Substitute teacher accused of 'sextortion' of children, adult

The 25-year-old Carver man would pretend to be a young female to get his victims to send them nude photos, charges say.
Publish date:
mitchell ottinger

A 25-year-old substitute teacher is accused of "sextortion" involving teenage victims and child pornography. 

Mitchell James Ottinger, of Carver, was arrested Tuesday and charged with two counts of production and attempted production of child pornography and two counts of making extortionate threats, the U.S. Attorney's Office in Minnesota said Wednesday. He has a preliminary hearing at 2 p.m. on May 7 in U.S. District Court.

Charges say he posed as a girl and directed minors to send him nude photos and then extorted them unless the victims met his additional demands for more images. 

Ottinger worked as a substitute teacher and paraprofessional for "School District 1," the complaint says, noting an image investigators obtained from his email showed a badge for an elementary school. 

It's not clear where exactly he worked. U.S. Attorney spokesperson Tasha Zerna told the Star Tribune his place of employment hasn't been disclosed and may not be because he works with minors. 

According to the charging documents, Ottinger pretended to be a young female using the aliases "Taylor Malek" and "Rachel Meyer" with a romantic interest in the victims. He then lured at least two minors and one adult into sending sexually explicit images and videos of themselves to him. 

If one of his victims blocked or ignored him, Ottinger would contact the victim through the alias or other accounts and threaten to publish and/or share the images unless additional demands for nude photos were met, charges state.

Sign up: Subscribe to our BREAKING NEWS newsletters

Law enforcement learned of this when one of Ottinger's 15-year-old victims contacted the FBI's National Threat Operations Center in July 2020, charges state.

Investigators believe Ottinger has been catfishing and sextorting victims since at least 2012 and there may be more victims. Anyone with information is asked to call the FBI Minneapolis Division at 763-569-8000.

If convicted, Ottinger would face a mandatory minimum sentence of 15 years in prison, the U.S. Attorney's Office says. 

Next Up

milk bar cake crop

Famous Milk Bar bakery hosts pop-up in Twin Cities

The virtual event only lasts for a few days, with limited quantities available.

Flickr - police barricades dismantle uptown - Chad Davis

MN National Guard soldiers 'standing by' to respond in Minneapolis

Mayor Jacob Frey asked Gov. Tim Walz for National Guard support Wednesday.

tom burke

Charges: Wisconsin star, former NFL player sexually assaulted a child

The child told her mother about the assaults in February, charges say.

Screen Shot 2021-06-14 at 8.45.06 AM

Charges: Drunk driver accelerated 'to jump barricade' in crash that killed protester

Prosecutors say it was "an extreme and violent intentional act."

Screen Shot 2021-06-16 at 9.29.50 AM

Through little fault of its own, Minnesota BBQ joint goes viral

A picture of its ribs was enough to attract the attention of the culinary world.

Flickr - COVID vaccine Joint Base San Antonio

More than 3 million Minnesotans have had at least 1 vaccine dose

The milestone comes almost 6 months to the day since the first vaccine was given in the state.


juan luis rosales 1

Charges: Jordan man possessed and sent child porn images

He is charged with 14 felonies related to child pornography.

U.S. district court minnesota - federal court

Man, woman get decades in prison for producing child porn

They're accused of sexually abusing minors in order to take videos and photos of the abuse.

prison, jail

Plymouth man gets 12.5 years in prison for child porn charge

He would acquire and trade "diaper erotica" and other content involving kids.

Jail handcuffs arrest

Austin 'repeat offender' sentenced to 20 years in child porn case

Phillip Arlan Koontz, 53, pleaded guilty earlier this year.

Thomas Yoeun

Charges: St. Paul man shot victim who had changed mind about buying weed

The suspect allegedly attempted to rob them, but ended up shooting the victim twice, charges say.

Edina teacher on leave, accused of possessing child porn

Reports say he admitted accessing child porn "for several years."

Screen Shot 2020-05-29 at 6.42.54 AM

St. Paul man gets prison, ordered to pay $12M for burning of 3rd Police Precinct

He was among four Minnesota men charged in connection to the fires at the Third Precinct following George Floyd's murder.