Skip to main content

Attorney: Police justified in deadly shooting during hostage situation

The fatal police shooting took place in the city's downtown on Nov. 27.

The police officer who shot and killed a suspect in Virginia, Minnesota, in November has been cleared of any wrongdoing. 

St. Louis County Attorney Mark Rubin announced Thursday that Officer Nicholas Grivna of the Virginia Police Department "was placed in a situation which necessitated the use of deadly force in the course of his work." 

Killed in the incident was J. Scot Alan Widmark, 41, of Virginia. 

Rubin came to the conclusion after reviewing a report from Vernon D. Swanum, an attorney who conducted the case review and presented his findings, which are detailed below. 

It was of Swanum's opinion that Officer Grivna "was facing a situation where a private citizen was in grave imminent danger of great bodily harm" during the Nov. 27, 2018 incident. 

Details of the hostage situation

The original 911 call was made by a woman at 5:01 p.m. who had run from her vehicle parked on the street in downtown Virginia when Widmark forced his way into the passenger seat and demanded she get out. 

The first officer arrived on scene at 5:07 p.m. to Widmark sitting in the woman's car, but then got out and pulled a large knife from his jacket and started walking towards him before running the opposite direction. 

The officer followed on foot as Widmark ran south on 3rd Avenue, then grabbing a man from behind who'd been walking in the same direction. Widmark placed the man in a headlock with his left arm and raised the large knife in his right hand. 

Follow Bring Me The News on Twitter for the latest story updates

More law enforcement arrived on scene, including Grivna, who was armed with a rifle. 

Repeated attempts to get Widmark to lower his weapon and let the hostage go were unanswered and Widmark continued to back away from officers, with Grivna deciding he was out of options.

"Officer Grivna believed that unless he ended the situation that [hostage] would be stabbed," Swanum's report notes. 

The bullet struck Widmark in the right hand and then in the right cheek. 

Approximately four minutes passed between the shot and the time EMTs arrived to treat Widmark, who later died from his injuries. 

"I have concluded that officer Grivna displayed superb training, courage, restraint, compassion, and professionalism and his actions were justified, lawful and therefore authorized under the law," said Rubin. 

"He probably saved an innocent citizen's life." 

Next Up


Gallery: Island cabin is one of northernmost homes for sale in MN

Want to buy one of the northernmost homes on the market in Minnesota?

Screen Shot 2022-09-30 at 4.54.42 PM

Charges: Houston men robbed Edina bank of $110,000

A third suspect has not yet been identified.

Arctic Monkeys

Arctic Monkeys coming to Minnesota for 2023 tour

The rock band hasn't gone on tour in the United States since 2019.

Flickr - Menards store front - Mike Kalasnik

Multiple charges over protests after fatal Menards forklift incident

The charges range from trespassing, destruction of property and assault.

Life Link

Boy airlifted after being struck by driver in Elk River

The boy is reportedly a student at Spectrum High School.

Woodbury mn

Fortune's Top 25 places to live for families includes Woodbury

The media outlet says it analyzed 215,000 data points for almost 2,000 cities and towns across the U.S.


Iconic Dangerfield's Restaurant sells, with buyer planning new concept

Dangerfield's Restaurant quietly sold recently after more than 30 years in business.

police lights squad car dark - Unsplash

Charges: Minneapolis shooter photographed 'lifeless' body before fleeing

Charges filed against an accomplice reveal new details about the death of Chante Williams.

Maple grove fire

5 youths are 'persons of interest' in Maple Grove greenhouse fire

Police say it's being investigated as a possible arson.

Dave Hutchinson

Dave Hutchinson has police license suspended for 30 days

The sheriff's suspension will begin on Nov. 22.


Mendota Heights bridge

Man shot dead by police after hostage situation on Mendota Bridge

The female victim wasn't seriously injured, police said.

1 dead in officer-involved shooting in Virginia, Minnesota

The suspect was shot and killed on Tuesday evening.

Bemidji police chief: Stop spreading rumors about deadly police shooting

A 34-year-old man was killed in the officer-involved shooting on Nov. 28.

Ronald Davis

Use of force 'justified' in fatal police shooting of Ronald Davis

The 31-year-old was holding a knife in his hand when he was shot dead.

1 dead in officer-involved shooting in Brooklyn Center

Police responded to a domestic disturbance call around 4:20 p.m. Saturday.

Chaos in Hubbard County: 3 dead, deputy shot during chase

The suspect and two victims were killed in the incident.