Skip to main content

State Supreme Court ruling due on priest sex law

  • Author:
  • Updated:

The Minnesota Supreme Court is expected to soon rule on the constitutionality of a state law that makes it a felony for clergy to engage in sexual conduct with a parishioner who seeks spiritual advice or comfort.

The high court in June heard oral arguments in the case, which focuses on the conduct of the Rev. Christopher Wenthe, a St. Paul priest, who was convicted in 2011 of third-degree criminal sexual conduct, under the state's clergy sexual conduct statute.

Rulings typically come within four or five months, the Star Tribune notes.

Wenthe's lawyers had argued that the statute violates the Constitution, which says, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion.” The priest formerly at Nativity of Our Lord Catholic Church had acknowledged a relationship with a 21-year-old woman over 18 months, and admitted to sexual conduct, but he denied it happened while she was seeking spiritual aid. His lawyers acknowledged that the relationship was forbidden by the church – but they said it was legal.

Wenthe had been sentenced to a year in the Ramsey County workhouse and was released early for good behavior, but he appealed the conviction. In November 2012, the Minnesota Court of Appeals overturned the conviction. (Here's the appeals court's ruling.) At that point, Wenthe and the Ramsey County attorney’s office asked the Supreme Court to rule on it.

The case would help set a course for other cases, including that of a Maplewood priest who is under scrutiny for an alleged affair this year with a married parishioner, the Star Tribune reports. He has not been charged.

The ruling is expected as the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis grapples with a number of accusations that the church did not appropriately handle allegations of sexual misconduct by its clergy.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-07-03 at 9.32.09 AM

6-year-old Northfield girl missing, mother dead of apparent suicide

Anyone who had seen the girl or her mother in the past two weeks should call Northfield police.

Pixabay - jet skis resting

Jet skier injured in explosion on Minnesota lake

The explosion happened on Little Lake 14 in St. Louis County.

Krisit Noem

Kristi Noem's response to 10-year-old Ohio girl pregnant after being raped

Abortion is illegal in South Dakota unless the mother's life is in danger.

police lights

Sheriff: Deputy shoots gun-wielding man in western Wisconsin

One deputy fired on the man, striking him in an unknown area of his body.

Screen Shot 2022-07-03 at 7.28.32 AM

Man found dead in 26 inches of water in Le Sueur County

The 45-year-old was found in near the shoreline on Lake Washington.

police lights

Man arrested after abduction attempt in Bemidji

The incident occurred in Cameron Park on June 25.

betty danger's

Betty Danger's in NE Minneapolis for sale for $4.2 million

The asking price includes the restaurant's ferris wheel, as well as a nearby single-family home.


Minnesota health officials warn monkeypox cases could grow rapidly

The state has so far confirmed only six cases of monkeypox virus.


Bodies of woman, three young children recovered from Vadnais Lake

Authorities say the bodies recovered were those of two boys, one girl and their mother.

Pixabay laptop keyboard phone dark

Charges: Duluth man had hundreds of child porn images, videos

The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children found nearly 330 images on the man's electronic devices.

hennepin county sheriff water patrol lake minnetonka

Scuba diver found dead in Lake Minnetonka identified as 20-year-old

The Hennepin County Medical Examiner's Office said 20-year-old Brady Alan Aune, from Elko New Market, died of freshwater drowning on June 3.


State Supreme Court rules that schools must report campaign spending

The Minnesota Supreme Court ruled Friday that school districts need to be more accountable in reporting campaign spending. The ruling stems from a 2010 complaint filed against the St. Louis County School District, which alleged district leaders and school board members violated state campaign laws by using public funds to promote the passage of a school building bond referendum -- and not reporting it to the state as campaign spending.

Diocese applauds Supreme Court's 'repressed memory' abuse case ruling

The Diocese of Winona said Thursday it is pleased that the Minnesota Supreme Court upheld a lower court's rejection of a claim by a Savage man that he was abused by member of the clergy in the 1980s. James Keenan lawsuit's against the Archdiocese of St. Paul-Minneapolis and the Diocese of Winona rested on his repressed memory claims of abuse by a priest who is now defrocked.