monday that Constitutional Amendment A violates the state's single-subject requirement and said it would have "far-reaching effects on the basic nature" of the state's governmental system, according to the ruling posted online by the Argus Leader.

“The failure to submit Amendment A through the proper constitutional process, voids the amendment and it has no effect,” the judge wrote, arguing the amendment doesn't modify the constitution it adds a new section to it, so it needed to be submitted to voters via the constitutional convention process, which it wasn't. 

Amendment A, which legalizes all forms of marijuana and allows for the licensing, sale and cultivation of cannabis, was set to go into effect July 1. Voters approved it by 54% in November 2020.

South Dakotans for Better Marijuana Laws, a group that pushed for the legalization of marijuana, wrote in a Facebook post, "We disagree with the ruling and we are preparing our appeal to the South Dakota Supreme Court."

Meanwhile, the South Dakota Attorney General's Office, which is tasked with defending voter-approved ballot measures, told KELO it wouldn't be commenting because its general policy is not to comment on pending litigation.

The legal challenge to Amendment A came from South Dakota Highway Patrol Superintendent Rick Miller and Pennington County Sheriff Kevin Thom, who filed a lawsuit against it, The Associated Press reports

Republican Gov. Kristi Noem, who appointed Judge Klinger in 2019, campaigned against Amendment A and spoke out against it even after voters approved it. She also ordered the state to pay for Miller's legal fees in his fight against Amendment A. 

She applauded the court's decision on Monday. 

"Today's decision protects and safeguards our constitution," she said in a statement sent to the Argus Leader. "I'm confident the South Dakota Supreme Court, if asked to weigh in as well, will come to the same conclusion."

Thom and Miller also cheered the judge's decision, with Thom saying it "solidifies the protections" outlined in a 2018 constitutional amendment that requires further amendments to stick to a single subject. 

South Dakota voters in November also approved Initiated Measure 26, which legalizes medical marijuana in the state come July 1. Monday's court ruling isn't expected to impact that. 

Fifteen states, including South Dakota, have legalized recreational marijuana, with other Midwestern states including Minnesota and Wisconsin considering it. 

Democrats in Minnesota have again proposed a bill to legalize recreational marijuana, but some Republicans are against it so it's unclear if it will get done this year as the GOP controls the Senate. 

Meanwhile in Wisconsin, Gov. Tony Evers proposed legalizing recreational weed and medical cannabis in his budget proposal, with medical marijuana more likely to get approval from the Republican-controlled Legislature. 

Next Up


Snow latest: Twin Cities set for up to 4 inches

A narrow system will travel across Minnesota overnight.

Blake Fredrick / Lake City Basketball

Lake City boys basketball player signs contract, honored on senior night

Frederick had a special call-up to the Tigers' varsity basketball team.


Man dies after being shot outside home near Grove City

He was found outside a home in Acton Township.

Screen Shot 2021-02-27 at 9.39.00 AM

Teen wounded in 'accidental shooting' in Moorhead

The 18-year-old was shot in the abdomen.

Kirill Kaprizov / Minnesota Wild

Watch: Another absurd night for Kaprizov as his legend grows

Kaprizov scored a crazy wrap-around goal in the Wild's victory over the Kings.


DoorDash, Uber Eats bump service fees for Twin Cities customers

After Minneapolis and St. Paul limited what companies can charge restaurants, DoorDash and Uber are charging customers about a dollar more

hockey rink ice arena

Hill-Murray girls' hockey shut down after 3 players with COVID symptoms kept playing

The players showed 'complete disregard' for the school's COVID

Screen Shot 2019-02-12 at 6.18.55 AM

Narrow band of intense snow to bring up to 7 inches to Minnesota

A winter storm watch has been issued where more than 6 inches could pile up.

Icicles; frozen; winter

As Minnesotans brace for huge gas bills, state ups assistance to $1200

Texas wasn't the only state impacted by February's arctic blast.


Marijuana, cannabis

Wisconsin governor proposes legalizing marijuana in his budget proposal

If it passes, two of Minnesota's neighbors will have legalized recreational marijuana.

Marijuana legalization bill fails in Senate committee

Today's vote is a blow to Minnesota's "legalize recreational pot" movement.


Recreational marijuana bill passes its first MN House committee

The bill would allow people 21 and older to use marijuana legally, with restrictions.

Marijuana, cannabis

MN lawmakers to introduce bill to legalize marijuana

Democrats plan to introduce the bill on Monday, while it's expected to be opposed by many Republicans.

Canada is now Minnesotans' closest source of legal marijuana

Canada is just the 2nd nation to approve a nationwide regulated pot market.

Stunner: Voter ID amendment fails

In a shocking upset, the voter ID amendment has failed, and by a sizable margin. With 98 percent of precincts reporting, the "no" votes led by nearly 8 percentage points, MPR says. The measure would have amended the state constitution to require voters to bring photo IDs to the polls.