Skip to main content

Stolen Bible led police to men charged in beating death of 90-year-old, charges say

  • Author:
  • Updated:

Two men are charged in the robbery and fatal beating of an elderly Carver County man, who was found bound and beaten in his rural San Francisco Township farmhouse last month.

Reinol Godines Vergara (35, of Richfield) and Edson Celin Dominguez Benitez, (29, of St. Paul) were charged in Carver County District Court Wednesday in the death of 90-year-old Earl Olander.

Vergara is charged with two counts of second-degree murder, while Benitez is charged with two counts of aiding and abetting second-degree murder. They are both being held on $500,000 cash bail or $1.5 million bond following a bail hearing Wednesday, the Chaska Herald reports.

The two suspects were arrested Tuesday after the county sheriff's office got a tip from a citizen following weeks of officials asking for the public's help. A reward offered by Crime Stoppers of Minnesota started at $1,000 but had increased to $7,500 recently.

According to the criminal complaints:

A man who was cleaning out a recently vacated apartment in St. Paul discovered two $1,000 savings bonds issued to Earl Olander inside a Bible written in European language. He searched the Internet and found Olander had been killed, so he called police on May 9.

Police learned Benitez had previously lived in the apartment and when police questioned him, he admitted to possessing the stolen Bible.

Vergara had known Olander previously after painting his house and shed. He told police Olander would be an easy target because he lived alone and had money.

On April 9 or 10, the two men – who had their faces disguised with hoods – drove to Olander's house from the Twin Cities. They had a shotgun, duct tape and rope.

They parked in back of Olander's home and entered through the unlocked back door. Olander was asleep on the couch.

The two men covered his head with a blanket and attacked him. Olander fought back and was hit in the head with the shotgun, then hit in the face, head and body. They then held him down and duct taped his hands.

The two ransacked the home, taking coins, old silverware, two dollar bills, and a Bible written in European language, then fled, leaving a bound and bloodied Olander in the living room.

When police arrived at the home on April 11, they found Olander's body. The duct tape around his wrists was stretched, indicating he was trying to free himself, and the blood around his body was in an arch pattern, showing his body had moved back and forth.

Next Up

Sebastion Wolbersen-O’Hara

Police: 15-year-old missing from home north of Twin Cities

Authorities say he may be headed to the metro.


Foundation, the building, the win

Identifying Value Plus Catalysts helps your financial strategy and foundation

boating minnesota lake

25-year-old Hopkins man drowns after falling off boat

The man reportedly fell from the boat while fishing with friends.

mayor frey city minneapolis live stream march 14 2022

What's in Mayor Jacob Frey's budget proposal?

Here's a breakdown of what the Minneapolis mayor is focusing on in 2023-24.

Low, Mimi Parker

Low cancels Europe shows due to Mimi Parker's cancer treatment

The Duluth band says the decision follows 'recent changes' in Parker's treatment.

Screen Shot 2022-08-15 at 11.09.39 AM

Wisconsin man admits to 1992 revenge killings 15 years after boyhood tragedy

The 52-year-old man is in custody 30 years after the 1992 double murder.

Chapel of Love at Mall of America

Chapel of Love set to close at Mall of America after nearly 30 years

The owner cited retirement as the reason for the closure.

Minneapolis police

Man stabbed to death in his Minneapolis home identified

The victim's wife had an order of protection out against the suspect.