Skip to main content

Substitute teacher accused of 'sextortion' of children, adult

The 25-year-old Carver man would pretend to be a young female to get his victims to send them nude photos, charges say.
mitchell ottinger

A 25-year-old substitute teacher is accused of "sextortion" involving teenage victims and child pornography. 

Mitchell James Ottinger, of Carver, was arrested Tuesday and charged with two counts of production and attempted production of child pornography and two counts of making extortionate threats, the U.S. Attorney's Office in Minnesota said Wednesday. He has a preliminary hearing at 2 p.m. on May 7 in U.S. District Court.

Charges say he posed as a girl and directed minors to send him nude photos and then extorted them unless the victims met his additional demands for more images. 

Ottinger worked as a substitute teacher and paraprofessional for "School District 1," the complaint says, noting an image investigators obtained from his email showed a badge for an elementary school. 

It's not clear where exactly he worked. U.S. Attorney spokesperson Tasha Zerna told the Star Tribune his place of employment hasn't been disclosed and may not be because he works with minors. 

According to the charging documents, Ottinger pretended to be a young female using the aliases "Taylor Malek" and "Rachel Meyer" with a romantic interest in the victims. He then lured at least two minors and one adult into sending sexually explicit images and videos of themselves to him. 

If one of his victims blocked or ignored him, Ottinger would contact the victim through the alias or other accounts and threaten to publish and/or share the images unless additional demands for nude photos were met, charges state.

Sign up: Subscribe to our BREAKING NEWS newsletters

Law enforcement learned of this when one of Ottinger's 15-year-old victims contacted the FBI's National Threat Operations Center in July 2020, charges state.

Investigators believe Ottinger has been catfishing and sextorting victims since at least 2012 and there may be more victims. Anyone with information is asked to call the FBI Minneapolis Division at 763-569-8000.

If convicted, Ottinger would face a mandatory minimum sentence of 15 years in prison, the U.S. Attorney's Office says. 

Next Up

Screen Shot 2023-01-31 at 9.18.37 PM

Bed, Bath & Beyond closing 86 more stores, including in Bloomington

The struggling chain closed a store in St. Cloud last year.

Andy Trowbridge

Tributes to KARE 11 sports producer who has died at age 35

KARE says Andrew Trowbridge died following a 'brief illness.'


Man pleads guilty to murder of Inver Grove Heights father

Michael Chang-Beom Lee, 43, was killed during a burglary at his home.

Eggs at Hy-Vee

Price comparison: How much do eggs cost at Twin Cities grocery stores?

Prices have been spiking, so where can you find the cheapest eggs?


FOX 9 promotes Hannah Flood to anchor, adds new reporter

Hannah Flood will co-anchor mornings while Se Kwon joins the team.

Carjacking pursuit in Little Canada

Watch: Suspects drive wrong-way on I-35E, before carjacking separate vehicles

The Ramsey County Sheriff's Office said the suspects are still at large.


St. Paul restaurant damaged in Sunday night fire

The fire department said the fire is considered to be "accidental."

Lake Superior.

MPCA: Minnesota's emissions fell by 23% between 2005 and 2020

Clean energy investments have driven the decline.

Dave Durenberger

Former U.S. Senator for Minnesota Dave Durenberger dies at 88

Durenberger served two terms before his disgraceful exit in the mid-1990s.


mitchell ottinger

Sub teacher involved in 'sextortion' of more than 10 minors pleads guilty

Some of the minors he knew from the school district where he worked.

Dylan Deling

Minnesota man sentenced for 'sextortion' of 40 girls

An FBI-led investigation led to the alarming discovery.

juan luis rosales 1

Charges: Jordan man possessed and sent child porn images

He is charged with 14 felonies related to child pornography.

u.s. attorney's office

Charges: Red Lake man with knife sexually assaulted victim

He's also charged with one count of assault with a dangerous weapon.

u.s. attorney's office

Man, woman get decades in prison for producing child porn

They're accused of sexually abusing minors in order to take videos and photos of the abuse.


Rochester man pleads guilty to producing child porn on Snapchat

He faces 60 other child porn charges in Olmsted County.

Stock market chart

Charges: 2 Minnesota men made thousands on 'pump-and-dump' scheme

They're accused of hijacking shell companies and pumping up stock prices before selling them for profit.